Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Welcome back to another episode of Vanguard Radio. I'm your host, J. Richard Jones, and it's a pleasure to be with you today. 0:16 Today, we're gonna get into talking about military electromagnetic capability, or EMC, as well as emission security and Tempest technology, EMSEC. And why is this important? 0:29 Well, we're gonna delve into the issues of security. 0:32 We're gonna talk about Tempest attacks and why that is so important to your security, um, in terms of, uh, bad actors being able to get ahold of data, keystrokes, and video imagery. 0:46 We're also going to talk about the need to have process security as well as proper testing done so that your electronics are compliant and, and up to speed in what they're doing. 0:58 Joining us today is a very special guest, Bruce Alexander, president, Raymond EMC. Bruce, welcome to the show. Thank you so much. So your company has a great story to tell, and I was reading your bio. 1:13 It's pretty interesting. You're involved in all aspects of shield enclosures, and, uh, you, you get into different types of sha- chambers and different types of products for different industries. 1:27 But the thing that really caught me was this thing about the Tempest attack and, and security, and as well just some of the standards that, um, you help different industries adhere to. 1:39 So the key points to me are all about secure processing and, uh, the safety and the certifications. But, uh, I'm sure you can tell us quite a bit more. But, but let's begin with your journey if we can, Bruce. Um- Sure... 1:52 tell us about how you go from being a part-time contractor to president of EMC. Yeah, that's, uh, that's kind of a good place to start, I suppose. 2:01 Um, back when I was in college, I worked for a landscaper and, you know, doing like cedar decks, fences, lock stone, stuff like that. 2:13 And, uh, the guy I was working for won a few contracts with what w- back then was called Rayproof Canada, uh, to install some, uh, shielded enclosures, and I was essentially, uh, his laborer to help him move panels and framing and put the thing together. 2:30 Um, but I understood enough about electromagnetics and, uh, wave theory, and I went from, uh, you know, 2:39 basically being a lackey, uh, laborer, putting together these things to, uh, being a test technician and verifying that they were put together properly. 2:48 So I worked as a, as sort of a part-time contractor for, uh, what then became Raymond EMC, uh, for a number of years and ended up starting my own install company. 3:00 And, uh, in 2012, uh, just the cards were on the table just right, and I bought, uh, Raymond EMC Enclosures and, uh, have been running it, uh, since then. Oh, that's a great story to tell. 3:14 Uh, as I understand it, when we get into talking about, um, the world of electromagnetics, I guess if I can call it that, it's, it's all about minimizing interference. It's about performance. 3:28 It's about security and privacy, some of what- which we've already mentioned. But, um, what is, what is EMC, and, and why do you need a special chamber? 3:40 So let's, uh, yeah, let's, let's chat EMC for a little bit because it's, it's kinda this-- The industry segments that we work in are very different applications, but our application is always the same thing. 3:54 We provide the same service, which is essentially we build, uh, big metal boxes that either keep radio waves contained or they keep radio waves out. 4:06 So for instance, EMC stands for electromagnetic compatibility, and EMC is a discipline in, in electrical safety where you verify that, [clears throat] um, electronic devices will get along with other electronic devices. 4:22 Um, and there's a, there's a huge military application here, but the, the simplest illustration I can use is actually out of automotive. 4:30 So in your car, you probably have some sort of electronic card that controls your brakes, and you've also got an electronic card somewhere that controls the, you know, the, the fuel feed to the engine. 4:41 You don't wanna drive by the airport where there's a really strong electromagnetic signal that lead- that guides airplanes down onto the runway and have that interfere with your braking module and tell it to stop working and at the same time interfere with your throttle module and tell it to go full throttle. 4:57 Um, that would be bad. 4:59 So all, uh, automotive devices are tested in a chamber like what we manufacture to ensure that the regular electromagnetic environments they operate in, uh, won't interfere with their proper and safe operation. 5:15 And then they're also tested to ensure that they don't create so much electronic or e- electromagnetic noise that they interfere with other onboard devices in the car. 5:24 So in the military, um, the EMC specification is actually MIL-Standard 461, and it's a very, uh, detailed specification on how to test, uh, electronic devices for military use that, uh, ensures that in the field, electronic devices won't interfere with other electronic devices and also won't fail when interfered with. 5:48 Um, so in, i- in the, uh, in the military, like I said, there's MIL-Standard, uh, 461, and it's one of the major ones they use, but they also use DO-160, which is an aviation specification, again, ensuring that the electronic devices onboard, uh, uh, airframes don't fail or interfere with each other. 6:07 So certainly from a military point of view, failure in interference is, is not an option, you know? So I could, I could see the, the, the value of that for sure. Correct. Um, 6:19 what are the-- I guess there's four pillars that, that are involved in EMC testing. Can you tell us a little more about that? Yeah, for sure. So there's, there's-- We'll, we'll subdivide it into two pillars first. 6:31 There's, uh, conducted and radiated, uh, testing. So conducted is basically that's, uh, electrons moving on conductors, and radiated is electromagnetic waves. And, um, 6:48 so for instance, uh, you wouldn't wanna have your, your harness for your, um, your radar system in an airplane, you know, a wiring harness running beside, uh, the, the fly-by-wire controls and the conducted signals from each of those interfering with the other systems. 7:08 So, so those systems are tested by imposing on them, uh, conductive, uh, electrical impulses, and as well measured to make sure that those -- the, the impulses on those systems aren't interfering with other, other systems. 7:24 And radiated is where it gets more complex because this is the electromagnetic waves that are, uh, unintentionally created from systems. 7:34 So again, they'll impose a radio wave on a system to ensure that it keeps functioning properly. 7:40 And, uh, they'll measure to make sure that the, the waves coming off of a system are not so high that they'll interfere with other onboard devices. Now, how do you, how do you go about doing that? 7:52 Because in a, uh, in its -- in a regular environment, you can't just decide, "Okay, well, I'm gonna, I'm gonna impose radio waves on this system and, uh, uh, and make sure that it keeps functioning," because 8:07 there's laws about how much power you're allowed to produce and, and, uh, where you can broadcast on the spectrum, so you could end, end up interfering with all sorts of different, different communication signals and whatnot. 8:19 So that's where our product comes in, where we build the box to do the testing in, and it keeps all of those radio waves contained, so you don't have f- interference from the outside world. 8:32 And as well, uh, you can create as much, uh, electromagnetic strength or radio wave strength as you want inside that box because it stays contained. Then the other thing we do inside that box is we line it 8:46 with material that absorbs radio waves so that when you're doing measurements, you know that what you're receiving with your equipment is exactly what is coming from the device or what's coming from your antenna and not bouncing around and echoing off the walls. 9:04 So it's kind of like a quiet room for radio waves. So this is where, from what I've researched, this is where design and fabrication of those chambers is so important. Correct. There is -- There's a lot that goes into... 9:19 It sounds, it sounds pretty simple, and it kind of is. 9:25 Um, but most of the time you sort of think about, you know, when you talk about radio frequency shielding, when, you know, when I tell people that know nothing about our industry, uh, what we do, you know, you usually get the question about, like, the tinfoil hats and, and sort of the, the, the conspiracy theorist, um, you know, shielded tents to, uh, to sleep in so that radio waves can't interfere with them. 9:49 And, um, but, but, you know, it's a lot more complex than that. But, um, it has to be done right because you can't... 9:59 You know, for instance, in military testing, you could be testing with a very, very strong signal, um, that, for instance, would interfere with, uh, emergency response systems. 10:11 And, uh, that's gotta stay contained in the room. 10:14 And, uh, as well, you need to know for sure that what you're, what you're reading off of a device is the, the actual signal that's coming off of that device, and that you're not getting interference from the outside world. 10:27 So design and, uh, you know, design is, is step one. Workmanship is step two. Uh, because it's fine to design, uh, an EMC enclosure and, and it looks great on paper, but if it's not put together correctly, it won't work. 10:43 So workmanship is also a key component in the, in the products that we, uh, manufacture. Yeah, it sounds like there's quite a bit to it. Um, Bruce, what is EMSEC and Tempest? So EMSEC is emission security. 10:59 So in that case, uh, what we're providing for, you know, normally a government agency or a government contractor, is a enclosure that ensures that radio waves can't get out to the outside world. 11:16 Um, so similar to, uh, EMC, I mean, EMSEC and, and Tempest technology is really kind of a division of, of EMC. 11:27 And in, um, in, in EMSEC, what you're doing is a computer will create unintentionally radio waves because you're throwing all sorts of electronics or electrons around in the different circuit boards and whatnot. 11:42 And if you have the right equipment, you can measure and pick up the unintentional emissions off of a computer, and you can recreate screenshots, keystrokes, mouse movement, uh, the communi- the electronic communications along the network cables, that type of thing. 12:00 So, um, what, what our enclosure allows the user to do is to process classified equipment without concern that the images from their screen, for instance, can be picked up outside of their controlled environment by an adversary. 12:18 We keep all of those radio waves contained in the enclosure, uh, where the computer is operating I gotta imagine that that's pretty important, especially these days with what's going on around the world. 12:32 Well, it, you know, it is important, and, um, it's become, uh, in my opinion, more of a threat than it was even during the Cold War. 12:40 During the Cold War, uh, mitigating Tempest threat was, was a pretty big industry and a, and a pretty significant concern. 12:49 But back in those days, you needed, you know, a million dollars worth of equipment, and it would fit in a van. So it was very hard to access places where, uh, secure processing would be taking place. 13:03 But, uh, in this day and age with, you know, technologies getting smaller and smaller, uh, it's much easier to do a Tempest attack than it was even 10 years ago. 13:13 Um, a couple of years ago, I, I found out about, um, a, a, a software-defined radio card that could be used for a Tempest attack, so I just told one of our engineers, "Hey, see if you can do this." 13:26 So for $250, he bought a, a software-defined radio card, he downloaded a free program, uh, off the internet, and he used one of our, our antennas, which was, was, uh, uh, a pretty good antenna. Um, but, uh, 13:43 didn't need to use a fancy antenna for, for this frequency. 13:47 And with, you know, with a, an old $600 computer and $400 worth of, uh, stuff that he ordered off the internet, we were able to pick up computer screen, uh, images from about 10 meters away. Wow. Huh. 14:03 And that was a, that was a kit that could, you know, it could fit in a, a, a backpack. Wow. So, so the Tempest threat has moved from, um... 14:14 It's become almost more like an insider threat, whereas years ago, it was, it had to be very, very capable, uh, you know, foreign operators, and now it's more like someone could be told just to, you know, throw this computer and this antenna in your backpack, and just throw it in a broom closet and don't ask questions. 14:33 So it's, it's really become a, a much different threat than it was even 10, 15 years ago. Oh, that's a great story. We've talked about some of the risks. 14:41 Um, so when we get into Msec risks, are there any, uh, examples that you could share with us, uh, as, as in addition to what we were just talking about? 14:50 Um, probably not, because we'd be, uh, we'd be starting to get into the area of examples that I can't talk about. So, um, but, uh, we certainly use the, the software-defined radio card. 15:03 We'll probably have that set up at, uh, Cansec this year, uh, to demonstrate, uh, just how easy it is to do a Tempest attack. We, uh, need to get legal advice on that first. 15:13 We can, we can pick up our own computer screen. We want to make sure that we're not picking up other computer screens in, in the area. Um, but, uh, it's, it's, it's very... 15:24 Uh, I mean, you can go in the, on, like I said, on the internet and look up what equipment you need, and with, you know, $400, you've got your own little Tempest, uh, system. 15:33 One of, one of the, uh, the security advisors that we've worked with, um, has kind of insinuated that the, the, probably the next threat in Tempest attack may not be government documents, but may be more along the lines of, you know, a, a 14-year-old, uh, person who's really interested in computers figures out how to do this and just, you know, uh, parks themselves in the park bench outside influencers' homes and sees if they can read their email or, or see what they're downloading on the, on the internet. 16:09 That certainly wouldn't, uh, surprise me. 16:12 I mean, I was just reading recently about, uh, I don't think it's so much related to this technology, but there was a young man in the States that was able to, uh, track all of Elon Musk's flight destinations, and, uh- Hmm... 16:25 it didn't, didn't sound like it was that hard to do, so- Yeah. Yeah... it, it's, it's certainly a possibility. I think this is, I hope you are able to do a demonstration at Cansec. This is something people need to see. 16:36 It's certainly an eye-opener. Um, let's talk- Yeah, and you know, it- Sorry, go ahead. Yeah... it really is an eye-opener because it's, it's... 16:43 You know, when you hear about it, it's kind of like, eh, how easy can that be? 16:47 And every time we've done a demonstration in, in our, uh, in our shop for our clients, there's usually sort of a few wide-eyed looks and, and, you know, really expressions, not realizing how easy it is to do this. 17:02 Yeah, no, it, it's certainly opened my eyes. Um, let's talk a little bit about the Canadian Industrial Tempest Program. I think it's known as CITP. Can you tell us a bit about that? Yeah, I can tell you a bit about it. 17:15 It's, um, it's really a program that Canadian government, uh, runs. 17:20 Uh, it's part of CSE, uh, part of their mandate, and it's a program that they run to ensure that, uh, Tempest products and, uh, the people who certify them are operating under the strict, uh, guidelines of the Canadian government and their NATO partners. 17:39 So it's really a program that ensures that you've got the right clearances, the right people involved with the right expertise that are, uh, making sure that the, the equipment operates correctly. 17:52 That's one of the other, sort of the other side of Tempest that, that, uh, I didn't, I didn't mention, um, that... 17:58 So we manufacture the in- the walk-in enclosures or, or enclosures for, uh, you know, racks, that type of thing. 18:07 There are also available, uh, Tempest computing equipment, which, uh, we, we don't manufacture that ourselves, but we work with a, a company out of Holland for the, the Tempest computing equipment. 18:19 But it's essentially a shielded computer. So instead of, uh, using, uh, like a shielded office, it's just the computer itself is shielded for, uh, lower threat applications. 18:33 Um, but, uh, that, again, the, uh, Tempest equipment is governed by, uh, the program you just mentioned. And it's about standardization and, and compliancy. Uh- Correct... 18:48 I know we talked a little bit about what the future could look like, but let's like, if we could expand on that a little more, what is the future of Tempest and the military in your opinion? 18:58 Well, I think on the, on the Tempest side, um, you know, you, you always sort of wonder like how, what's gonna be the next advancement in terms of things like nanotechnologies. 19:12 Um, you know, like I said, it used to be that a Tempest attack had to be done in the back, you know, no, from the back of a van with, with a good power supply. 19:22 Now it can be done with a, a laptop, a software-defined radio card and a, you know, essentially a battery. Um, and you just wonder like how, how small will things get that can actually pick up a signal? 19:36 Like could, could the next advancement be something, you know, could it be done with your iPhone? Um, it can't be done yet with an iPhone, but certainly things are trending in that direction. 19:48 On the, uh, EMC side, uh, the electromagnetic compatibility side, as things get more and more, uh, dependent on electronics and especially digital electronics and automated systems, of course that creates more and more radio waves that could potentially, uh, interfere with devices. 20:11 So the, um, the attention to detail in testing becomes more and more complex. 20:17 Um, certainly in the military there, it, it's, it's pretty standardized and, and, um, where, where we're seeing a lot of advancement in EMC is actually in the automated vehicle, uh, industry, where, you know, not only do you have all of these, uh, you know, sensors and, uh, you know, electronic systems on board a car, but, but now you've gotta run the thing with AI and how does that react to different, uh, situations and, and, uh, electronic impulses? 20:51 So it, it becomes quite complex. Yeah, I never thought about that with, with the automation area, and especially with cars. That is really interesting. You are listening to Vanguard Radio. 21:01 Our special guest today has been Bruce Alexander, president with Raymond EMC. We've been talking about military electromagnetic capability as well as emission security and Tempest technology. 21:16 It's a pretty big role in terms of security, in terms of performance and, uh, privacy. Now, uh, Bruce, you're going to be at CANSEC, yes? Correct. 21:26 Yeah, we're gonna be there with, uh, one of our European, uh, partners, uh, Euro Tempest. 21:32 They, they manufacture Tempest computing equipment, and we'll be there as usual, and really looking forward to being back at the show in person again after a two-year hiatus. Yep, for sure. 21:44 I wanna thank you for coming on to Vanguard Radio. It's been a really interesting podcast, and there's lots to learn here for sure. Thank you very much for having me. I appreciate it. 21:53 [outro music] The views, information, or opinions expressed during the Vanguard Weekly Podcast Series, CGE Weekly Podcast Series, Vanguard Radio Podcast, and CGE Radio Podcast are solely those of the individuals involved and do not represent those of Vanguard or any affiliated media products, their employees, or owners. 22:20 Vanguard Magazine, Canadian Government Executive Magazine, and its affiliates are not responsible for and do not verify for accuracy any of the information contained in this podcast series. 22:31 This podcast may not be copied or distributed without express written approval of Promotive Communications Inc., PCI. You may not edit, modify, or redistribute this podcast without consent from PCI. 22:42 PCI assumes no liability for activities in connection with this podcast or for use of this podcast with any other website, computer, or playing device