Transcript 0:04 Welcome back to another episode of Vanguard Radio. Today we're gonna have a special emphasis on COVID-19. 0:12 We're gonna talk a little bit about, uh, double-layer security, gray zones, and, um, the effects of potential security attacks during a crisis. Joining us today is Valerie Finley, and she's speaking with us from home. 0:28 She is research fellow, National Police Foundation, American Society for Evidence-Based Policing. She has a master's in sociology as well as a master's in terrorism study. Valerie, welcome to Vanguard Radio. 0:45 Thanks, John. I'm pleased to be here. Valerie, to begin, you've got some very interesting credentials. For the benefit of our listenership and readership, could you tell us a little bit more about your background? 0:56 Yeah, for sure. Um, so I have about 20 years experience in, uh, cyber and in national intelligence in, uh, the U.S., uh, U.S. and Canada. 1:06 Um, I started in IT security, so that was long before cyber was ever coined a term, and have worked, um, primarily in government, but have also worked in, uh, private sector and various partnerships internationally. 1:21 So where do we start? I guess from my side, what exactly is double layer vulnerability? So I guess it requires a fairly broad discussion. 1:30 So I guess the best place to start is to talk about sort of how we, how we view security in general. So whether, and I'm gonna talk about it sort of domain agnostically. 1:40 We've always looked at, um, security in general through particular domains, their assets, their vulnerabilities, and then the threats that could be exacted upon them. Now what we're seeing is, um, more of a view. 1:56 I don't know how much of this has been operationalized, but, um, looking at security and its planning and assessments more from dynamic state as opposed to threats and actors. 2:05 So we're looking at the, the states of impact, um, when we have a particular crisis or a threat. 2:14 So if we look at COVID-19, one of the important things to recognize about COVID being a pandemic, um, and, and this would apply to an epidemic as well if it were just here in Canada, is that there's a number of systems that are impacted. 2:28 So there's the physical wellbeing and psychological of the population. There's the social, right? So how we move about, how we behave. Actually, if you look at, uh, 9/11, it's a really good example. 2:38 So, um, 9/11, although that was a terrorist activity, that had a very deep impact on how people behaved, what they did, what their normal habitus was, and that had a cascade effect across a number of different sectors, like if we look at the airline sector in particular. 2:54 Also, there's economic, political. There's social services and support, and then there's national security in all these areas of impacts when we have a major national crisis like we have right now. 3:06 So basically in times of crisis, there are a lot of areas of potential exposure. Yes, and I think when, when we've gone through security assessments before and security planning exercises, we look at specific threats. 3:21 And when we think about threats, we think about malicious and non-malicious. 3:25 So we can have malicious where it's a state actor or a particular nation or adversary that's attacked one of our systems, and that could be, um, that could be a, a utility system. 3:36 It could be, uh, data or information related to national security. So it could, it could be multiple domains. And when we look at something like a pandemic, that's obviously non-malicious. It, it is, we presume. 3:49 Um, it's, it's come out, um, of, um, a situation that was geographically distanced from us. And once it's arrived here in Canada, we're starting to see how the impacts are cascading as we would expect to a state. 4:05 So we're looking at the state of the nation today, the state of how things are in Canada, and what we're seeing is obviously we went through a period of, um, you know, people were, uh, you know, obviously very panicked and very scared. 4:17 So we saw, um, you know, people doing a lot of buying. They put, um, an enormous amount of stress on our supply systems. 4:25 And then we start seeing the, the, you know, the, the questions around what this pandemic actually is, what it means with very limited information because it is a new virus, and what that means to employment and what that means to our government services in shoring up, um, the, the income and revenues that are not gonna be afforded to our businesses and to our, to our, uh, citizens. 4:48 So as these things roll out, we start to see, you know, we start at, at the top of a pyramid of one thing happening and a number of things, um, being impacted as we go along. 5:00 What that creates is, um, a broader state of vulnerability. And the reason I bring that up is one of the hot topics in, uh, Canada and the US in military has been gray zone. 5:11 So gray zone tactics or hybrid warfare are meant to create, um, um, a vulnerability or a vulnerable state where democracy can be attacked. 5:23 What we're seeing right now is we're almost in an artificial state, um, or an artificial gray zone where we're left even more vulnerable. 5:30 So it becomes even more important to have, going back to what you were asking about, this, you know, double layer security. It's really more multi-spectral. 5:38 So you're looking at, um, one particular problem and all the problems that problem can beget, and then all the solutions that are required to shore up each of those individual problems so that you can 5:51 restore, um, um, a state of, um, normalcy or normal operations in a situation where you, you're in a crisis. Valerie, what, what exactly are gray zones? 6:08 So gray zones, um, so it's actually known as, um, you know, gray zone tactics, or sometimes it's referred to as hybrid warfare, or, or sometimes gray zone warfare for that matter. 6:19 So what gray zone actions are, so these would be actions that, um, adversaries, so, and this is very broad, so other nations, um, or nation sympathizers or disruptors would use that are below the threshold of actual warfare, so what we consider to be traditional warfare. 6:40 So the, it's like the non-military means to achieve whatever their geopolitical objectives may be. 6:48 So gray zone actions might include things like, um, election meddling, um, economic coercion, the ambiguous use of unconventional forces, um, and these adversaries, when, when they're utilizing these actions, they use all tools at their disposal. 7:07 So they, they will use things like sanctions, um, misinformation, cultural, religion, or technology avenues, um, and all of this is meant, all of these actions are meant to erode a nation's, um, democracy. 7:22 So these objectives or the agenda by the adversary essentially targets these national assets or economy or politics by utilizing those tools to attack the stability of a nation overall. 7:37 So they're very, um, they're very coercive, um, very covert, very hard to detect, very hard to prevent, um, and also very hard to control. Social media obviously has a, has a huge play in that. 7:49 So, um, these narratives and, and how we perceive them and how our governments and militaries, uh, respond to them become really important in maintaining our democracy, um, as well as the overall stability of a nation. 8:04 The situation that we're in currently with the crisis leaves us somewhat more susceptible to, um, these types of gray zone actions because we're, we're already essentially in a state of vulnerability. 8:16 So to what effect, um, do we have a very good, um, eye on our, um, ability to manage additional threats should we have one when we're already in a state of crisis? 8:31 Valerie, can you talk a little bit about prevention, detection, response, and recovery strategies? What does it mean? What does it do, and how does it help assist in a situation like this? Um, sure. 8:45 So, um, there, essentially we look at, um, security assessments, uh, of any domain, um, in these four ca-categories. So there, there are four phases related to an incident. 8:58 So there's prevention, detection, response, recovery. 9:01 So prevention is, um, essentially all of the things that you have in place that would prevent whatever threats you've identified against whatever particular assets you're trying to protect. 9:13 Now, ideally, you do this, um, well in advance. Um, you will do all this planning and make a determination on what those, uh, safeguards are. And then around that, you'll encapsulate the detection. 9:25 So you'll wanna detect the threats that you've identified and, and maybe some unknown threats as well around that asset. 9:34 So you've got your countermeasures, you'll have your detection, which is sometimes people will hear us talk about monitoring, so that would be, um, a detection piece. And then there's the response. 9:45 So how do you respond should you have an incident? Um, and then how do you recover? And 9:52 how you respond and how you recover are really interesting because they're, they're sort of on the other side of, um, you've had an incident. 9:58 So if you're looking at the response phase, you're looking at all of the things, people, processes, tools that are required to respond to the situation, to neutralize it and isolate it, and then so that you can move on to recovery. 10:14 So you're looking for that, that, um, that whatever that benchmark of stabilization that you've identified is, um, attaining that, and then you can begin your recovery activities. 10:24 Your recovery activities, there's a lot of metrics that are wrapped around this. 10:27 So, um, there's recovery times, there's, uh, recovery capabilities, so to what level of operations do you need to be recovered to within a certain amount of time. 10:38 So all of these things are really key to cybersecurity in particular. 10:42 Other areas of security don't necessarily employ them, but tho-those phases represent a really good framework for literally, um, you know, any type of security incident or any crisis. 10:56 Two other pieces that we look at are, and this is again prior to in preparation for an incident, are attack vectors and then attack surfaces. 11:05 So the attack vectors are the s- the avenues into a particular asset that we need to recognize so that we can manage them, put mitigation around them and safeguards, and also possibly detection. 11:19 Attack surfaces are, is the surface that a threat could operate on. So we often talk about reducing our attack surfaces. 11:28 So that means almost, um, you know, a, a decentralization of certain assets so that those surfaces are smaller and much more manageable. 11:37 So these, these three pieces are really important in cyber, um, in particular, and responding to, um, you know, par-particular threat scenarios. 11:48 If we flip that and go back to what I was saying, um, about states, so if we take our eyes off of threat scenarios and we look at states, so an end result of a particular impact in a maybe a worst case scenario, maybe there's a staggered view towards that That becomes a very different view in terms of risk mitigation because you're not, you're not managing an actual threat anymore. 12:09 You're managing an end state, which becomes very important when you look at attack vectors and attack surfaces. So it's almost like a chess game. You've really got to try to anticipate each move and what the exposure is. 12:24 In your opinion, are we prepared for this? Um, I think we're seeing that, that we're not. Um, and I, I think, you know, we're, there's a lot of evidence of that right now. 12:35 And, you know, my, you know, I've obviously a background in security and, um, as well as sociology. 12:40 So I'm seeing some interesting, um, I guess, behaviors and, and cascade effects in, um, how people are dealing with this crisis and, and our governments as well. 12:52 So, you know, we're, we're so interconnected that this is creating other problems, um, again, at the social, psychological levels, uh, economic, political, as, as we saw yesterday. 13:03 Um, so it becomes really important to ensure during this response and recovery period, which is essentially what we're in, so that we can maintain a level of stability that we're not borrowing data and, and that we're, we're looking at the specifics around this pandemic and what it means to Canada and then lower down to the provinces, to the municipalities by their demographic. 13:29 So data and models need to be based on calculated incidence, prevalence, and, and to that specific demographic, and then described in risk frameworks of possibility and then probability. 13:41 What we're seeing is an inconsistency across the board. 13:43 And of course, with, with social media, it's becoming even more, um, I think alarming and confusing to people because they're hearing, they're not hearing a consistent message, um, overall. 13:55 And on social media, that's an, it's impossible to control. 13:59 However, from the government, um, perspective, the messages at the federal level, the provincial and the municipal need to be very coherent and very, very consistent, um, and very managed, um, recognizing that, um, you know, any statements that could relate to conflation or conjecture around the, you know, potential and possible threats and, and, uh, resulting impacts can have a very deep effect on people's psychological wellbeing as well as their normal social habitus and, and how they behave, um, in the time of crisis and then afterwards. 14:38 I see that, um, our prime minister has been very active in, in addressing Canadian citizens. But do you think the social media is playing a role perhaps in creating unnecessary panic? 14:53 Well, and I think this, this goes back to the discussion around gray zone, right? So you, you have to wonder, um, in this time of crisis for us, um, and for the US, you know, they're, they're obviously our partners, um, 15:06 to what extent are we seeing the same misinformation tactics and disruption that we saw during election periods? Um, we were well aware that this was occurring at the national security and intelligence levels. 15:20 So what we're seeing on social media, to what extent are some of those messages manufactured to create this destabilization? 15:28 Noting that at that micro level, the individual level in societies, um, that affects things as you go up. 15:35 So the individual level, if there's destabilization, that affects how we group as a society and then how we act as a collective being probably the nation is probably the best description. So the, 15:49 the messages that we see on social media, um, you know, these are really, um, unattributed, right? So we, we don't necessarily know where some of these are coming from. 15:59 They're flashing before our eyes as we're looking at our news feed. And to what extent is that, um, affecting how we feel as we're managing the situation? 16:13 Because it's important to recognize, I think this is probably the, one of the first incidents, um, that has really at the practical level, um, impacted people unilaterally. 16:25 So, um, the ones that are actually listening, um, and, and that are self-isolating, we haven't really seen that in our generation. So it's a, it's a huge, huge departure away from what we're used to. 16:38 And I think, you know, the effect of that, um, is really worth noting. 16:43 So we're seeing other, you know, other pieces come into play as well, where, you know, the, the messages we're hearing from government are, are very much, you know, motherhood hectoring type statements that 16:56 are meant to, um, restore confidence and, or to, you know, maintain confidence in our, in our government and that we'll be taken care of and everything will be okay. 17:05 The services will be there and available to the people. 17:09 But unfortunately what we're seeing again on social media are reports that, um, some of these essential services, um, not workplaces, but essential services, their capacity, accessibility, and availability are not there. 17:24 So what is broken down? So when we have a collective, we had a million people, um, applying for EI, what is that doing to the systems that the people are relying on to make that application for relief? 17:38 What we're hearing is that the systems are overloaded. There's confusion around the process, and it's not clear how to, how to, um, successfully maneuver that entire transaction. 17:51 That becomes a narrative that, um, propagates, you know, very well in social media. We're hearing also the same with some of the banks, right? 17:58 So we're, we're hearing a lot of the, uh, conversations around mortgage deferrals and, um, loan relief and that sort of thing. But to what extent is that actually occurring? 18:10 So I guess where I'm going with that is, you know, that becomes a part of that risk management framework when you're looking at, um, you know, a, a, a threat situation or a crisis situation. 18:23 You define those assets, what are important, what has to be available, accessible, um, and has to have the capacity to serve during those times of crises, and, and how does that actually play out when a crisis actually occurs? 18:37 I don't think we've ever gone through that exercise, um, you know, nor I don't think the US has either. 18:42 So it's a really important point of reflection where we are now to mark these as areas of, um, you know, concern and, and further scrutiny as, well, once we recover from this, as we go forward, um, because they are so essential to, uh, the fundamental operations of, you know, our, our cities, societies, and the country as a whole. 19:06 Well, you know, I, I certainly have a lot of empathy, as I'm sure you do, for all of the people who are suffering the impact of COVID-19. But to a certain degree, this is also, um, a test of our policies and procedures. 19:21 I feel that there will be some learning outcomes that will come out of this, and, um, there'll also be probably new policies and procedures. 19:28 Like, you've mentioned social media, and there's a lot of really good, reliable, responsible sources, but there's also a lot of sources that are not necessarily, uh, responsible or have their own agendas, which could be affecting things in a negative way, contributing to a lack of confidence, contributing to, to panic. 19:48 And, um, one of the articles I was reading posted the other day was by an infectious, uh, disease doctor who said, "You know, 19:57 we have this issue of this problem, but in a way, I'm, I'm really concerned about the cure because what effect will that have on future generations and how they view how we manage viruses and, and what level of control and responsibility, what, what systems will be in place?" 20:14 Uh, you hear a lot in the newswire the- these days about people being more concerned about the solution than the actual cause. Do you care to comment on that? And, um, what, what steps, what could we be doing better? 20:27 Yeah, I mean, I think there's a lot, um, there's a lot to be said for, um, you know, w- w- what that, that scientist observed because I think there's... We're in a new territory, right? 20:39 And I think that's-- It may not be net new. I think we have seen, um, obviously pandemics like this in the past. 20:46 Um, however, now we're in a new era where if we keep in mind our legislation around some of this is, um, decades old. 20:58 So the legislation, policies, and, um, regulations that we have in place, because they're decades old, we see, um, where there may not be the effectiveness as they were intended to have based on when they were actually scribed. 21:14 So the interconnected world that we have now, um, and it highly globalized, which is also a really important factor, um, how well-traveled our world is, the ease of travel, the speed of travel, and, and also how much we depend on some of these technologies to just perform our day-to-day activities becomes a really big consideration in not only legislation, but also in risk planning. 21:39 So when you look at something like a virus, um, the, the normal human behavior and psychological response to that is what we're seeing today. People are scared, and that's normal. But what do we do to mitigate that? 21:54 And I argue that there are things that can be done to mitigate that. Um, 21:58 the messages on social media, the messages from our governments have to be stronger, uh, more immediate, and more direct than what people are hearing in social media. 22:09 You can never resolve all doubt, but y- that's what you're competing with. 22:14 So there's a narrative out there that can't be controlled in social media other than speaking over top of it and, and being more, um, y- you know, more... 22:24 I wouldn't say transparent because I think there's, you know, there's some elements of this that there's some things people need to know, and there's other things that they need to be assured of, and I, I think the two are very different. 22:35 But being able to, um, you know, manage what people are seeing and hearing on social media can't be done in social media. It can only be done from the messages that we're receiving, um, you know, from our leadership. 22:47 So Valerie, to get a little more specific, can you comment on more specific issues related to security? I mean, COVID-19 is to some degree an opportunity i- if, if there are vulnerabilities. 23:01 So what are some of the specific security threats? So I think right now we're seeing, um, the obviously a stress on the, the, the basics of, um, you know, just our operating society. 23:14 So we don't have a stress on our food supply system or, or manufacturing as we know it. Um, that in fact would've been a really great message to get out early on, uh, from, 23:26 um, government at all levels to help people understand that they don't need to go, uh, buy huge amounts of food because domestically, we have, um, you know, our own supply chain. 23:39 We also do rely on the US, but there's, there's enough to sustain us, and I think that was a message that was missing. 23:47 The strain of availability, accessibility, and capacity on some of our technology systems where people are, are required to go online, uh, noting that not everybody has, um, internet access, um, in our country, that these systems are stressed. 24:04 So, you know, people are reporting, um, you know, having to Wait hours on the phone or if they're online, um, that their sessions are timing out because of just the sheer volume of traffic that's associated with, uh, whatever that service is. 24:21 So, you know, these are things that we wanna look at because again, it adds to that psychological impact. 24:27 So if the very basics of the services and systems that are there for the relief of the general populace are not working, are not accessible, or aren't, um, available to them, 24:40 that becomes another compounded, um, aspect of how people perceive and behave in, um, a time of crisis and, and, and how they react. So I think, you know, it becomes a multi-spectral security exercise. 24:55 You can't take, you know, one piece and, um, silo it and assess it and just, you know, develop mitigation measures around it because you've defined that as an asset. 25:07 The, the assets across the board are the assets that maintain the g- the overall, uh, wellbeing of our nation, and then its people. 25:19 So that becomes a very big, broad exercise with a lot of interconnected systems, but it becomes crucial, and it becomes crucial in looking at it through various lenses. 25:29 So various lenses that would represent a crisis type or, or a particular, um, event. 25:37 By doing that, you're coming up with different measures, different mitigations to counter whatever the negative effects are of that crisis or event. 25:48 And I think that's where we're, we're having a v- a, a very difficult time at it right now with, um, it's again, going back to essential services and, and people being able to access those services, um, that are standing in the way of them receiving, you know, put bluntly, money. 26:06 That's money that pays rent, that pays utility, that buys foods. Um, and if that's not available, to what extent is that person able to sustain themselves? 26:17 Do they become part of another social system down the road, whether it's welfare or bankruptcy? So those cascade effects are really important to recognize, and the metrics are all there, which is a really great thing. 26:28 We already know in terms of the country, um, what percentage of the country is two paychecks away from bankruptcy, or that has X number of months in savings, um, available to them. 26:39 So we can plan for these scenarios based on the metrics we have, and by putting those particular incidents or crises, um, lenses over top of it, it gives us a better view of what we need to do to maintain that stability when these things happen. 26:55 Well, data certainly is, uh, a power, and I'm sure there will be learning outcomes that come out of this, and it will be probably to some degree a game changer for how we act should there ever be another pandemic in the future. 27:11 You're listening to Vanguard Radio, and we have had the pleasure of speaking with Valerie Finley, research fellow, National Police Foundation, American Society for Evidence-Based Policing, 27:24 with a master's in sociology and a master's in terrorism studies. Valerie, I wanna thank you for joining Vanguard Radio this morning. My pleasure. Thanks, John. [upbeat rock music]