Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Welcome back to Vanguard Radio. I'm your host, J. Richard Jones. Today, we're gonna talk about bringing shipbuilding back to Ontario. 0:17 It's a pretty big industry. There's a lot going on in the area of building, repair, and construction, and our guest today is, uh, quite qualified to talk about that. 0:28 Uh, we're gonna be meeting with a representative from Heddle Shipyards, which is the largest Canadian ship repair and construction company on the Great Lakes. Uh, they're operating shipyards in, uh, St. 0:41 Catharines, Hamilton, and Thunder Bay, and they're a wholly owned Canadian company. So, uh, Heddle has been doing this since 1987. 0:50 We're gonna learn a little bit more about, um, some of the vessel life cycles, and here to tell us about it is Ted Kirkpatrick. He's the Director of Business Development and Government Relations with Heddle Shipyards. 1:03 Ted, welcome to the show. Good morning. Thanks for having me. Yeah. 1:07 It's, it's great to have you, and I'm looking forward to what, uh, what we're gonna talk about, 'cause a lot has changed, and shipbuilding is back in Ontario. So why don't we begin with this? 1:16 Like, what, what is the state of shipbuilding in Ontario? Well, I would say it's, it's not quite back yet. I mean, I think that Ontario was once one of, if not the epicenter of, of shipbuilding in Canada. 1:30 Um, you look at shipyards like the Port Weller Dry Docks and the Thunder Bay Shipyard that, that we operate now. Uh, the Port Weller Dry Docks built 1:40 over 80 vessels, both commercial and, uh, government, uh, over its history, and the Thunder Bay Shipyard, um, which was started in 19- or the early 1900s, built ships for both World War I and, and World War II. Um, 1:57 that has certainly fallen off in the last couple of decades. There's a variety of reasons for that. 2:04 Um, so what we've done as an organization, or what we're doing as an organization, and I think there's tremendous opportunity to, to do so, um, is to bring real meaningful shipbuilding work back, back to Ontario, um, most notably in support of the National Shipbuilding Strategy. 2:22 That's pretty interesting. I would imagine there are opportunities, um, and ha- I, I would think technology has, uh, greatly improved the efficiencies, but, um, maybe you can comment on that. 2:35 And then what are some of the challenges now that you're... we're, we're seeing an increase for, for ships? Well, I think, I mean, I think the challenge is, is that... So I guess it's probably worth just 2:48 having a little history of 2:50 the shipbuilding industry in Ontario and, and that, like I said, the, the Port Weller Dry Docks and the Thunder Bay Shipyard, I mean, were, were huge employers, over 2,000 people each yard, uh, and built many, many vessels over a long period of time. 3:06 In 2015, the Port Weller Dry Docks went insolvent for, for the last time and, and were taken over by, um, the St. 3:14 Lawrence Seaway Management Corporation, and the Thunder Bay Shipyard kind of went through a similar cycle where, where it went insolvent. 3:19 Um, in 2016, um, Heddle Shipyards purchased the, the, the Thunder Bay Shipyard, and then in 20, um, 17, we took over operation of the Port Weller Dry Docks. 3:32 Both those facilities were effectively mothballed, uh, at that time. And so what we've been doing over the last five years, and, and it's mainly through the, 3:42 the refit work that we've been able to secure, a lot of that coming from, through the Canadian Coast Guard, we've been able to invest in the people and, and technology and equipment to bring those yards to re- you know, to revitalize, 3:57 uh, what was effectively a dormant or mostly dormant shipbuilding industry in Ontario. I should caveat that by saying that there are some small shipbuilders that do great work in Ontario. 4:06 There's Pike Metals that builds boats for the Canadian Coast Guard. There's Metalcraft in Kingston that, that, the- they, they build, uh, tremendous small aluminum boats. 4:16 But in terms of building larger vessels for the Canadian Coast Guard, Ontario hasn't ve- really been engaged in that, at least to the, to the extent that the other shipyards, the other major shipyards across the country have been. 4:30 Uh, and that's what, that's kind of what we've been doing as an organization, is to bring these facilities back online, and, and, and we recognize that there is a tremendous oppor- There's still a lot of vessels that do need to be built, um, under the National Shipbuilding Strategy, and we feel that Ontario has a l- a lot of excess shipyard capacity to, to add to that and to support that. 4:54 So we've got the space, and we're creating jobs. I'd be curious, Ted, how did, how did COVID affect this industry? Um, or, or did it have an effect at all? 5:04 'Cause it sounds like we're just kinda starting to really ramp up now. Uh, I think it had, it did, it definitely had an effect. I think we were fortunate in the sense that, um, 5:14 because we do so much work for the Canadian government and the Canadian Coast Guard, um, we were, w- we remained... One, we were declared an essential service, so we were able to operate more or less as, 5:28 uh, as normal during, during that whole time. Um, and the reality was, is that the, the work, the, the work that we do is critical work to keeping, 5:38 uh, Canadian government vessels and Canadian commercial vessels in service. Um, so we were able to, to kinda 5:47 transition through that whole phase, um, relatively uninterrupted, albeit, I mean, we still faced supply chain issues and, and things like that that everybody did. 5:57 Yeah, no, that, that, that was a difficulty, um- That was a very tough and, and tragic thing to go through. 6:04 But that said, there was also a lot of innovation that happened as a r- a result, um, which leads me around to the technologies and efficiencies. Has, has it changed that much in the last five years? 6:15 Is there any specific areas of technology that are really contributing to your efficiencies? There are, I think, and, and I think this is n- not just 6:27 true for the shipbuilding industry, but, uh, automation and, and, and different, different things like that, that, that we can, that we have been implementing and, and putting into the shipyard. Um, 6:40 those have been things that are helping improve efficiencies. 6:44 What's really interesting now is, is, you know, starting to, to see what, what opportunities are out there on the, in the AI space and, and how that can improve things. 6:53 So, uh, it's definitely an exciting time from a technology standpoint. So in terms of growth, um, what is the province doing to really support... 7:03 Like, this is staple, this is a staple business, it's great, it's creating jobs. W- how, what kind of support are you getting for this? 7:09 So the Ontario, the Ontario government has been, has been very supportive, which we've been very thankful for, and we've been, we've been able to secure some funding for skills development and, and training and things like that that's allowed us to, to, to train new people and upskill existing people. 7:25 Um, there's certain legislative initiatives that we're working on with Ontario that, um, that are progressing, and we're thankful for that. 7:34 And I think the biggest thing is that we've been able to highlight the opportunity that the National Shipbuilding Strategy represents for Ontario. 7:43 I think what people f- forget is that Ontario is very much a maritime, is very much a maritime region. 7:50 I know that kind of sounds funny because we're not cl- anywhere close to, you know, our oceans, um, and, and we don't have, you know, the culture of, um, Newfoundland or Nova Scotia that are, you know, tr- traditional maritime communities or regions. 8:07 But the reality is, is that, um, you know, Hamilton Harbor, where, where I'm located today, is, is the, the busiest Canadian commercial port on the Great Lakes. Um, the Welland Canal, which, which runs through St. 8:19 Catharines, which is where our Port Weller Dry Docks facility is, uh, that's one of the busiest commercial waterways in North America. Uh, and billions and billions of dollars tr- of trade go through there. 8:31 Some of the largest Canadian flag shipping companies are headquartered in St. Catharines or, or close to, uh, in St. Catharines or Burlington, which is close to Hamilton. 8:43 Um, and so much of our economy is driven by trade that comes by water and, and then also obviously then there's the whole system that supports those navigation routes, i.e., the Coast Guard and, um, you know, and, and all of that. 9:00 And I think that, that, that kinda has gotten lost, especially when facilities like the Port Weller Dry Docks kinda went away and all those jobs went away, you know, a c- a couple decades ago. 9:12 Um, and what we've been doing and what we-- and where Ontario has been really a, a fantastic partner is, is they've, they've recognized that there is a huge opportunity, 9:25 that we are a maritime region first and foremost, and that under the National Shipbuilding Strategy, there's still a significant opportunity 9:34 to, to build a shipbuilding industry in Ontario or revi- revitalize a shipbuilding industry in Ontario. Um, and they've kinda jumped, jumped in, uh, with both feet, uh, to help us forward that. 9:48 So I think we're on a good path, but we, there's still a lot of work to do, um, to make sure that we can, that we can secure shipbuilding work for Ontario shipyards. 10:00 And I think, um, the industry is, is forecasting a pretty significant increase. Is that correct? Yeah, and specifically in the, in the second pillar of the National Shipbuilding Strategy. 10:10 So obviously all of your listeners will be familiar with the National Shipbuilding Strategy in that it's, it's divided into the s- you know, three pillars: the large vessel, the large vessel construction, then the small, medium vessel construction, the pillar two, uh, and then the Vessel Life Extension Program. 10:26 And obviously the, you know, under the, the pillar one, all of the large vessels have been allocated to the, to the three big shipyards. Um, but under that in the pillar two, um, the pillar two category, there's 10:44 40-plus vessels that, that the Canadian Navy and the Canadian Coast Guard are gonna get, need over the next 20 years, uh, that have not been allocated to any shipyards. 10:53 And, and as, um, like I said before, the, the capacity that we, that we can bring to bear and as kinda Canada's probably biggest small shipyard, um, we f- and we feel that, 11:07 that we're in a very, uh, strong spot, not just to secure the work, but, but to add the capacity that Canada, uh, needs to be able to get all of those additional vessels in the water in the next, um, um, you know, over the next c- and over the coming decades. 11:23 So from Heddles' perspective, you guys are ready and have a good plan to handle the increase in shipbuilding. 11:30 But I'd be curious to ask you in terms of, um, local supply chain support, ha- have you been affected at all in that? What, how does that look? What do you forecast for that? 11:40 Yeah, no, that's a great question because I think that's one of the things that actually makes Ontario a, a really, um, attractive partner in terms of increased shipbuilding work. 11:53 Um, I mean, where I am today, Hamilton, this is Steel Town. This is, this is the industrial heartland of, uh, for sure Ontario and if not, Canada. Um- 12:04 So there's a, the, the local supply chain in terms of industrial manufacturing is, is probably second to, is second to none anyw- anywhere in Canada. Um, and we're really fortunate in that sense. 12:15 I'll give you a great example. I mean, we've built vessels in Hamilton where we have, you know, every piece of steel comes to the shipyard cut and bent and ready, and, and ready to weld. 12:27 The reason that we do that is there's companies that are 10 minutes down the road from us that, that that's what they do, and that's what they do well, right? So we've been able to leverage 12:38 the industrial capacity that's around, uh, that's, uh, in Southern Ontario to support the activities that we're doing in the shipyard. Um, and we feel that that's a strength that we can carry forward as, as we bank, um, 12:53 as we move towards increased shipbuilding work in Ontario, um, we're gonna be leveraging the local supply chain that we have, and we're very fortunate that we have a very robust one, uh, at our disposal. 13:04 You know, I'm curious, when, when I hear about the shipbuilding industry, um, a lot of time they talk about these cycles of boom and bust, uh, within shipbuilding and ship repair. 13:14 Do you think that's starting to flatline now? Uh, I think it is, uh, in, in certain aspects, certainly for the ma- the big, the, the, the major shipyards. Uh, w- we have not... We still deal with that in, in Ontario. 13:29 Uh, we're still very much, um, cyclical in, in, in the work that we get, um, which does create challenges obviously, in terms of retaining people and, and, and planning for investments and things like that. 13:45 So we are still kind of trapped in that cycle, which is why, you know, shipbuilding and bringing shipbuilding back to Ontario is, is, is such an important piece because that's what will alleviate that cyclicality. 13:58 And I've said this before to, to many people. I mean, really what we're looking at in Ontario is a generational multi, you know, billion-dollar economic opportunity for people to 14:09 secure long-term employment that, that is, you know, these are careers that, that you can start a family and, and buy a house with. 14:18 Um, and that's probably one of the reasons why we've been successful in kind of getting the Ontario government to, 14:25 to, to really start, um, supporting us and advocate for us, is because there's a huge economic opportunity, um, for the communities in which we operate. 14:35 And so when you look at the build programs that we're looking at, whether it be MSMM or the vigilance g- uh, the vigilance program that we've, that, uh, Hedlos partner with, with Vard and Thales and SH Defense and Fincantieri, I mean, these are, these are long-term, um, 14:54 build programs that would sustain hundreds and hundreds of jobs over, um, years and decades. 15:02 Um, and I know, again, your listeners are obviously very familiar with the National Shipbuilding Strategy, and it's, and it's the same for all the, uh, for Seaspan and Irving and Davie. Um, 15:15 they're b- they're able to create that long-term employment that's consistent, it's predictable, and people can plan their l- their lives around. Um, and that's what we're trying to bring to, to Ontario. 15:26 Ted, I'd like to touch upon the Team Vigilance program. Can you talk about that a little bit? Yeah, absolutely. Thanks. It's, um, yeah, it's a very exciting, uh, it's a very exciting initiative. 15:38 So we've, we've partnered with, uh, with Vard and, um, Thales, two really great Canadian companies, as well as, uh, SH Defense and, and Fincantieri to, 15:49 to essentially build an unsolicited proposal for the Vigilance class OPV, uh, as a replacement for the Kingston-class vessels. 15:57 Uh, I spoke earlier about the pillar two of the National Shipbuilding Strategy and, and, and under that, the, the pillar two, probably the biggest package or the biggest, um, 16:09 run of vessels, uh, will be the replacement of the Kingston class. Um, and Vard has, has done some really great work in terms of, uh, trying to identify what we think that the Canadian Navy's gonna need. 16:22 And there's lots of work to do and, and we look forward to working with the Canadian Navy and the Canadian government to define what all that looks like. 16:28 Um, but from a shipbuilding perspective, it's really exciting 'cause, like I said, I talked with before about trying to secure shipbuilding work for Ontario and reducing the, the, the boom and bust cycle. 16:39 With these partner companies, we feel, one, we have a very strong group, um, that we, that, that can support each other. We have the shipyards in Ontario that have the, the capacity to do this. 16:52 And, and with partners like Fincantieri, there's a real opportunity for transfer of knowledge and transfer of technology, um, where we can train people and leverage what is a global shipbuilding giant, Fincantieri, 17:07 um, and learn from them, and be able to build our yards and train our people in a way. 17:13 W- I, I guess what I'm trying to say is it's not like we have to reinvent the wheel because we can lean on the strength of our, of our partners. 17:20 And just in terms of, um, job numbers and the economic opportunity that, that, that program would, uh, would generate, uh, just goes to what I was speaking about earlier in terms of a, a generational opportunity to create wealth and jobs and, and, and, um, in Ontario and in Ontario shipyards. 17:40 So we're really excited. Obviously, there's a lot of work to do, but we feel we have, we have the right group. Um, 17:46 and we certainly feel that, uh, we have the capacity and the capability to, to execute on the, on the Vigilance program. 17:54 You've been listening to Vanguard Radio, and we're having a really interesting discussion this morning with Ted Kirkpatrick, Director of Business Development and Government Relations for Heddel Shipyards. 18:05 We've touched upon, um, the logistics and, uh, the fact that shipbuilding is back in Ontario, what some of the challenges are, and what some of the opportunities are, and they are big. It's certainly been an education. 18:19 Ted, I want to thank you very much for joining us this morning. Yeah, it's been great. I've been really happy to, to talk to you, and I guess what I'll, I'll... If, if I may just say one last thing. Um, shipbuilding is 18:33 back, but there is lots more to do, and the, and the opportunities that are, that are out there, um, are significant. 18:41 But there's still a lot of work to do, again, to kind of alleviate the boom and bust cycle that, that we're still, that we're still faced with here in Ontario. Yeah, definitely. 18:50 And, uh, we look forward to your success, and I hope you'll come back on and, and, and report back to us. I'd be happy to do so. 18:59 [outro music] The views, information or opinions expressed during the Vanguard Weekly Podcast Series, CGE Weekly Podcast Series, Vanguard Radio Podcast, and CGE Radio Podcast are solely those of the individuals involved and do not represent those of Vanguard or any affiliated media products, their employees or owners. 19:24 Vanguard Magazine, Canadian Government Executive Magazine, and its affiliates are not responsible for and do not verify for accuracy any of the information contained in this podcast series. 19:35 This podcast may not be copied or distributed without express written approval of Promotive Communications Inc, PCI. You may not edit, modify or redistribute this podcast without consent from PCI. 19:46 PCI assumes no liability for activities in connection with this podcast or for use of this podcast with any other website, computer or playing device.