Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Welcome back to another episode of CGE Radio. I'm your host, J. Richard Jones, and it's a pleasure to be with you today. 0:15 Today we're gonna talk about driving digital insurgency to success. We know that digitization is here. It's not something that's just for the future. It's here right now, and we can build around those capabilities. 0:30 Uh, the technology exists commercially to be, uh, utilized both across public sector as well as the defense community, but there are some issues and some challenges that have to be dealt with. 0:42 So as we take a look at, um, how my guests today look at helping defense and intelligence agencies to advance their missions and to really help in promoting stability and security, uh, for citizens and nations and multinational alliances, we're gonna focus in on the, on the matter of trust and innovation and security and compliance, all powered by a very powerful, extensive global partner ecosystem. 1:09 So today I have special guests that I'm very pleased to welcome with us. We have Derek Dobson. He is Defense Industry Lead from Microsoft Canada, and we have Chris Pogue, who is president and CEO of Thales Canada. 1:27 So gentlemen, welcome to the show. Thank you. Nice to be here. Thank you. Pleasure. So, uh, Derek, I'd like to start with you on, on this question. 1:38 Um, how do you think the demands on, on the battlefield have changed over the last few years, and why is digital transformation more important than ever? 1:51 Yeah, I think it's really clear that we need to look at the strategic context that then drives straight into the battle space pretty quickly from there. 1:56 First of all, we see a, a reemergence of great state competition and open conflict between sovereign nations. Technology, digital or otherwise, has always been coveted as a source of advantage in these circumstances. 2:08 And with that, you see a change in the nature of, of warfare itself, so hybrid warfare coexisting alongside conventional approaches to war fighting, meaning that information operations, cyberattacks, and disruption to social cohesion, like through, uh, at- attacks on economies, businesses, and critical infrastructure, all of increasing importance. 2:26 Then the third bit, we know about the, uh, the nexus or the fusion of the, the various domains, land, sea, air, plus space and cyber coming together, and commanders needing to synergize their capabilities and the decision-making processes to get an advantage across all three. 2:40 What does that mean in digital? 2:42 Well, specifically conversations around decision dominance, being able to, to, to see and make sense of things quicker, quicker, uh, be the fir- first and, first and most effective person to act, and then leveraging the data that comes from all of the sensors that, that are designed to do exactly that, collect all of that information across the various domains using AI, cognitive services, et cetera, all the way out to the tactical edge. 3:05 And of course, all of that infrastructure needs to be secured, and we see a rise in nation state attacks. 3:10 Just even in the last three years, uh, Microsoft has issued 20,500 plus nation state notifications when government, uh, including defense infrastructure and other customers, have been attacked by nation states themselves through cyber means. 3:25 So quite a lot happening there in the, in the battle space. Chris, how do you see it? Yeah, maybe I'll pick up on a couple of the comments Derek made. 3:32 I think the use of the word space versus battlefield is an important one. 3:37 When we think of space, we think of all the sort of dimensions of warfare, the hybrid warfare concepts of the early 2000s and how those are now actually realized, uh, today. 3:46 We, we see them today, in fact, in the Ukraine, as an illustration. 3:50 Um, but the idea of a battle space also leads to the, some of the concepts of, the traditional concepts of systems of systems and the way multiple types of systems has to come together and they have to be connected in a fashion. 4:01 The greatest vulnerability to system of systems capability is often at the interfaces and at the seams, and so they, I think those are driving functions. 4:09 Interoperability amongst forces, amongst NATO allies, amongst with the US, amongst Five Eyes nations, has always been a driving force of defense in Canada and the defense procurement system in Canada. 4:20 And as those things come together, we sort of look at the opportunity to leverage the digital technology that Derek spoke of, bring that to get inside the OODA loop. 4:29 One of the fundamental concepts in defense has always been the idea of the OODA loop, observe, orient, decide, and act. 4:37 It really dates back to, uh, you know, pre-World War or rather pr- post-World War II and the study of how we would u- use it for air forces, but it, it exists in everything. 4:46 And digital gives us a chance to speed up our own OODA loop and make more effective decisions faster and potentially get inside the adversary's OODA loop, whether it's through hybrid warfare or whether conventional means. 4:57 I think those are some of the things that demands of the future will lead, and we're presently ready to take on those challenges. Yeah, I, I, I think that's, uh, a very interesting point. 5:08 Um, Derek, what are some of the best practices for the management of digital, uh, transformation? Uh, how, how can defense organizations get started with their digital transformation journey? Thanks. 5:22 I, I think it's really important to start any conversation like this by understanding there's no one, uh, recipe book for success, so each, each transformation will be different. 5:31 But that said, there are some common principles that need to be adopted. The first is to really understand why you're transforming in the first place. What's the strategic imperative? 5:40 And then really that takes you down the path of understanding what do your policies and your results frameworks, et cetera, say you're trying to get out of this, so that you can link all of your programs and projects to those, those priorities. 5:52 In the military sense, an awful lot of that will, will rotate around readiness, w- force posture and readiness, et cetera, and you should be able to tackle the projects you do to see how you will get a benefits realization path back towards that or to indeed to the, the outcome expectations in a battle sense. 6:08 But equally the department's goals will be very well articulated through each line of business, HR, finance, procurement, real property, IT, et cetera. All of those are broken down. 6:16 So understand the linkages between the projects and programs that you're putting into place and that which you're trying to achieve. 6:22 But really I think the most important thing is to know that when you're jumping headfirst into this activity, you're getting right into a really human-based or human-driven activity itself or transformation, and with that in mind, there's, there are probably a few key takeaways to think about it. 6:38 First of all, it's, it's about leadership. 6:41 All of these magic transformational programs are gonna require very capable and very well-empowered leaders who are able to communicate across the whole spectrum what digital transformation means across the whole defense team from top to bottom and bottom to top, and show them how their journey will lead to better outcomes for them personally in terms of their, their working experience and indeed what they're trying to achieve in terms of their role in the organization. 7:07 Then beyond that, you know, scope's usually important. Don't try to transform everything at once. Do it in bite-sized chunks. You know, take an agile approach, small project, learn, refine, and scale. 7:20 I think that, that's really, really important. And then the last couple of points really is just to make sure that you focus on changing more than just the digital tools themselves. 7:30 Think about also the business processes, the procurement methods, the contract vehicles, the training, the skilling, all of it together as part of your transformation journey, not just buying some tools and putting them into place. 7:42 All of that is where you get to. And hey, the final bit I did mention it's a, a, a human-driven activity. Celebrate success as you come along. 7:49 You know, each little piece is a successful, uh, milestone as you go towards your transformed state, which you'll probably never reach to reach in the front end state anyway. It's a journey. 7:59 Celebrate the journey and make sure everybody knows that they're doing well as you go along. 8:04 And the journey is always evolving, um, on our, on our weekly show we're talking quite a bit about the issues of leadership and training. 8:12 Um, I'd be curious to ask you, Chris, how, how much of a, a role do you think training plays in, uh, in, in some of the areas that, um, that Derek has, has, uh, identified? I think it's a crucial role. 8:25 I mean, if you really want people to adopt digital technologies, they need to be able to get past any fear factor they may have of those, and training is a way you overcome the fear of the unknown or the fear of the mission. 8:37 When I was in the Air Force, uh, flying, you know, the, the ability to be trained in multiple types of scenarios allowed you to react to the scenario you didn't know yet was coming, and digital's the same thing. 8:48 Um, I mean, it's going to give capability and bring capability that will require people to be prepared for it. 8:54 I, I think one of the points that's a really important point is to recognize that, that digital is about a shift, a paradigm shift in the way you think about problems. 9:03 You have to think about problems through a digital lens, not think about taking paper and turning it into a digital product. You have to think about the way you'll use the data and the way you'll organize data. 9:13 I, I'm reminded of a conversation I had a couple of years ago around the intelligent enterprise with Admiral Bishop at the time, and we were really talking about, you know, this challenge he was facing about how do you, um, how do you rather than try to find the right data to make a decision, use all the data to make the right decision? 9:31 It always stuck with me as a powerful thing that digital brings to the battle space. 9:36 The other thing I think that's important to recognize is, you know, you used the phrase started, John, and that's an acceptable phrase I think for defense 'cause it's early days, but make no mistake, I mean, the digital transformation has been going on in defense for a while. 9:48 It's, it's part of the procurement processes now. It's being thought about. 9:52 Um, that doesn't mean it's all there yet, don't get me wrong, but it's being thought about, and some of the things I think that are important in that consideration is really to think about that, well, I use a 70, 20, 10 rule when I think about it, like 70% of your energy is on getting the data organized and getting the right data, 20% on how you use that data, and the 10% on the technology. 10:12 And when I think about the technology that's available, I think about going on in the commercial sector, I really think about the cost technologies to give you viable products today, making sure that they're consistent with Allied and NATO standards, the countries that we're gonna wanna operate with and share data with and share information with. 10:28 The idea of an open architecture I think drives these things so you don't get locked into any kind of single solution, and then perhaps most importantly is really to think about the way you need to shift the way you think to a digital first mindset. 10:40 Some of the things I'm seeing that are really moving us in that direction within defense is the adoption of these, the idea of the combat digital platform or digital platforms to allow you to experiment with ideas a lot earlier, changing the way you might procure so you can procure capability faster so you don't get behind, you know, to the, uh, you're not on the bleeding edge, but you're also closer to the leading edge of the technology that's available. 11:02 Those are some of the things that sort of pass through my mind in terms of best practice to bring digital to defense. 11:08 Yeah, I, I, I, I agree with you on that, and I think, you know, uh, Derek had, had made the comment that digital is here now, and I think the key is in the adaptation and that paradigm think, shift in thinking and as well the training. 11:23 I mean, when we look at this horrible thing going on in the Ukraine right now, technology, I... It's possible, um, maybe the technology quotient has been underestimated here. 11:34 I mean, you're able to report on real time where people are. Everything is broadcasted across social media. Everybody knows what's going on, whether it's, whether it's accurate or not. 11:43 I think that changes a lot of dynamics. Uh, Derek, why do you feel a partnership and collaboration is so important in the defense industry? What are the benefits? 11:55 I think I'll probably touch on a few of the areas that, that Chris, uh, alluded to as well. 11:59 Actually, to drive significant, significant change at the rapid pace that we're really looking for i- in transformation, it's gonna require partnerships and does require partnerships both between defense, as in the department and the armed forces, and the other government departments that they rely upon, uh, as well as the traditional defense industrial base, uh, providers that are partners for the, the defense a- agencies and the technology sector Great partnerships are necessary in order to make sure those stakeholder sh- groups are really aligned in four key areas. 12:30 First, Chris will talk about procurement. 12:32 It's always, always a tricky subject in defense, but particularly in relation to digital solutions and technologies, because collaborative approaches and trust are really gonna be needed there to break down some of the famously complicated, uh, and controlling processes that serve as barriers to outcome-focused, um, uh, procurement and adoption of new technologies. 12:55 You need your teams to be able to work together to implement solutions based on an outcome expectation vice excessively detailed requirements specifying exactly how each solution should be built and what technology must be built into it. 13:11 That in a, that will hamper innovation. So a great partnership will help you to build trust that will overcome that. Chris talked about standards as well. 13:19 Defense and industry partners have to really agree on common platforms, architectures, and standards in order to allow solution developers to head off and innovate, really. 13:28 And you're talking about solution developers, independent software vendors, and, and, and other developers to really get to grips with the problems and develop those solutions that can be rapidly implemented and scaled in the department. 13:39 Two other points to, to think about. Uh, security classifications. Clearly we're gonna be dealing with some sensitive mission data and workloads, et cetera, and all of that will need to be protected. 13:50 That said, defense and the defense ecosystem regularly errs on the side of over-classifying everything, which creates unique challenges when it comes to partnerships in the software development world. 14:03 We can develop an awful lot on the low side and then deploy high, and that needs to be considered all the way through the journey. 14:09 And, and my fourth one really then comes to the requirement for us to build a joint culture that le- allows us to do digital transformation. 14:17 Great partnerships are focused on mission outcomes, and the best ones where innovation and capability development and adoption are achieved at scale and speed are completely badgeless. 14:27 We should be able to put our teams of developers side by side with various firms, companies, partners, and members of the armed forces and departments so that we can co-develop, and ultimately we all want to empower the defense organizations to achieve more through the power of technology. 14:43 So let's do that together and side by side and in a creative way, rather than necessarily being badged and siloed as we go through the journey. 14:52 Yeah, what I, what I, what resonates with me is there's a leadership issue, there's trust working as a team. Don't worry so much about the technical. 15:00 When we talk about security in terms of battlefield, I mean, you've got to have that real data available in the field. 15:07 And, you know, in, in, in some of the previous engagements that have gone on, adversaries, I guess, in the black net had a lot of the very same data, and they were in some cases maybe getting it faster. 15:18 So it is about speed to market. Chris, I want to give you an opportunity to weigh in on, uh, on Derek's comments and, and my question. Yeah, I mean, I think 15:28 good ideas and good answers and great solutions come from anywhere, so the idea that, that, you know, partnerships and collaboration is a crucial to success here. 15:38 You, you know, we even have it in the vision of our company committed to collaboration. 15:42 Um, and, uh, just as an illustration, we, we work with over five hundred companies, uh, small and medium-sized companies as well across Canada on the Aegis program, which is essentially, you know, uh, delivering a digital capability to the Navy for the Arctic Offshore Patrol Vessel and the joint supply ships. 15:57 Those solutions will not be delivered to the Navy by one company. There'll be multiple partners because good ideas are gonna come from everywhere. 16:04 I, I do think some of the challenges, I'll touch back on procurement, is finding ways to enable the defense organizations to see what's going on in the, in the industrial sector, and I think that sometimes that sort of gets in the way. 16:19 So it's important to create mechanisms where they can see what is in the realm of the possible, and then understanding that there is a merging of capability between what commercial sector has done in the past twenty years with digital, where it's been really driving the digital adoption. 16:32 You just think of companies like, uh, Shopify that, you know, change the sort of the nature of the market space. 16:38 How can those capabilities be brought into defense and brought in to be effective in those sort of remote, austere, hostile environments where size, weight, and power are gonna matter, the tactical edge that, that Derek referred to, um, and how can they be adapted for that particular environment? 16:53 I think that's where you can create this unique relationship between multiple industrial sectors all kind of focused on the mission. And I do want to pick up on the mission context. 17:02 I've found throughout my career, both in uniform and since I've been in industry, was when people got focused on solving a mission, and they realized that they were delivering something to the men and women who put their life on the line to protect our nation, 17:16 all the little barriers and the things that got in the way of partnering and collaborating fell away because you were focused on the mission. 17:23 Nothing focuses your mind more than trying to deliver those people that are willing to put their life on the line to keep you safe, and we certainly see that today. 17:32 So, uh, I can't imagine an answer that doesn't include those kinds of collaborations. Yeah, so true. 17:41 Um, Chris, I wanna ask you, as, as we're looking forward to, uh, the future of intelligence on the battlefield, what do you think is the next frontier? 17:52 Well, I think we're in the, in the middle of the first frontier, for sure. 17:56 You know, finding ways to get the adoption going, to test a little bit, trial and error, and adapt different technologies to the, to the battle space. 18:04 I think there's a few things that strike me as important things to keep in mind as maybe the next frontier, and that would be, um, the idea of bringing augmented or artificial intelligence, what we like to refer to as augmented intelligence, into that OODA loop to help the decision-maker make a decision faster. 18:20 The idea that we're moving from data sciences to decision sciences. Um, the idea of frugal AI really interests me. 18:27 In other words- AI algorithms that don't require the large data sets, and the idea that this can be done at the tactical edge where decisions have to be made. 18:37 I, I can see future battlefields and battle spaces where decisions have to be made right at the tactical edge. You can't necessarily go back to a commander. We need to give that kind of a capability in the field. 18:47 We used to have a thing when we were building defense systems called SWAPC or size, weight, and power and cost trade-offs that you were always making, and I th- see frugal AI as a size, weight, and power model for the decision systems that we wanna deploy. 19:02 I, I think any of the tactical intelligence we, we can create and use, um, trust is going to be that underpinning of all of it. 19:11 Um, I think an example of what we're kind of living with right today as we watch, uh, Zelensky, I call, call it the Zelensky effect. [laughs] Yeah. 19:18 In that we have someone who is able to get on social media, although there was a, there was a deep fake today, apparently, but get on social media and speak directly to the world. 19:28 And I would say that, you know, he may be the Churchill of this generation in that he's caused a nation to rally behind him. 19:35 Those are the kinds of things I can't imagine happening if we didn't trust what he was saying, and that's powerful. That's a very powerful representative example for all of us. 19:45 And so at the end of the day, for any of this to be as successful as it can be, we have to find ways to create that trust, whether it's trust in the delivery organizations, whether it's trust in the data, trust in the decisions, and I think we're seeing a very good example of it live on TV and on the internet almost every day over the past 21 days. 20:05 I think you're exactly right, and, uh, it, it's certainly connecting with people as well, and when you're in the throes of things, I, I agree with you, it's about getting the job done as well. 20:16 Uh, Derek, how would you respond? Uh, what fantastic response from Chris there, to be honest. I think I'd probably come back to where I started with my opening remarks, actually, was around the, the future is now. 20:26 You know, we're actually seeing, uh, the frontier arriving right now on our doorstep, and I think therefore my kind of questioning is, is really around, uh, you know, where does the function sit today, and how is that being evolved into tomorrow? 20:39 And, and I sit, uh, looking at the fact that we've always been around the intelligence cycle really about direction, collection, collation, analysis, and dissemination of, of, of intelligence focused on that ability to drive faster decisions. 20:54 Great. We talked about that as a strategic driver in the first place, but what th- cha- has changed at the moment? 21:00 Well, firstly, the speed at which decisions need to be made from the strategic level to the lowest possible tactical level, so right there from NDHQ all the way in through J- CJOC all the way down to the joint operational area, and, you know, a s- a, a section commander, as it were, uh, or the commander of a ship or aircraft really needing to make those decisions. 21:19 The number of collection sources of information that are being brought together to actually feed the, the decision-making is increasing exponentially, and the amount of data that needs to be assessed to be turned into actionable intelligence is increasing. 21:33 So I, I look at what is that frontier? Where is it moving right now? 21:37 So we're looking already at the way that digital technologies are aiding the collection, fusion, and analysis of information right out to the edge, and I would really stress the fact that, you know, all source fusion is currently being achieved through commercially available and cloud native applications using AI, uh, to ge- generate a common operating picture right now, not something that's being developed in the future, already being, uh, i-i- being done. 22:00 Um, open source intelligence is being used at, at a much gr- greater scale now, and it's being leveraged to an extent that was previously unimaginable in the era of manual collection and collation, really, uh, including, of course, collecting and collating that open source data from the web and social media, et cetera. 22:18 So we're seeing that. 22:19 On top of that, in order to make those decisions fast, you need scalable computation, including the infrastructure and AI, and that's gotta go out to the edge, even in denied, disrupted, intermittent, and low bandwidth environments and across federated mission networks, again, possible right now, so able to, to be developed and delivered. 22:38 Uh, and with all of that, what does that allow you to do? 22:41 Advanced threat modeling, great threat recognition, really accelerating all of that n- available right now and helping drive decisions using automation, AI, um, and low-code and no-code tools that are driving next best, uh, deci- next best action decisions in a much more, um, holistic and accurate manner. 23:00 So I'll leave that there just now, but quite a lot happening on the current frontier to take us to the next l- the next capability bound, as it were. 23:09 So I think the future is now, and we need to, to make sure we embrace it and, and get on with it, really. You've been listening to Vanguard Radio, and we've been talking today about driving digital insurgency to success. 23:24 I want to thank our special guests, Chris Pogue, uh, President and CEO of Thales Canada, and as well, Derek Dobson, uh, Defense Industry Lead for Microsoft Canada. Gentlemen, it's been a really interesting show. 23:37 I, I really appreciate you coming on today. Thanks a lot, John. Thank you. 23:50 The views, information, or opinions expressed during the Vanguard Weekly Podcast Series, CGE Weekly Podcast Series, Vanguard Radio Podcast, and CGE Radio Podcast are solely those of the individuals involved and do not represent those of Vanguard or any affiliated media products, their employees or owners. 24:08 Vanguard Magazine, Canadian Government Executive Magazine, and its affiliates are not responsible for and do not verify for accuracy any of the information contained in this podcast series. 24:18 This podcast may not be copied or distributed without express written approval of Promotive Communications Inc., PCI. You may not edit, modify, or redistribute this podcast without consent from PCI. 24:30 PCI assumes no liability for activities in connection with this podcast or for use of this podcast with any other website, computer, or playing device.