Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Welcome back to another episode of Vanguard Radio. I'm your host, J. Richard Jones. Today, we're going to be talking about submarine sustainment. 0:17 It's a complex and, uh, difficult subject. It's, it requires a lot of specialized knowledge and expertise for sure. 0:24 Um, just talking about areas of maintenance, uh, timelines for acquisition, sustainment, making the move from, you know, Victoria-class level subs to a new and larger fleet, there's just so much to get into. 0:37 And joining me to talk more about that is our special guest, Mr. Tony March, who is Vice President for Marine and Mission Systems at Babcock Canada. Tony, welcome to the show. Thanks very much for having me. Yeah. 0:51 It's a lot of good stuff. I'm excited to, uh, be having this conversation with you. Um, why don't we jump right in? Let's, let's talk a little bit about the release of the Canadian Patrol Submarine Project RFI. 1:03 Um, what role do you see Babcock Canada playing? 1:08 I think, you know, as you, as you said, John, there's a lot of, you know, submarines are really complicated and complex engineering that require a lot of specialized support. 1:18 Uh, I really was encouraged in that request for information that Canada is looking really deeply at how they do the sustainment and in-service support and quite a bit beyond just the acquisition of the platform. 1:32 And I really see Babcock's role, having, you know, been involved in submarine sustainment for the past sixteen years, uh, as playing a very large and pivotal role in the sustainment and in-service support of the Canadian patrol submarine going into the future. 1:51 Well, I mentioned a little bit about the Victoria class. Um, with the Victoria class, there was no design authority from the builder, and, uh, that role had to be assumed by Canada. 2:02 There are now multiple submarine builders competing for the Canadian Patrol Submarine Project. 2:09 As, as the incumbent in service support provider, what role do you see them playing in the acquisition, the transition, and the warranty, and in-service support phases of this project? 2:23 So I think, you know, design authority is really fundamentally about who gets to make the technical decisions around the asset, and that's a really, really important role. 2:34 Uh, the original equipment manufacturers, we believe, should have an enduring role in supporting the design authority in making those decisions. 2:45 And having that access and that reach back to the, the original design will really benefit Canada in delivering the operational outputs they're expected. 2:56 Uh, you know, the OEM also will play a role in helping build the Canadian workforce and determine what skill sets are needed and how the development of the required people is gonna happen in order to generate, uh, that. 3:15 You know, there's, you know, shifting from operating four submarines and sustaining them on a third line basis on one coast to eight to twelve submarines being sustained on two coasts is really no small undertaking. 3:28 Uh, and getting that transition right is important. 3:31 So I think the OEM's gonna have a real pivotal role, uh, working with the in-service support provider, uh, both in the acquisition and through the life of the class as it progresses in service for thirty-plus years. 3:45 Um, correct me if I'm wrong, but I think the initial, 3:49 uh, operation targets for, for operation capability are being suggested as two thousand and thirty-five for platform delivery and two thousand and thirty-seven for the initial, uh, capabilities and operations. 4:04 Um, those are pretty ambitious targets for submarine acquisition, aren't they? How do you, how do you su- foresee acquisition and in-service support unfolding in terms of procurement strategies and contracting? 4:15 Well, I think the Navy has been really clear on the need to get, uh, a new submarine as quickly as possible, and the Victoria class are aging. You know, they're over thirty years old. They've served very well. 4:28 They're a very effective submarine, operationally capable, uh, but they are approaching the end of life, and as things get old, they require more and more maintenance to continue to operate. 4:39 Uh, I think that how Canada delivers the in-service support is a really great question. 4:46 Uh, and certainly I'm encouraged, very encouraged, that Canada is looking, as I said, more deeply at how you do in-service support at the acquisition, how those things come together. 4:55 There's multiple contracting models that could be used in that space. Canada's progressing through the sustainment business case analysis. Us, along with other industry partners, are contributing to that. 5:07 We're certainly really looking forward to more fulsome engagements, uh, around the sustainment business case analysis to provide our input into Canada. Uh, what contracting model they pick will be very important. 5:19 What we would say is it is critically important to select that model, select your team as early on in the process as possible. You cannot be doing it at delivery of the asset. You will have missed 5:34 years and years of opportunity to build an optimal solution. So what I'd say is I'd strongly encourage Canada to, as closely couple as possible, the acquisition and the in-service support selection. Yeah. 5:47 Um, the foreign submarine builders will have little experience in the delivery of capability in Canada. 5:55 Uh, Tony, based on the sixteen years of experience that Babcock has in submarine in-service support for the Royal Canadian Navy, what are some of the key elements they must consider in transitioning from build to in-service support? 6:13 Probably wanna highlight four things. So the first is a Canadian, a Canadian supply chain and how you tran- how you transition a foreign design and foreign equipment supply chain into Canada. 6:24 We successfully did that with Victoria class. Over ninety percent Canadian suppliers involved in that program. 6:32 That's important not just from a Canadian content and industrial benefit perspective, but from a sovereign capability lens. 6:39 Uh, infrastructure and human resources, you know, that's really, really important for how you set this up. 6:45 As I've said, two co- one coast through line support, shifting to two coasts, more submarines, more maintenance, more people needed. 6:53 Uh, the government structures that go around managing a very technically complex asset with a robust safety management system, uh, what Canada uses may be different from what, uh, foreign builders are used to. 7:08 Doesn't necessarily mean we're gonna use the same safety management systems or same processes that we use today, but there is a navigating that particular path will be important. 7:18 And then the digital tool sets, you know, we're in, we're in a digital world. 7:22 You know, how you integrate not just the physical platform, but the digital platform into the, the Canadian defense support ecosystem, uh, and how that... 7:34 You know, we really view, uh, Babcock playing a really key role in being able to help Canada with all those a-aspects. Yeah. Digital's certainly gonna play a bigger and bigger role. 7:44 Um, one of the high level mandatory requirements from the request for information is several concurrent lines of operation. 7:53 Based on the class maintenance plans you know of with each of the original equipment manufacturers, how many submarines do you believe Canada would need to meet the operational signal, to meet the maintenance needs, and have a strategic spare capacity to enable training, force development, and other activities? 8:12 I, this is a really, it's, it's a really good question, and it's really challenging to answer, um, you know, without further definition of what a line of tasking specifically means. 8:23 You know, Canada's been really clear that they wanna operate on three oceans and have submarine presence in the Arctic, Pacific, and the Atlantic. 8:33 Uh, you know, twelve submarines historically gives you the ability to, to do that, depending on the operational availability you're looking for. 8:43 You know, you may be able to generate that with less, uh, but having twelve submarines would give you some strategic depth and some resilience in the event something goes a little bit astray. 8:57 Uh, so when I hear the customer in Canada strongly advocating for twelve, uh, I would certainly understand the rationale on why they do that. 9:05 Even if you could generate slightly more availability, it's always nice to have that little bit of extra, uh, when things go not quite the way you'd planned. Oh, definitely. Yeah. 9:17 As Canada continues to refine requirements for its sustainment business case analysis, um, what themes do you believe to be important in relation to in-service support? 9:29 Well, I think the key theme is, you know, you've, I've talked about you've got a complex stakeholder environment, is getting everybody who's involved in delivering submarine availability aligned to a single, clearly articulated goal. 9:44 And readiness and availability is that. What I would offer is the goal that needs to really be the touchstone. 9:51 So getting people and getting the organizations, whether they're inside government, whether they're in industry, whether they're in the Navy, aligned, that everybody is on a common objective of operational days that, that the enterprise is trying to generate will be absolutely critical. 10:09 And then everything will start to, to build back from that. So getting that availability and then having accountability and really understanding who's accountable to make the decisions that drive that availability. 10:23 Uh, having those things defined at the outset will set this program and set the Canadian patrol submarine up for success into the future. 10:32 Tony, I, I wanna talk a little bit about the existing industrial base in Canada for supporting marines. 10:40 Um, can you comment on what, like, what it's taken to build it over the lasting, last sixteen years and what you see as being the necessary ingredients to continue its growth? 10:51 I talked about the transition of the supply chain. You know, that took a huge amount of effort, and that takes a lot of time. 10:58 You know, we've led the development of a network, four hundred and fifty suppliers from coast to coast, investment of over two hundred million in small and medium-sized businesses and, you know, supporting over twelve hundred highly skilled jobs as it filters down into the piece. 11:12 So, you know, that takes, takes time. That took, you know, multiple, multiple, multiple years to get up to that level. That didn't happen in one or two. It was closer to a decade. 11:22 You know, I'd offer that you, you want to, you know, we're, we're running the race, we're running that race at pace right now, and we wanna be able to hand that baton across, uh, to the Canadian patrol submarine effectively. 11:33 You wanna keep that momentum going. 11:35 So I'd say not having a break, maintaining continuity of as many of those suppliers as possible, uh, transitioning into a different class, but, you know, continuing that, not having a break in submarine, uh, submarine. 11:49 So that's, that really supports that, that delivery as soon as practicable. 11:53 Uh, you know, capacity and flexibility, you know, the reality is we're in a global demand for some of these, these key skill sets, and industry does have more flexibility. 12:04 That flexibility is not unlimited, but industry does have more flexibility to bring to bear. 12:09 You'll need a lot of, of human resources to do production work, to do engineering, to do supply chain, to do project management, configuration management, all those different areas. Submarines are a very niche market. 12:23 We've talked about it's a very specialized skill set. It's not a surface ship. It's much more mechanically dense. There's a lot of things there. 12:31 Uh, we, we feel that it's important that you acknowledge that specificity and make sure there's a clear investment path to be able to provide that capability and capacity to support Canada in the delivery. Uh, 12:48 and then, you know, as I said, you gotta bridge it across. That importance of handing that baton across is really, really important. 12:55 We saw with the introduction of the Victoria class from the previous Oberon that there was a challenge. 13:01 There was a, you know, we transitioned from an, uh, ind- uh, Canada-led in-service support model to an industry-led model. It wasn't seamless. There was a break in time. 13:10 You know, I think we really should learn the lesson from that experience and do everything we can to minimize that. 13:18 That's why I've talked about importance of in-service support concurrent with acquisition, managing the supply chain, and having a really clear people and infrastructure strategy going forward. 13:29 You know, uh, the final question, there, there's been a lot of rhetoric around the Victoria-class submarine and the Victoria in-service support contract and how we need to do things differently. 13:43 I imagine it's a pretty sensitive subject, but what are your, what are your thoughts on this? Well, yes, I think it's really important. 13:51 I think it's important to acknowledge that the sustainment of Victoria class has not achieved necessarily the outputs, uh, that Canada was really hoping for. 14:00 Uh, and I don't think we should shy away from that, and that the, the, the acknowledgement that we collectively need to build a better sustainment f- solution for the Canadian patrol submarine is absolutely true and valid. 14:15 Uh, I'd say, you know, the concept that VISC as a model, when it was, you know, developed in the early 2000s, was actually quite forward-leaning. 14:25 Uh, the challenge has become implementing that model across the enterprise. 14:30 Uh, no matter how good the solution is, you know, you really need the buy-in from all the enterprise players, and I talked earlier about the necessity of getting alignment around what are the outcomes, operational availability, and fundamentally, who is making those decisions, uh, to drive that behavior, and you get outcomes, accountability, and that'll, that will align. 14:54 So I think, you know, doing those things differently will drive some different performance. Uh, we're very open to leveraging the experience we've gained over the last sixteen years a- and sharing that. 15:06 You know, there's a lot of things that have gone right, uh, through the last sixteen years of sustainment of the Victoria class, notably the supply chain, development of a sovereign capability of submarine engineering experts in the country, and there's a lot that needs to be, uh, a lot to be gained there. 15:23 Uh, so I think there's a lot to be learned, uh, and a lot that we can add to those conversations. 15:30 We certainly look forward to doing that, uh, and look forward to, uh, a new Canadian patrol submarine operating under a new and improved sustainment model in the future. 15:40 [upbeat music] You've been listening to Vanguard Radio, and our special guest has been Mr. Tony March. He's Vice President of Marine and Mission Systems with Babcock Canada. We've talked about submarine sustainment. 15:55 It's complex. It's difficult, and it does require specialized knowledge and expertise, and our guest has shed so much on it, and we've covered so much more than that. Tony, thank you so much for coming on the show. 16:08 Thanks for having me. 16:12 The views, information, or opinions expressed during the Vanguard Weekly Podcast Series, CGE Weekly Podcast Series, Vanguard Radio Podcast, and CGE Radio Podcast are solely those of the individuals involved and do not represent those of Vanguard or any affiliated media products, their employees, or owners. 16:30 Vanguard Magazine, Canadian Government Executive Magazine, and its affiliates are not responsible for and do not verify for accuracy any of the information contained in this podcast series. 16:41 This podcast may not be copied or distributed without express written approval of Promotive Communications Inc., PCI. You may not edit, modify, or redistribute this podcast without consent from PCI. 16:52 PCI assumes no liability for activities in connection with this podcast or for use of this podcast with any other website, computer, or playing device.