Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Welcome to the Vanguard Radio Show. I am your host, Terry Pavlik, editor-in-chief of Vanguard Magazine. We have an exciting show for you this week. 0:16 And now over to Nestor Arellano. Unless you've been living under a rock, you're likely well aware that cybersecurity and state-sponsored hacking are really major news topics these days. 0:30 One only needs to dial in on the social media chatter from the US about its intelligence community and their recent briefing on Russian hacking operations in the US for President-elect Donald Trump, and his strong reactions as well on what they had to say, to gauge how much cybersecurity has entered the public discussion. 0:56 Here in Canada, we just found out that our government systems are not as secure as we would want to believe them to be. Check out the Vanguard article, Government Computer Networks Can't Stand Up to Cyberattacks. 1:13 Documents from Public Safety Canada indicate that the country is a prime target for cybercrime, state-sponsored cyberattacks, and lone wolf-type hackers. 1:25 Consulting firm PricewaterhouseCooper prepared for the Federal Public Safety and Emergency Organization 1:33 a report which revealed that Canada's federal information technology system are ill-equipped to handle potential cyberattacks. 1:43 Well, today we have with us French Caldwell, Chief Evangelist of governance, risk, and compliance company MetricStream. 1:52 He's here to discuss with us what this could mean to the government and the military and defense establishments, as well as companies doing business with them. Hello, French, and welcome to our show. 2:07 Well, thank you, Nestor. And, um, yeah, I, I saw the report and, you know, it, it's interesting. 2:14 Um, you know, Public Safety Canada certainly has responsibility directly for, uh, federal, um, cybersecurity, and then indirectly for helping, uh, you know, pr- provinces and, uh, local, uh, government agencies, and then also in providing some guidance, uh, for the private sector. 2:37 So it's a big responsibility for Public Safety Canada. Yes. Perhaps, uh, for the benefit of our, uh, listeners out there, could you... 2:45 Um, I found out that you've done some, uh, some work for the US government, uh, for, for the military. Could you finally, kindly, uh, give us a brief, um, background of, uh, your, your career? Yeah, certainly. 3:00 Uh, you know, I'm a retired nuclear submariner, and as a matter of fact, I wrote a book once, uh, called Arctic Leverage: Canadian Sovereignty and Security, uh, that focused on, uh, the reasons that Canada was looking at improving its, uh, submarine program back in the early 1990s. 3:18 And, uh, so I do have a Canadian link there. 3:20 But with the US federal government, uh, I, uh, helped run a war game back in 2002 called Digital Pearl Harbor, working with the White House and the US Naval War College, trying to determine if it were possible to launch a strategic cyberattack on North America. 3:43 And, um, well, uh, with the help of 120 experts, uh, we did find that, yes, in that war game, it was possible to design such an attack. So what do you make of this, uh, report now? 3:58 Uh, um, the report that says that, um, government, um, systems are simply not up to the challenge of, uh, facing up to, uh, cyberattacks. 4:10 Well, I think, you know, government has, uh, certainly tried over the years to ensure that they're putting in place the right security controls. 4:19 And of course, Canada and the US have worked closely together in establishing cybersecurity standards for government. 4:27 Uh, but it's always a game that, um, you know, the, the offense has tremendous advantages, uh, over the defense. 4:36 Because no matter how many defensive measures that you put in place and preventative measures, uh, that you put in place, it takes only one successful hack, uh, to, uh, get access often to very sensitive information. 4:53 And, and the threats are both insider threat, uh, and threats from outside hackers, and outside hackers can be nation states, uh, or they can be cyber criminals. So it is a very, very tough game to play. Mm-hmm. 5:10 Well, our, our government is in the midst of reviewing its, uh, cybersecurity policies and, uh, practices. Um, 5:19 for, for somebody in, in your, with your background, uh, what would you think would be the, um, the items or the issues that they would, would be looking at right now? 5:32 Well, I, I think we have to have a whole new look at cyber strategy, period. 5:36 Um, one thing that I don't think that we have ever come to grips with, uh, is that if you look at today's world, uh, Canadian GDP is 100% dependent on digital technology. 5:54 There is no industry where the business models, uh, the business processes are not dependent on in- um, on, uh, on some form of information technology and using digital technology to get our markets and our services out to customers all around the world. 6:12 So when we, um, think in those terms, it maybe becomes a little bit of a look at more about what are our actual cyber national interests. 6:25 And what are the national interests that are, you know, from a cyberspace perspective, uh, that Canada has? 6:32 And then not only how do you protect cyberspace for government agencies and for, a- and for, uh, and work with the private sector, but also how do you promote, uh, the cyber interests of Canada around the world, 6:48 you know? It, it's something we think about when we think in terms of maritime strategy. We think about it in terms of commercial strategy, diplomatic strategy. Uh, we think in those terms. 6:59 When, when it comes to cyber strategy, we've been all about defense, defense, defense, and no one's out there playing offense- Hmm... except for the bad guys. Yeah. Um, interesting, um, uh, outlook there. 7:11 Uh, and you mentioned about offense. How would this play out or how would this impact the military and defense establishment? 7:22 Well, I think the military and defense establishment are primarily always gonna continue to play defense. I mean, Canada's a peaceful country, uh, and, and a NATO ally. 7:32 Uh, and NATO itself is investing quite a bit in, uh, cybersecurity and cybersecurity strength. 7:39 Uh, and but there is also an active offensive, uh, counterpart, uh, as we've seen in recent years as militaries and NATO have begun to develop their own cyber commands and, and cyber war strategies. 7:53 So I do think that, uh, we do... You know, the, we need more clarity in role. If you go and take a look at the cybersecurity strategies, 8:05 it is often very unclear as to what agency is in charge of what, who is responsible for what. And there's also, with cyber, there's this blending between, um, you know, the, the, the private sector and the public sector. 8:22 If you look at critical infrastructure, critical infrastructure, most of it is probably out in the, out in the private sector. 8:28 And if it's not in the private sector, a lot of it's owned by, um, you know, by local municipalities. Mm-hmm. So there's, you know, what role does the military play in protecting critical infrastructure? Mm-hmm. 8:42 That's a hard one to ask because then you're asking the military to take on a domestic role, which, uh, in our system is not a common thing for them to do. Hmm. 8:53 Yeah, because i- if we look at the developments that we see in the media, um, terrorist groups are actively using social media to undermine, um, their opponents or, or, or Western states. 9:08 There are scores of, um, government-sponsored or state-sponsored actors trying to, um, and in many instances, successfully breaching Canadian and US, uh, computer networks. 9:25 Uh, the debate about proactively acting against the- these actors ha- has been going on. Well, you know, hopefully, um, you know, Canadian and, uh, US and, uh, other NATO, 9:39 uh, allies, uh, have resources that are, uh, proactively engaging in and penetrating the networks of other, uh, you know, of our, of our opponents as well. 9:52 But, you know, that's an interesting thing, though, because when you look at this, this is like a cyber war that's occurring. 10:00 It's not like, not as if, you know, uh, you know, we're all standing back, uh, waiting and, and it's not like in the Cold War where we never actually physically engaged with the, uh, with the enemy. 10:13 But we're actually engaged, uh, in this cyber war on a day in and day out basis, and the other side is playing, playing very, very hard. You- you've seen all the, uh, press around the Chinese and the Russian, uh, hacks. 10:29 Uh, you know, it's, they are playing, playing very, very hard. And another thing too is I'm starting, we're starting to see the private sector play hard. Mm-hmm. 10:39 When Sony got hacked, as far as I know of, that may be the first public, uh, announcement, uh, that there was actually a hack back. In other words, Sony attacked back. 10:54 Now, they didn't go directly and find and, and do something to hack the, um, you know, the North Korean government. 11:01 Uh, but what they did do is they went and hacked and attacked the, uh, servers where a lot of Sony intellectual property movies had been put. 11:13 And, and they so that, so that those servers could not be used to share these, uh, illegal copies of, uh, of Sony's, uh, intellectual property. 11:24 So that's the first time I know of, of a direct hack back by a private sector entity. Now, a lot of these servers were in China. 11:34 So here's a private sector company doing an attack on a physical asset in the treasury of a foreign government. 11:42 This, uh, incident that you were talking about, uh, French, this was a little more than just, uh, two years ago, right? Yeah. I mean, it was the North Korean attack on, uh, Sony. Mm-hmm. 11:53 Um, yeah, I think it was a little over a year, a little over a year ago. A little over a year ago. Somewhere around... Yeah, November or December of 2015. 12:01 Do you see something like this escalating as sort of a tit for tat, uh, cyber warfare as you were talking about, not just involving countries, but private, the private sector? Uh, you could. I mean, you could. 12:15 I mean, it's a possibility. So i- it's very interesting. 12:19 I think, uh, some companies probably feel like they have to have their own capabilities to, you know, to take, uh, you know, take charge and protect their intellectual property. 12:29 Now, on the other hand, the government has actually been very proactive at notifying companies when they've been hacked. Mm-hmm. Right? 12:36 So no- notifying companies and also notifying other government agencies, uh, when they've been hacked. 12:42 So quite often, you know, the FBI or, or other organizations like that, um, you know, law enforcement organizations in, uh, Canada will be the ones to notify private sector companies that they have evidence that they've been hacked. 12:57 So there's, there's definitely this cooperation that is developing between government and the private sector. Uh, but there's still not a lot of clarity on roles and missions. 13:09 You know, what is the role of the military, particularly when it comes to the protection of private company assets? Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. 13:16 Uh, what is, you know, the role of, uh, say, Public Safety Canada or, or, uh, Department of Homeland Se- Homeland Security in the US, uh, in collaborating and, and encouraging information sharing with the private sector? 13:30 Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. What is the role diplomatically around cybersecurity? 13:34 What should, um, you know, foreign affairs and the US Department of State be doing, uh, working with other allies diplomatically to, uh, encourage more effective cybersecurity strategies? 13:48 And all of these different roles and missions need to be clearly laid out at a national strategic level. And, and right now, so far we've been playing sort of a, a game of bottom up, everyone protect their own. 14:02 Protect your own stuff. And we're seeing that we're losing that game. You know, the cyber criminals collaborate. You know, the people on the other side collaborate. 14:13 They, they share tools and techniques, uh, amongst each other, even have auction sites where you can buy different exploits. We're not effectively collaborating on the, um, on our side, on the good guy side, you know? 14:28 Yeah. And, and lack of clarity on roles and missions, I think, is necessary, uh, in order to lay the groundwork to ensure effective collaboration. Mm-hmm. 14:39 Now, here and in the US, there's a lot of, uh, companies, uh, doing business with, with the government. 14:46 Um, n- not just, uh, service companies, but also, uh, a lot of technology companies, a lot of, uh, firms there, uh, s- providing products and services to the Defense Department. Uh, what would you say- Right... should... 15:03 What sort of guidance could you provide them in order to better protect their, their data and their intellectual property as well as the government's networks? 15:14 Because their companies, uh, will conceivably be, you know, uh, interoperating with, with the government's, um, uh, computer system. 15:26 Well, you know, whenever you bring in a third party, um, you in- you know, you're, you're exposing yourself to all the risk of that, of that third party. So that third party's systems need to be robust. 15:40 Um, they need to have effective security. Uh, their employees need to be reliable. 15:46 And we've seen, uh, you know, here in a couple of cases where, uh, unreliable employees, uh, in the US have totally undermined the National Security Agency. So this is, um, you know, this is, this is a real... 16:02 It's a real threat. Now, it's a threat, of course, with the agency's own employees. But also when you begin to expand the boundaries 16:11 to third parties, uh, you're, you are exposed to all the risks that those third parties are exposed to. So you're increasing your risk profile unless you have very effective third-party risk management. 16:25 That applies to the government, and it applies to the private sector entities as well. 16:30 We've seen a lot of cases where financial services organizations have begun to, uh, impose very, very rigorous requirements on third parties for, uh, security and privacy and data protection. Mm-hmm. 16:43 So I think the government needs to ta- take a close look as, as at its ability to impose, um, these, uh, rigorous standards on the, on the third parties and business partners that it works with. Wonderful. 16:58 Um, we'll have to leave it at that, French, but, uh, thank you very much for your insights. Um, wonderful, wonderful, um, uh, points that you put out there and presented. Well, thanks, Nestor. 17:10 It's good talking to you, and I look forward to, um, maybe joining some of your other podcasts in the future. Will do. Will do, definitely. Thank you very much. [outro music] That's it for this edition of our podcast. 17:26 We hope you enjoyed and found a lot of useful information from our interview with French Caldwell. This is your host, Nestor Aureliano, saying see you again next week on the next episode of Vanguard Radio. 17:41 [outro music]