Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Welcome back to another episode of Vanguard Radio. I'm your host, J. Richard Jones. Today, we're gonna be talking a little bit about safety and standards. 0:17 My special guest joining is, uh, Mr. Matthew Palmer. He's Global Commercial Lead for submarines with Lloyd's Register. Matthew, thank you so much for joining us here from England today. No, John, thank you for having me. 0:31 I'm very looking forward to discussing how Lloyd's works in the naval submarine world. How does LR, Lloyd's Registry, support submarine designers and builders, and also navies who operate submarines? 0:45 This year has been quite a big year for Lloyd's because it's recently our 25th birthday of our naval ship rules. 0:52 So we've had 25 years of supporting naval vessels, classing naval vessels in that, and those lessons learned and that experience we've been putting into our submarine program. 1:05 And Lloyd's has been supporting a naval submarine program since 2005. So it's 25 years of naval rules and 20 years of supporting submarines. 1:17 We are quite an old organization, back from 1760, so we can leverage our shipbuilding experience back to the commercial world, all the way back to about 260 years. 1:29 But kind of there lay, lays the first challenge when we talk about kind of providing assurance to naval platforms. 1:36 So your listeners may have heard of rules and classification, and actually one of the questions is, "Why don't you have rules for naval submarines?" And it's quite a simple way when you kinda break it down like this. 1:50 When you paint a commercial ship gray, you can call it a naval ship, so naval ships have that pedigree going back all those years, and the rules is this collection of lessons learned. 2:04 So for submarines, there is no commercial equivalent of a submarine. The closest thing you get to is a submersible, and we class submersibles. But a naval submarine is very, very different. 2:16 The number of platforms is very, very limited compared to the commercial world as well. 2:21 And being a submariner myself, we've always liked to say we are special and different, and our work we do is secret, so there is less sharing in the submarine community, unlike the, the commercial world. 2:34 So from Lloyd's, we had to think about how we would provide benefit from the space and what Lloyd's would offer and would be in this space. 2:42 So we have been working on our version, you could say, of rules, which is our submarine assurance framework, which is a goal-based process question set 2:54 to capture kind of the submarine operations and the kind of complexities of submarines. I do something when I do a course or speak to people, I kind of ask them, "What's the difference between a ship and a submarine?" 3:07 Everyone laughs, and everyone's like, "Well, the obvious question, a ship's not designed to go underwater." 3:12 But actually, when we start breaking it down, we start kind of drawing out these kind of complexities, you know, a submarine's a system of systems, and it, everything is critical on a submarine, which starts thinking about the kind of philosophy of how you will actually look after a submarine and the kind of integration of safety in a submarine. 3:31 So w- we looked at what we did on our new construction projects, supporting the UK surface fleet of the Astute and the Dreadnought class, and we withdrew those lessons learned into building this framework. 3:44 The integration of the International Safety Association and the Naval Submarine Code, which is a goal-based document just designed to sit there, such as your likes of SOLAS and MARPOL. 3:56 So it's a kind of a naval equivalent. 3:58 So when we were creating our framework, it was designed to link into those higher documents, such as the Submarine Code, and also allows us to connect into our standard kind of rules, such as kind of materials, risk, even parts of ship rules where applicable. 4:15 But it takes into that submarine nuance of how a submarine would operate and function in there as well. I mean, I will give you some examples of where our submarine framework has been designed. 4:29 So we talk about new construction, so we're applying sections of that framework to our site team. 4:35 So in the UK, we have a site team of six surveyors supporting the UK submarine program, and as I mentioned before, they've been there since 2005. 4:45 One of the big kind of common areas we looked at between ships and submarines was the area of supply chain, 4:54 and actually how that works and all that kind of experience of doing it for naval ships and commercial ships, and actually that pump, that valve, that piece of plate is coming with that certification. 5:07 It's been tested, it's been seen, and it's been witnessed, and it's been coming back into yard and actually integrated into the submarine there as well, whole process, using that kind of experience. 5:19 But again, it's the questions of actually how, how are you going to use that bit of equipment in that submarine environment. 5:27 And just this year, we've actually started supporting in-service submarines in a kind of full-time presence as well, actually maintaining a fleet at sea. 5:37 So again, we've got two full-time surveyors supporting a navy to ensure operation availability. But again, it's those lessons learned from the ship side, from the naval ship side, 5:50 and putting that experience in the waterfront to kind of reduce those maintenance periods and get those ships to sea. And then also, we've got our kind of deep technical expertise in there as well. 6:01 Lloyd's Register, as I said, has been around for over two hundred and sixty years. We hold a lot of valuable information. 6:07 So one of the tools we take is where commercial world is going, and there's capability to kind of modeling those fuels, those risks, and actually bring that into there, and actually how we can support a navy to kind of provide that kind of overall peace of assurance 6:24 that way. But the kind of main bit we're kind of working on is like equivalent level of document is our kind of submarine assurance framework is our version of naval ship rules, but in the kind of submarine domain. 6:36 But it's highly tailorable based on our kind of experience with working with naval assets. So hopefully, John, that kind of answers the question in a nutshell. It does, and it's almost like an ISO standard, if you will. 6:50 Um, I should also mention, Matthew, you've had a career with the Royal Navy as an engineering officer on nuclear-powered submarines, so you know a thing or two about it. 7:02 You're also involved in the publication of several goal-based standards, such as the Naval Submarine Code, LR's Submarine Assurance Framework, and LR's Code for Unmanned Submarine Systems. 7:14 So with that kind of background and understanding, I'm sure, like, it's... 7:19 I know that Lloyd's Register, you guys are really well known for your marine and offshore industry work, for helping clients design and to construct and operate. 7:29 But some of what you're saying there, I guess I could ask you, that's probably why the Navy goes to, to LR for these types of services. Is that correct? Yes. I mean, we talk about... Again, 7:44 this is a common thread that I want to get across about the differences and similarities between the commercial and the naval world. 7:50 In the commercial world, if you had a refit that went on for twelve months, something's probably gone drastically wrong, and people probably would get made redundant. 7:59 But as we see in the naval world, with very complex assets, there's very long maintenance periods, very long refits as well. And we get asked this by, by navies, "Actually, how would Lloyd's help us? 8:13 What is the benefit of using Lloyd's?" And we go, "Well, actually, using Lloyd's can help to increase operational availability." 8:22 And i-if you're an admiral, you want to get your assets at sea, you want to get them performing, doing what they do. They're not much use to you alongside. But from a Lloyd's point of view, from kind of 8:34 material readiness and material assurance, operational availability is kind of broken down, and there's two parts. There's operational readiness and operational sustainability. 8:45 When we talk about operational readiness, that is the kind of ability for the submarine to leave the dock side and conduct missions. In order to do this, it's, has it done its maintenance correctly? 8:58 Does the Navy have sufficient confidence that the maintenance has been done to the correct standard, and they can sign that certificate to say that that submarine can leave the wall? 9:09 In this way, this is how kind of Lloyd's supports, as I mentioned, about embedding surveyors into, alongside the dockyard to support submarine maintenance and act as an extra arm for the Navy to witness it with those kind of experiences of surveyors that have seen it, kind of done it, and can provide that independent third party back to the Navy, that they've got the confidence that that vessel can leave. 9:34 So once we talk about, that's operational readiness and how LR supports. But also, you've got operational sustainability. Once you're actually on mission, can you stay on mission for that intended duration? 9:47 And this is kind of where LR's global network really comes into play about supporting a naval asset from its home port. 9:55 So we've got the, the maintenance has been done, it's been verified, it's been tested, but actually a vessel kind of staying at sea for months at a time, how it can support into that network as well. 10:08 We've several kind of high-profile naval deployments gone around the world where they've done forward maintenance and ports, where the local LR surveyor with the n- with the na- right naval experience and qualifications has come on and supported that period on those kind of Lloyd's assets. 10:25 And also getting the supply chain when you're forward-based as well. Where do you look for for your maintenance? How do you know that pump is the pump I want? 10:34 And it's that kind of confidence of seeing that kind of Lloyd's assurance process, that Lloyd's certification in there as well. 10:40 So when you're doing that work, it is all kind of fitting in together, and this kind of all supports the piece of kind of operation availability. So that is kind of 10:51 another thing why a navy would go to Lloyd's for support as well, is we're seeing that navies are not always building in their country. 10:59 They're actually looking at building in countries that have got that pedigree of continuous submarine building, such as if we take Canada, for example, we can look at Germany, and we can look at South Korea, both highly experienced coun- countries for building conventional submarines. 11:18 And actually, another kind of benefit of Lloyd's is that Lloyd's have surveyors who can speak the language, understand the culture, and have those working relationships in the yard. 11:29 So the Navy doesn't have to keep people out there, but Lloyd's kind of supports its assurance, 11:34 as you would say, boots on the grounds, and provide an assurance back to the Navy that it, once it gets its new asset, it can put it into a certification regime and maintain it into a certification regime. 11:47 One of the things that we see when we see these programs is we see the kind of very exciting pictures, the kind of capability, but one of the things we need to get across is actually how do you maintain that capability and keep that capability going for its lifetime Or maybe longer than its predicted lifetime. 12:05 Because again, the trend we're seeing at the moment is actually on the surface ship side, is that kind of growing room in surface ships. Growing rooms are submarines that luxury don't have. 12:16 So it, it's, it's very interesting, but again, this is kind of how Lloyds can support a navy in kind of building a new asset or keeping their existing assets at sea and trying to get the most availability out of those assets. 12:31 Sounds almost, so you're a standard that ensures connectivity between the designers and the builders of the submarine to make sure those standards meet the needs of what the Navy wants to fit what they're trying to do and what their purpose is. 12:48 Yes, we're very much an independent third party, so we kind of sit in that triangle between builder and navy. We're not the one that gets the milestones or gets the asset in there. 13:00 We had instances where we presented certificates where actually it's up for the Navy to accept. 13:05 But in the commercial world, if Lloyds pulls a certificate or writes defects on a certificate, that commercial ship cannot sail till it's rectified. In a naval world, that is a very, very different proposition. 13:18 It is up to the Navy. They can override it. But again, they've got to go to their own internal regulator saying, why they've overwritten Lloyd's register now as well. 13:26 It's almost an independent balance, I would describe Lloyd's in this kind of purpose, and it's a model that's been working in the kind of surface ship world for hundreds of years. 13:39 I'd be interested to know what kind of lessons have been learned for, in supporting a global fleet of in-service ships to supporting submarines in service? 13:51 Again, to talk about where we are now, we have to look back at the kind of why you'd work from a classification society and what does a classification society kind of bring in there as well. 14:01 Lloyd's currently classes sixteen percent of the world's fleet, which is about two hundred and forty-five million tons. And a quarter of new ships every year are built to LR class. 14:14 So that kind of shows the volume and, that LR is dealing with every year and it, new construction and in service. So that kind of experience 14:25 is the kind of lesson that's learnt that we're kind of pulling through that when we're talking about surveyors doing in-service ships, they're not kind of fresh out the box surveyors. 14:35 Those surveyors have been around the world, they've seen a lot. They know what good looks like. Importantly, they know what bad looks like as well. So it's that kind of experience on the ground in there as well. 14:47 And also, the kind of, as I mentioned before, twenty-five years of naval rules of kind of supporting naval assets. A navy is a very, very different operator to a commercial operator. 15:00 A commercial operator, we're like, "I want a container ship this size. Let's go. Build it to plan." Straightforward to the rules. The Navy goes, "I want this type of capability." 15:13 Someone designs this capability, and actually going through those design spirals, capability will change, different standards will be brought in. 15:21 I mean, we have to look at what's happening at the moment in the world, such as kind of autonomy. How do you build in autonomy? How do you counter drones? But when the ships were designed, this wasn't included in there. 15:36 So it's having that ability, we found for Lloyds, it's the ability to tailor in standards and build up that certification in a goal-based process of asking the right questions based on those experience of the types of questions we need to ask. 15:52 For example, is where do you want to use it? If you're buying it off the shelf, the off-the-shelf model, is that, say, where you want to take it? 16:01 I mean, a great example, if we look at the Canadian submarine tender is polar regions. If we're buying off the shelf, are they designed to fit into that polar regions? 16:10 Do we need to look about putting polar standards into that kind of specification and justifying the standards we've got? 16:17 This is something that Lloyds have kind of developed over time, is that kind of specification, that justification of those standards can kind of reach into there as well. 16:26 And again, one of the most important areas I would say is that it's back to the supply chain of understanding where your equipment is coming from, and it's not that I'm buying from my supplier in my country. 16:38 That supplier may be subcontracting to another supplier in a different country. And how do you know the quality, what's been brought into the supply chain, and going into that submarine through material traceability? 16:51 I mean, one of the greatest anecdotes I like to use is that the tugboat towing out the ship or submarine sometimes can have more material traceability than a naval vessel, but one costs probably ten times more than the other. 17:05 So it's, again, you've got that kind of commercial class experience, but you can apply that to a navy from a model that works and has been working for, like, the, the world's fleet. 17:17 So we don't have to use class in terms of rules. We can use the classification toolkit and actually pull out the things we want. 17:25 So we're still assuring material certification, supply chain, works approval, new construction, survey, in-service testing, all that kind of experience to kind of keep the assets doing what they need to do. 17:37 So that, that, the benefit of using a class society is that experience, that knowledge, and that kind of breadth of detail in there as well. Matthew, the technology's constantly changing too. 17:51 As the technology comes in l- online, it's got to be incorporated into the design for the submarines. But how do you deal with that? Oh, again, that is the kind of million-dollar question, as they say, on that one. 18:06 Because as we find- Traditionally, naval standards are updated and designed for that project. Once that project is there, they look after that. 18:16 But when we look at the kind of new project, then there's a review of actually how do those standards fit if I want to bring in some new technology. And again, it's out there in the commercial world 18:31 that Lloyds doesn't create the standards and rules. Industry tells Lloyds where it needs to... where it's going, and Lloyds goes, "Okay, industry's going that way. We're looking at alternative fuels. 18:42 We're looking at the IMO twenty fifty targets on emissions. What can we use to put in there as well?" So methanol, ethanol, LNG. Okay, we have to start writing standards to assure that in these ships. 18:56 The kind of two examples we pull out from my experience is the technology qualification process, where we deconstruct the technology, and then we use a risk-based certification process to assure that technology as to how we know what it is, we know how it's integrated, we know the consequences of that, so we can go through those steps and build an assurance regime together. 19:21 This has kind of led to the other week, we've certified a remotely operated hydrogen-powered vessel. If you asked five years ago, there was no standards for that. But we've done it, and it's been accepted by a regulator. 19:35 One of the areas that's very applicable to submarines is battery technology and air-independent propulsion systems. 19:42 Again, this is where we can kind of take Lloyds' experience of alternative fuels, oxygen, hydrogen, combining those together for endurance systems on submarines. You know, how do you manage a gas in a tank underwater? 19:56 Or we've had the other one, lithium batteries. We've seen those articles you see about electric cars catching fire. Batteries catching fire on a submarine is, um, is a very, very bad day indeed. 20:07 It's actually assuring that, though that technology is fit for purpose in that environment in there as well, what we're gonna do with it, how important is it? If it fails, what happens to the submarine? 20:21 Do we have the right standards, or don't we have the right standards? What do we need to add? And actually, how is Lloyds gonna as-assure to kind of support the safety case of that materials, survey, yard, and actually, 20:36 what evidence does the Navy need, or the designer or manufacturer need to come sign it off and issue it, or from ourselves to issue a type approval certificate or a Lloyds certificate to say, "We've seen it, and this is what it's done," to provide that kind of independent assurance. 20:55 Matthew, I wanna talk a little bit about operating aging submarines. How can LR help with extending the life of the assets? This is something, John, I've got personal experience with, actually. Right. 21:08 A-a-aging submarine and going beyond its designed life. This is absolutely a huge topic for navies of, "How do I keep my asset going beyond its designed life? 21:17 I want it to do a very different role than it was intended to do when it was first built and new." So it is a huge question of relational management, life cycle modeling, condition assessments as well. 21:30 For example, on a submarine, we have a capability in Lloyds where we can independently model submarine structures and understand the fatigue cycles that they're loading on now as well. 21:41 We can model in that kind of corrosion and go, "Okay, well, that, that could last you another ten years based on this operational profile as well." And another thing to mention is submarines are very secret. 21:54 We don't always know how submarines are operated. Do they drive it like a sports car, or do they drive it very, very carefully? I suspect if you asked the last CO who operated it, he'll say very, very carefully. 22:08 So we've got to build in that kind of assumptions. So if we take the pressure and go, actually, the pressure looks good based for this operation, but actually, we want to upgrade the capability of it in there as well. 22:22 And actually, we want to go to places that were hotter than originally intended. How do we actually update the submarine and do that standards justification? Or, or sensors, how do we provide that power? 22:35 That power needs cooling. It's those kind of questions that we need to ask. And again, it's back to what I was previously saying of kind of finding the appropriate standard. Is it, is it correct? Can we, can we do it? 22:48 Can we ask those kind of goal-based questions in there as well? 22:52 And it's that kind of approach of step-by-step asking that question, that kind of structural methodology, that kind of deep technical expertise that Lloyds has in parts of the business of where we sit in a different area. 23:06 I'm still very surprised and amazed by what we have and kind of where we find it. 23:10 I talk to someone actually in an area that I never expect to help me, but they are the experts in that field, and that question is raised in that naval environment. 23:19 So we can kind of support it across an asset life cycle. Lloyds has been, like I said, in the marine industry, offshore installations. 23:28 Once they're out, they're not designed to come back onshore until they're getting decommissioned. How do you manage those assets? And there's very, very harsh conditioning. 23:37 So Lloyds has got lots of kind of through life cycle modeling simulations. It has that kind of technical experience, that kind of understanding. 23:46 We can put people into teams, so we can see it and map it as well, and that kind of trend analysis as well. We've seen what platforms are doing or how materials behave over the age. 23:57 Because we've got that data, we can bring to bear, because sometimes you find that navies will have limited data based on the amount of platforms they've got or how they're being used in there. 24:07 But it's a common question across the board in life cycle monitoring and how you can do it, especially these more complex assets coming in line. 24:16 And what you find is now that- Assets have been designed with a kind of life extension on them as well, just in case they have to go further, because they know they probably will need to go further dealing with different threats or environments they might see. 24:29 A lot of it comes back to our experience with surface ships and the commercial world about extending these platforms and keeping them going. You've been listening to Vanguard Radio, 24:41 and I want to thank our special guest, Matthew Palmer, Global Commercial Lead for submarines with Lloyd's Register. 24:48 We've talked about technology, the parallels be- between design and construction, and meeting the expectations of what the Navy wants and the product that they get, the difference between ships and submarines. 25:00 Matthew, I want to thank you very much for coming on the show. 25:02 It's been very interesting, and I know that you guys are going to be at this year's Deep Blue, so I think you'll have some interesting things for people to hear and see. 25:11 Yes, thank you, John, for having me, and it's always dangerous asking a submariner to talk about submarines and given the time limits. 25:16 But yes, I will be in Deep Blue person, so if anyone does want to find me, more than happy to talk, talk to us about it in detail as well. 25:24 So, like, again, John, thank you for having me and letting me talk about what Lloyd's Register do in the submarine space. Thank you so much. 25:34 The views, information, or opinions expressed during the Vanguard Weekly Podcast Series, CGE Weekly Podcast Series, Vanguard Radio Podcast, and CGE Radio Podcast are solely those of the individuals involved and do not represent those of Vanguard or any affiliated media products, their employees or owners. 25:53 Vanguard Magazine, Canadian Government Executive Magazine, and its affiliates are not responsible for and do not verify for accuracy any of the information contained in this podcast series. 26:04 This podcast may not be copied or distributed without express written approval of Promotive Communications Inc., PCI. You may not edit, modify, or redistribute this podcast without consent from PCI. 26:15 PCI assumes no liability for activities in connection with this podcast or for use of this podcast with any other website, computer, or playing device.