Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Welcome back to another episode of Vanguard Radio. I'm your host, Jay Richard Jones. It's a pleasure to be with you today. 0:15 Today, we're gonna talk a little bit about employment opportunities, talent, and the challenges. Uh, we're gonna hone in specifically on, in the defense industry, but, uh, it's... 0:27 some of the things we're talking about are not just limited to that. 0:31 When it comes to talent, there's the challenge of attracting and retaining talent, and if you are the talent, it's, uh, the challenge of finding companies and, and people that wanna value what you do and that are a good fit for your career. 0:46 Our guest today joining us is James Baker, CEO at Keynote Search. 0:52 Keynote Search is a full service executive search and recruitment firm, and they have a very unique proposition because they guarantee success based on a 12-month program. Welcome to the show, Mr. Baker. 1:09 Thanks for having me. I'm looking forward to this. Uh, and I appreciate the introduction as well. 1:14 So let's talk a little bit about, um, what are some of the biggest pressures on talent right now within the defense sector. And, uh, I know you guys are also targeted to other segments as well. 1:26 Maybe for the benefit of our listenership, you could, uh, tell us the other areas that you cover off as well. Yeah, I'd be happy to. So I mean, our business, we... 1:34 There's four kind of main industries that we spend, uh, time supporting. Uh, the defense aerospace sector is one, and obviously drew us to Vanguard in particular, and, you know, your leadership. 1:43 And, uh, we also work with the technology sector. 1:46 We do a lot of work within the nonprofit space, and then we have a large kind of, uh, book of business in the financial services sector as well, and that's, uh, predominantly within Canada. 1:55 Uh, despite my accent, uh, we do kind of focus here on the domestic market. So coming back to the defense side of things, what are some of the trends that you're seeing right now within that community, James? 2:08 Uh, so despite my kind of, you know, younger complexion, you know, I've been in this business 20 years, and candidly, I've never seen a market like this. Um, you know, there's two real core problems that we're facing. 2:20 One is the availability of talent, um, so actually employees out there available, looking for work, uh, actively seeking new opportunities. And the other is the compensation pressures that are being put in. 2:30 Um, the supply-demand mix is just so horribly skewed towards employees right now. It's creating massive problems for every sector, but, you know, particularly kind of defense aerospace. 2:41 You know, I think of organizations that may have multi-year, you know, contracts, for example, you know, government contracts, which have, you know, built-in provisions for, you know, compensation increases, cost of living. 2:54 But in the last year, we've seen compensation go up between 10 and 15% for most positions. There's no way that, you know, defense companies have got those types of, uh, provisions built into their agreement. 3:05 So it's putting huge pressure onto different organizations. Um, and you know, I'm seeing a huge amount of Peter robbing Paul. Um, you know, we're seeing companies competing for the same talent. 3:17 You know, we are seeing people employed every single day being targeted by other organizations, both domestically and internationally, for new opportunities. 3:26 And so your employees have options right now, which is making it very hard for businesses to plan, um, making it very hard for them to know exactly what the makeup of their teams may be a year away, two years, three years into the future. 3:41 Um, 3:43 and what's probably the most concerning of all the problems we're seeing right now is as defense companies in particular become more technology enabled, uh, with regard to the solutions, the services they're providing, they're now competing against, uh, you know, large tech businesses who have very deep pockets from private equity, from venture capital, and can offer 4:05 at times almost absurd, absurd amounts of money for certain talent they need to move forward, which again, is counter to perhaps the compensation structures that may be in place at most defense organizations. 4:16 That's gotta be tough. It really affects planning. It affects, um, every... getting to the end result. For a large corporation, a lot of the projects that are being worked on are time sensitive. 4:27 I'd be curious, with COVID, are there other retaining factors that come into the play when, when you're negotiating some of the talent and, and, and the contracts? 4:37 And, uh, what kind of tactics are, are you using to really attract the right people and to help companies retain? 4:45 I mean, if I was to look at it from the lens of those which we're seeing more success versus others, um, you know, it's almost become table stakes that an increased amount of flexibility is a given for every new employee coming into an organization. 4:57 So, you know, we're seeing a massive improvement in the overall kind of corporate wellness programs, you know, things like increased vacation time, things like unlimited vacation time, flexibilities around work schedules. 5:11 But, you know, you look at, you know, particularly those defense companies with a manufacturing or production side to them, you know, you have to have people on site, yet you may have your corporate teams working remotely. 5:21 That creates inequity in the workplace. Um, 5:24 much easier for somebody to get, you know, 40 hours of work done when they only have to walk down the hall to their office versus somebody that may still have an hour's drive either way to work. 5:33 So we're seeing some issues with regard to internal equity for the employee experience. But, you know, we're seeing some things that are working well. 5:43 As I say, you know, corporate wellness, uh, adherence to values, and actually demonstrating the values of an organization and living by them is something that has become almost table stakes for now organizations to keep people. 5:55 Um, we've seen a real uptick in incentive programs, so bonuses, performance bonuses tied to everything from profit share to corporate performance being rolled out to wa- far wider groups of employees that perhaps were not eligible for it previously. 6:10 Um, 'cause I'll tell you, the biggest problem is if you lose talent right now, it is so, so difficult to replace them because this person's working elsewhere, um, they're probably earning good money, and the minute you make an offer to them, spend the cap runs, you're gonna get into a situation where you might be overpaying by 20% for a particular result, while also creating internal pay equity issues with, you know, their peers and teammates within the organization. 6:36 So the market is a complicated place to navigate for most organizations right now. So is it safe to say that it's an employee market right now? I would say so, yeah. 6:49 So if you're looking, certainly a seller's market if you're selling home right now, and it's certainly an employee's market if you're considering a change of employment. Um, but what's interesting is the employees are, 7:01 they're realizing that their work construct has maybe shifted. They're not necessarily going in nine to five, so they're far more aware of the work they're doing day to day and how f- that may not be that. 7:13 Um, looking at the ways they can connect with people if not everyone is working in the same office space or building as them. 7:19 So how companies are able to reinforce culture is quite often a driving force in their success of not only keeping people, but actually bringing new people to the table and compelling them to consider an opportunity with that company. 7:34 Now, 7:35 I guess it also puts a lot of pressure on, on your firm and your expertise in the sense that you've really got to try to get it right and, uh, make sure that person fits in and negotiate the right deal, the right skill sets, and, uh, the match to what the employer is looking for. 7:54 I know we were talking earlier before we began the show and, and your mission statement, you'd said, is to, to help businesses succeed through, uh, the people that, uh, you find to place in their companies. 8:07 That's not an easy task. And, and, you know, on top of that, you, you've got a 12-month, uh, success guarantee. How are you able to do that? 8:15 Like, how do you find and build these relationships and really understand and go deep? Yeah. It's, uh... 8:22 Well, fortunately, it's not that easy, otherwise we wouldn't be in business, and there wouldn't be a demand for our service. 8:26 But yeah, for us, it's about ensuring that we can be objectively reviewing and comparing the qualities of different people. 8:32 Um, so our research team, you know, right now, typically will look at anywhere between 200 and 250 different people that might be interested in a particular opportunity. We go talk to those 200, 250 people. 8:46 Um, you know, we usually expect 20% to 30% of people to express interest. You know, so that means we're interviewing anywhere between 50 and 60 people per job that we undertake on behalf of our clients. 8:56 So when I can sit down with 60 people, I can start to compare and contrast different experiences, different values, different personality styles, uh, different successes, and start to make some objective recommendations on behalf of the employer that we represent. 9:11 And so, you know, we can go from 50 down to 12, 15, take them through additional screening evaluation before we present kind of the top four or five to our client. 9:20 And from there, there's still the client's interview process, their assessment process. 9:25 But for us, it means that we're looking at solving a specific problem or challenge for the company and looking to target people that are not only capable of doing that, but are excited by doing that type of work on behalf of another organization. 9:40 Yeah, that's, uh, that's quite a process for sure. James, can you talk a little bit about the EDI challenges in, in the sector? Yeah. Um, for sure. 9:50 I mean, I'm, I'm personally, I love the conversations that have been started now around EDI. I'm, I'm pleased that there is a continued lens on ensuring that we have diverse and inclusive organizations. 10:01 And I think it's, we, we would all agree that historically, the defense sector, the military has not had as much representation as we would have liked. Um, but for me, it's, 10:14 the challenge we're having right now is in the last couple of years, uh, learning and development has been stalled. 10:20 You know, a lot of development of your skills and your experience comes from working with peers, working alongside somebody that perhaps is senior to you, somebody that's seen the problems before and can provide advice that'll stop you making the same mistakes as everybody else. 10:34 So, you know, diversity, equity, inclusion, and ensuring that you have good representation in your organization is predominantly driven right now through promotions and progression of people within your organization, which means taking people from education right through to your executive. 10:50 Um, so I'm seeing some organizations that have put in place some quite brilliant strategies around actually identifying people in post-secondary education right now and mapping a journey for them right through to the executive. 11:05 Um, there's no given to this. There's no guarantee the person gets that role, but they're making it clear what somebody high potential can bring for their organization and actually takes them through that journey. 11:16 Um, but with a more diverse workforce, with people who are gonna ask different questions due to different life experiences, different backgrounds, we're finding organizations are actually seeing huge benefits, not only to their customer experience, um, but also to the internal employee experience as well, because, you know, as much as we hate to admit it, we're pack animals. 11:37 We like to spend time with other people, and so if we can enrich those experiences and conversations, it works wonders. But defense is, 11:47 has work to do, and in my opinion, it starts with working with the post-secondaries, uh, industry associations, advocating for opportunities for a wider talent pool. Um, 11:59 also working with the federal government because, you know, we know with security clearances, there's certain parts of the world where it's more difficult to attract people from, uh, which automatically limits your talent pool. 12:10 So, um, there's work to be done, um, but I'm really encouraged by the You know, education to executive programs that I'm starting to see pop up within a number of defense organizations now. 12:22 I think the education and training is important. Creating that career path also, uh, I would think encourages people to invest with the company, um, because you can see that there's an opportunity. 12:35 Um, let's just talk a little bit about the labor market. If you had a crystal ball, what, what would you forecast out there for the next 12 to 24? Uh, it's gonna get worse. 12:45 Um, retirements in this country are, you know, consistent, uh, consistently higher than the amount of new workers that we're at, uh, able to add to the workforce. 12:54 So we are continuing to put a deficit onto our workforce right now in Canada, which means that it's gonna continue to get harder and harder to find people. Uh, unemployment is approaching record lows again. 13:06 Um, and I think we're gonna see a massive increase in counteroffer situations within companies. 13:13 Um, so I think you're gonna see that organizations are gonna have contingency funds set aside for bonuses to try and keep people if they're looking to leave. 13:23 I think we're gonna see, uh, compensation go up again by another 10 to 15%, and 13:30 I think the remedy for most organizations right now is to build in a very strong retention strategy for their organizations, because replacing key people is expensive. 13:42 Uh, and in most instances, the value and experience you're getting for an increased investment is not even at the level of what you may have lost with, uh, the incumbent member of staff. That makes total sense. 13:55 I mean, you're investing, you're going through the whole process. Uh, it's the disruption to business as well. Um, fi- final question. 14:03 James, what sets Keynote Search apart from some of the other firms in the industry that you're dealing with? I mean, it's a competitive marketplace. Yeah. I mean, I, I believe, I mean, we're fortunate. 14:16 We work in an industry in executive search where there's a number of very capable firms. Um, but when we built this company, you know, almost seven years ago now, we, 14:25 we had one kind of key thing that we said we wanted to do better than everybody else, and that was to manage the post-hire experience for employees. 14:32 Um, so I'm very fortunate to have worked with some brilliant organizational psychologists, some executive coaches, to help build, um, what we call our post-placement integration program. 14:42 Um, so every single person that we place, we actually assign an executive coach to work with that person and their direct boss, manager, um, to help integrate into the organization. 14:54 Um, we're not trying to make them better at their job. We're not trying to give them new skills, new experiences. We're trying to help them get aligned with the organization. What are the objectives? 15:03 What are the milestones? How do I communicate with both my immediate supervisor, but also the people that may work with me or below me in the organization? 15:12 And that's a, you know, a program that lasts now for the first three months of employment. 15:17 You know, there's, you know, nine deliberate steps which involves an awful lot of communication and feedback loops, so that while you may be building trust with your organization and your peers and with your colleagues, you can actually have critical conversations because somebody's there to help navigate those difficult conversations in the early weeks. 15:34 So for us, that's been a game changer. 15:37 Um, I would say it's been a game changer for the experience of new leaders that we placed in particular because they have somebody in their corner who's backing them, and often these people are significant investments for an organization. 15:49 They represent cultural change for organizations. So giving them that extra helping hand to get up to speed and perform at their very best is something that we're very proud to bring to the market. Yeah. 16:00 It's a relationship, it's a partnership, and, and that type of support and follow through is just so important, critical, I would think, to the success. 16:09 You've, uh, been listening to Vanguard Radio, and we're talking about talent and opportunities and challenges in the defense industry. It's been a very in- interesting conversation. 16:19 We've had the opportunity to speak with James Baker, CEO at Keynote Search. James, I, uh, really wanna thank you for coming on the show. It's been really interesting. Yeah. Thanks for having me. 16:29 It's been an absolute treat. Thank you. 16:31 [upbeat music] The views, information, or opinions expressed during the Vanguard Weekly Podcast Series, CGE Weekly Podcast Series, Vanguard Radio Podcast, and CGE Radio Podcast are solely those of the individuals involved and do not represent those of Vanguard or any affiliated media products, their employees, or owners. 16:59 Vanguard Magazine, Canadian Government Executive Magazine, and its affiliates are not responsible for and do not verify for accuracy any of the information contained in this podcast series. 17:09 This podcast may not be copied or distributed without express written approval of Promotive Communications Inc., PCI. You may not edit, modify, or redistribute this podcast without consent from PCI. 17:20 PCI assumes no liability for activities in connection with this podcast or for use of this podcast with any other website, computer, or playing device.