Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Welcome back to another episode of Vanguard Radio. I'm your host, J. Richard Jones. Today we're gonna further examine, uh, the area of the IDEaS program. 0:18 We've talked about this in previous episodes, uh, of our show. 0:22 And as a quick refresher, the, uh, the IDEaS program, otherwise known as the Innovation for Defense Excellence and Security, is a program that is designed to improve DND's access to the creative potential of Canadian innovators to build, um, and innovate an ecosystem for national defense. 0:44 It really does help, uh, to improve and to take ideas and move things along, uh, in a, in a quicker type of process, and there's a number of elements that are involved in that. 0:56 Today we're gonna examine a pretty big problem that, um, that plagues the Navy ships. It's, uh, the title of our program as such today is Rust Never Sleeps: Detecting Corrosion Above Aboard Navy Ships. 1:11 Um, this is an issue that's no, no major thing to tackle, and in this episode of Vanguard Radio, we're gonna talk about that problem a little more, and we're gonna talk about different ideas and how we can detect and assess corrosion behind the surface coatings such as paint, insulation, tiles, and seamless decking on board the, uh, Royal Canad- Canadian Navy, RCN platforms in order to reduce corrosion's operational impact and improve the effectiveness of scheduled and unscheduled maintenance. 1:47 Now, to tell us a little bit more about that is Mr. Tom Muise, Sandbox and Test Drive Manager for IDEaS. A little bit more about our guest. 1:58 Tom Muise is retired from the Canadian Armed Forces as of January 2018 after 34 years of service. He joined the communication reserves in 1980 and transferred to the regular force in 1985 as a pilot. 2:14 He was then selected to fly search and rescue helicopters and completed tours in Comox, BC and Gander, Newfoundland, flying the CH-113 Labrador, as well as an exchange posting with the United States Coast Guard in Cape Cod with the HH-60J, uh, Jayhawk, and he was also a commanding officer in the 413 Squadron in Greenwood with the CH-149 Cormorant. 2:43 Tom was also a project director for the Canadian SAR helicopter acquisition. He went on an operational deployment as the commanding officer of Camp Mirage in support of Afghanistan in 2005. 2:57 He was also an air operations advisor for Expeditionary Operations headquarters in Ottawa. 3:04 From 2010 to 2013, he was the Director of Strategic Plans for the Royal Canadian Air Force, and from 2013 to 2018, he worked as a commanding officer at the Defense Research and Development Canada, DRDC, military support unit. 3:21 Since January 2018, he has been the Sandbox and Test Drive Manager for IDEaS. Tom, welcome to Vanguard Radio. Oh, thanks very much for having me. It's a pleasure to be here. Okay. 3:35 So, so to begin, Tom, tell us a little more about Sandbox. What is Sandbox? 3:42 I guess at, at the very base level, a sandbox is just an opportunity for innovators with, you know, new prototypes, uh, giving them an opportunity to demonstrate their prototypes to the Canadian Armed Forces, and so an opportunity for the Canadian Armed Forces to learn what's out there and to give their opinion on those devices back to the innovator. 4:03 So that helps the innovator perhaps improve their product down the road, and it helps DND and the Canadian Armed Forces understand what the art of the possible is so that we can see if we can solve our problems. 4:14 So it's an experimental testing platform? 4:19 Um, you can think of it as being an experimental testing platform, but probably the word demonstration is a bit better than experimental, um, 'cause they are short duration demonstrations. 4:29 Um, and it's not DND testing the item. It's the innovator who operates it and shows it to us, and then we give them feedback on what we think about it. I see. 4:41 So as that relates to corrosion, what's, what's the Corrosion Detection in Ships, CDIS, Sandbox all about? I, I can see that this is a big problem. 4:51 There's probably a lot of expense, and, and if proper maintenance is done, it would probably save a lot of dollars. No, a- absolutely, and it, and it's not just a problem for the Canadian Navy. 5:01 It's a problem for, you know, shipping worldwide. Uh, corrosion is, is that constant battle that is going on. 5:08 Um, and it's just about how can you mitigate and understand it, uh, so that you can reduce your cost as much as possible, and not just the financial cost of the repairs you have to make, um, but there's also a cost to the department when a ship is unavailable because of the, the maintenance is taking longer than we might have anticipated. 5:26 So there's that operational impact of the ship being out of service while it's in maintenance cycles. So anything- Cost... we can do to improve that is really good. Cost of delay. Yeah, that's an important point. 5:38 I'm, I'm just thinking about what's going on with all the shipping lines right now. I could imagine if anything, uh, in other sectors were delayed, that would be a major problem and have big costs associated with it. 5:49 Yes. And, and there, there's nothing unique to the Royal Canadian Navy for, for those corrosion issues. Uh, like I say, it, it, it just goes across, uh, all, all kinds of machinery corrodes all the time. 6:01 So you just have to manage that corrosion as best you can. Yeah, for sure. Uh, the pandemic itself has had so many effects. 6:09 It's, it's, it's been a very tough thing to work through for a number of businesses and, and a number of different industries as well. Um, out of it, there has been quite a bit of innovation in technology. 6:20 I'd be curi- curious to ask you, um, how has COVID-19 affected your sandbox? 6:28 Um, it, it's had a huge impact on sandboxes because fundamentally a, a sandbox is about physically getting people together in the same geographic location in a physical, uh, environment sense where we can see demonstrations of actual products against actual problems. 6:46 So when you overlay the, all of the travel restrictions we've had, it's made the conduct of sandboxes, uh, virtually impossible, but that doesn't mean the entire IDEaS program has come to a stop because we do other, other things that we do in a more virtual sense where we have innovators that are working within their own lab spaces to develop things. 7:04 But when you get to the sandbox stage of actually demonstrating, people need to travel, and travel and the pandemic just are not a good match right now. 7:13 But, but that situation is improving, and we're hoping to get sandboxes underway again shortly. Oh, that's great news to hear. 7:19 Ha- have you been doing any virtual, uh, meetings at all for some of your, your tests and, and examinations? 7:26 Uh, we have been able to have conversations with people that have applied to come to the corrosion sandbox, uh, because we tried to do it, uh, in April of 2020, um, but that's just when the pandemic hit, so that forced us to, to not conduct that one, and we postponed it for a year. 7:46 Um, and then when it didn't happen again in 2021, we did have, um, some time with each company just in a virtual sense just to discuss their products, but it's not a great replacement for when you really wanna see the rubber hit the road and how well does it actually work in a, in a functioning environment. 8:04 So, um, we've had to postpone it again from April '21, and now we're trying to do it in April 2022. 8:11 And if we look at the way travel is starting to open up with people being vaccinated and being able to travel again, um, I think we're on much more solid ground that it will actually happen this time around. 8:22 Well, that's good news. Um, coming back to the issue of detecting corrosion, what, what scenarios do you examine for, for that type of sandbox? 8:34 So that, that's a, that's a really good question because the scenarios you wanna examine impact how you design and the actual sandbox environment you're gonna set up. 8:43 You know, what kinds of equipment are you gonna have available for examining? What kind of facilities do you need? How many companies do you bring? And which kind of technologies are, are you interested? 8:53 So when we looked at this problem, um, we've ended up pick- picking a location in the Halifax Harbor, which will enable us to use a, some, um, 9:03 simulated examples of corrosion where we know what the corrosion is, but because it gets covered by paint and things like that, then they, the innovators have to come in and prove that they can find that. 9:14 So we've narrowed it down to looking on corrosion of steel that's out of the water, uh, as in the top side of ships, versus corrosion that happens on the hull that's in the water, so there's an underwater component to what we're looking for. 9:29 And then we find corrosion on deck plates, which are large, flat expanses, versus corrosion on pipes, which is, presents a very different technical problem. 9:40 Um, and then there's connecting structures, uh, that can happen, and then you also get corrosion inside the, the many different tanks that are inside a ship as well. 9:48 So there's a whole range of different physical setups because different physical setups are gonna impose different technical challenges on how a corrosion sensor is gonna be able to perform in those different environments, and it may not be all one solution. 10:02 There could be solutions that work in one area but not in another, so we're open to all of those. 10:08 So that's why you choose those scenarios then, to get the best plethora of, of testing and, and to meet all the different requirements. Yes, e- e- exactly. 10:17 And for the sandbox itself, um, because we need to know the extent of the corrosion when someone does a demonstration, so we have built, uh, and pre-corroded a variety of test panels, uh, for all those different scenarios, and then the innovator gets to come and, you know, scan, you know, scenario number one, and they tell us what they think they've found, and we can compare it against what we know is there to see if it's there. 10:43 Because the, the corrosion itself will, will be hidden from sight during the simulations, you know, painted over or, uh, covered in insulation or things, just like it would be on a ship. 10:55 So once you get these results in, how are they used? That's really gonna be up to the Navy, and, and I'm not a representative of, of the Navy, and, and I'm not a corrosion expert. But 11:05 by understanding, um, how well different detectors work against those different scenarios, they will be able to make decisions down the road to say, "Is this a technology that is worth pursuing? 11:19 Uh, should we go and try and buy some of these devices when they become available on the marketplace?" So it's, it's to inform them of ways that they can try and, um, monitor corrosion on ships, uh, down the road. 11:34 Well, that makes a lot of sense. So I'd be curious, uh, what's next, uh, what's gonna be in your sandbox next, Tom? Uh, as- aside from the corrosion sandboxes? Yep. 11:45 Um, so the, uh, we are just really starting to reboot with a, with an ability to start planning new ones because we, we did have to be on hold while the pandemic was going on, but now there seems to be that glimmer of light at the end of the tunnel. 11:57 Um, we're looking at doing a counter unmanned aerial system sandbox, um, most likely in perhaps, uh, summer to, to fall of 2022 in terms of when it actually happens. 12:11 So we're hoping to announce that, um, early in the new year, um, with the, what the structure of that sandbox would look like and what kinds of partic- peculiarities that we're looking for, uh, to address in that problem space. 12:24 Because we did do a similar sandbox in 2019, which is coming up on three years ago, 12:30 um, by t- by the time 2022 rolls around, and we need to go back and reexamine that problem because like many defense problems, they, they never quite go away because technology is evolving. 12:43 Uh, the threats against us are always evolving, so the same kind of problem can resurface. 12:49 Uh, even though you may have looked at it once before, uh, the problem resurfaces in, in another few years, and you need to go back and reexamine those challenges again. You've been listening to Vanguard Radio. 13:00 Our special guest today has been Mr. Tom Muise, and he is sandbox and test drive manager for IDEaS. 13:09 We've been talking about the sandbox program, and we've been also talking about a major problem for Navy ships, which is detecting corrosion. 13:18 Uh, recently, uh, Tom and his team were actually at the Deep Blue Forum, which took place on October 28th and 29th. 13:26 There will be a call for applications coming out on November 3rd with regards to the, uh, detecting corrosion program. If you'd like to have more information, please refer to the IDEaS website. 13:40 Tom, I'd like to, uh, thank you for sitting down with Vanguard Radio. 13:44 No, thanks very much for the opportunity, and it's, uh, it, it's useful to us to pass our messages on to as many people as possible, so thanks very much. [outro music]