Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Welcome back to another episode of Vanguard Radio. I'm your host, Jay Richard Jones. 0:12 Today, we're gonna get into the topic of next generation of war fighter training, and I have a very special guest who's going to be joining me. 0:20 He's a retired Navy commander, and he brings more than two decades of operational and training experience in advanced air operations and joint warfare. 0:31 Now, before I introduce our guest, I wanna talk a little bit about the company that he's involved with. 0:37 Cobham is a global provider of innovative defense solutions, including military training and simulation, health services, advanced manufacturing, secure communications and connectivity, as well as digital transformation and cyber security. 0:55 We were just chatting before the show and I said, "You know, if there's just one message you could leave with our listenership and readership, what would it be?" 1:03 And he said, "We as a company wanna be remembered for providing mission-critical solutions, whether you're operating in defense, infrastructure, or cyber." I'm pleased to welcome to our show today Mr. Jay Ballard. 1:16 He's Vice President of Defense with Cobham. Jay, welcome to the show. It's a pleasure to be here. Thanks for having me. So why don't we jump right in? 1:24 You know, how is the character of warfare changing, and what does that mean to how military is trained today? You've seen it all. Yeah. 1:31 You know, when I grew up, I was a, uh, a cold warrior, and we practiced, you know, everything the Soviet Union could throw at us versus NATO, and it was a massive major combat operations that then once the, the Berlin Wall fell, uh, became counterinsurgency or, or very small wars of choice, uh, to, to correct some, uh, perceived wrongs. 1:50 So that, and then there's a long history of that. You know, several... 1:54 The Canadian Armed Forces have had 20 years of counterinsurgency, and now with, uh, Russia's in- invasion of Ukraine and we're seeing the, the w- war in Iran right now, major combat operations are back, back on the table, but they're now being fueled by, uh, technological advances, and there are a lot of things that have changed, like speed. 2:12 You know, it used to be, you know, airplanes would go fast, missiles would go fast. However, ballistic missiles being fired, uh, openly and in multiples in a theater, uh, it... 2:21 You've got, you've got seconds, uh, or very few minutes to see that launch, uh, get your radars on it, try and get missiles out in time. It just compresses the timeline. 2:32 The kill chain, what's known as it, the, the find, fix, track, target, engage, assess, uh, that the military uses, you know, when you see something you wanna shoot at, you've gotta do it very quickly. 2:41 Uh, uh, and if you don't, you're gonna lose an opportunity to take out a very valuable piece of hardware. 2:46 Mass, we're seeing mass now becoming autonomous systems, where instead of 1,000 airplanes, so that are crewed airplanes that are coming over the horizon, you may have, you know, 100 and then a whole bunch of autonomous missiles that are, that are, uh, coming. 3:01 Some of them are expensive, very expensive, uh, $3 to $4 million apiece, and some of them are very cheap, like the Loitering Munition or the Shahed, uh, uh, uh, drones, uh, one-way drones that, that are in the theater there in Iran as well. 3:13 Those are in the 25, $35,000 range. Uh, so you can see the finances are quite different between those. And civilian infrastructure. In what used to be protected during counterinsurgency, you could afford to do that. 3:26 You wouldn't strike something if there were a bunch of civilians around. Now that's being rolled back as well, uh, and, and that, that is, uh, quite a problem. 3:36 You know, there's so much going on in the world today, and we're certainly seeing a variety of technologies being used. Um, what capabilities do you think will define truly next generation military training ecosystems? 3:51 You know, uh, and that's a great question. There are, the, the classic training and the... There's two different types. You got individual training and collective training. Individual training is, is what it sounds like. 4:00 You've got an individual in. They're learning a trade for the most part. They're learning how to fire a weapon, learning how to throw grenades, uh, fire mortars, an- anything along those lines. 4:09 Uh, and, and then there's education that's associated with that. Uh, and that, that has tended to be, you get a bunch of people that are gonna be into that trade. They show up at, at a class. You go through. 4:20 You have an instructor in the front. They're using physical objects you can hold. That requires everybody to be there for that length of time. The s- the schedule of that class is set. 4:31 Uh, so everybody's gotta be there for a certain amount of time, and you're training to the kinda middle of the pack, and you can't speed anybody up. 4:38 Advancements now are that you could use augmented reality, virtual reality, or computer-based systems, and you could do that distributed. 4:45 So you can have the majority of that class, people that are going through, would be, uh, doing this work in garrison or at home. They don't have to be away from family. 4:53 Uh, and, and you're not spending money on housing them somewhere else and feeding them. So they can go through that a lot. It's more immersive, and you... Just think of it this way. 5:00 You've got the smartest instructor ever, because you've, when you put these courses together, virtual reality, you, you know everything there is. You've talked to the manufacturers. 5:09 You've got digital twinning of that, of that capability, and you go through. So the, you know, the instructor, whether it's computer-based or whatever, is extremely smart. Using adult learning techniques. 5:19 Is distributed, so 24 hours a day, seven days a week. From home you can do it. So you can increase your throughput. The, and you can advance faster if you have that individual, uh, training. 5:29 Now, there are always times when you're gonna have to bring people in for a end-to-end check. 5:33 So if you are learning how to fire artillery rounds, at some point you've gotta actually, you know, hit the button, pull the lanyard, and hear the boom, and make sure that that round is going downrange where it needs to go. 5:44 But you're at a much higher step by the time you get there, and you don't, you only have to show up for a small amount of time. Now, on the collective training side, that's where you're training teams. 5:54 You need to have psychological fidelity and, and have the fight that's going on emulated In what th-that person is going through that training, uh, they- they're talking to the people they expect to talk to. 6:08 They're, they're getting the responses and, and everything makes sense. It, it, it fits i-in there. And to do that, but from a live virtual constructive standpoint, we need to emulate what's going on in the theater. 6:19 So there needs to be actual first person view, uh, drones flying around. You need different types of cuing drones flying around. 6:27 Those are modern battlespace evolution, evolutionary steps that have to be taken into account. And quite honestly, I don't see a change of those going away. 6:35 If anything, they're gonna get even worse with swarms and, and AI behind it. So you've gotta train like you will fight, and that's gonna be a big step. 6:44 So if I hear you correctly, training has become a lot more flexible, but you still need to have the, the physical practical, but it also, being able to do training from home gives an opportunity to have a speed to market approach. 6:58 I think it's a great combination. 7:00 And with what we're seeing with the technology on the, on the physical side, yeah, you've got to experience it, and there's probably new training techniques that are gonna come out of that as well, right? Yep. Oh, yeah. 7:11 It, it's, you know, the... 7:12 Being able to do multiple iterations of something, especially extremely dangerous or hazardous environment is, is, is a key and, you know, the simulation ties into that an, an awful lot and, and how you do it. 7:23 And then from a, from a, from a technology, a doctrinal standpoint, all of the evolution, the technical evolution that has happened, it needs to be incorporated into defensive and offensive doctrine, uh, for most nations. 7:37 And if you've never done it before, now you've got to get experts in, you've got to try it, you've got to simulate it, research and development and, and just do multiple iterations of it in order to get it right. Yeah. 7:48 Jay, I wanna talk a little bit with you about C5ISRT integration. A lot of the moder- modern operations are increasingly driven by C5ISRT capabilities. 8:00 How should the training environments evolve to ensure personnel can operate effectively in panned domains, data-rich networked battle spaces? That's gotta be a challenge. Yeah. No, it, it certainly is. 8:12 And, and there's a lot, lot to that. You know, C5ISRT, command, control, communications, computers, cyber, intel, surveillance, reconnaissance, targeting. That's, it's a mouthful. No wonder they say C5ISRT. 8:23 [laughs] So, so you can imagine the amount of data. 8:25 When you're talking about all of that, that's basically all the data that's going through that you're gonna have to use and, and, uh, parse through in order to make decisions. 8:33 So the first thing is you've gotta have a good system. You have to have data that's coming in you can count on, and it has to be timely so you can make decisions in a, in a hurry, and then gauge your... 8:43 You know, make your a- uh, decide what actions you're gonna take and then gauge how that, that is. 8:48 So we refer to it, uh, in the, in the fighter community, we would say you're going into a fight, you know, you're listening to radar and you're coming in. You've got either good, no, or bad situational awareness. 8:57 Good situational awareness means what's in your head and what you see on your radar corresponds with what's actually out there. No situational awareness is you don't see this, uh, the target out there. 9:08 You're basically tumbleweed. So you've got to either, you, you... 9:11 Normally, the decision you're gonna make at that point is usually to leave because you don't know what you, what's there and you don't wanna do, you don't wanna make an error. 9:18 You don't wanna shoot a friendly or you don't wanna get shot. 9:20 And bad SA is when you're absolutely certain you know in your head what, what, what's going on, and it's wrong, and that's when you do make the, the worst decisions. 9:29 So that data come in and, and you shoot a friendly or you get shot. So you need to, to make sure you can count on the data that's coming in. It's, it's reliable. It, you can, it's timely. 9:39 You can make the right decisions you need to. And those... In, in incorporating that, you also, you need to train to speed. You know, s- I, I talked about speed, uh, early on. 9:50 It's like how fast things happen in the battle space. All the different missiles that are coming in are very fast. 9:55 Well, you gotta be able to make those decisions quickly because if you don't, your, your opponent is, is ahead of you on the decision cycle. 10:02 And until you get faster at it, you may have to turn down some of the stuff you're looking at. Like I said, a lot of data coming in. All right, I can't handle all that. 10:10 I'm gonna start reducing, figuring out what you need to filter out and reduce, and that is basically training like you're gonna fight, uh, like you will fight, and, and making the right decisions using the hardware or, or the systems you're gonna use, uh, in the real world. 10:25 Um, Jay, can we talk a little bit about synthetic training environments? They're becoming central to military preparedness. 10:33 Can we talk a little bit about the technologies that are involved in that and what things are gonna look like in the next coming decade? So synthetic environments, uh, training environments can be anything. 10:44 It could be just some maps on, on the floor and some orders that are handed, and you imagine yourself in a tent. It, that's what's referred to as psychological fidelity. 10:53 Rand did a study in 2019 that said you don't necessarily need a high-fidelity simulation or simulator in order to get, get the, the training audience interested in something that's going on. 11:05 B- Because the more interested and immersed that training audience is, they, they can actually envision themselves. They're talking on a radio to who they expect to, to talk to. They are getting responses back. 11:15 This all makes sense. It's the order of battle. It's all of the capabilities that that force is gonna have. It's all the capabilities the enemy's gonna have. It's making sense. They're gonna retain that better. 11:25 It's, it's for transfer of training, the more immersed you are, the better it is. So, and, and, and it enables you to train like you're gonna fight. 11:33 But that's really the key, and then what kind of technologies go in there. You look at what type of, what, what type of training is it? Is it gonna... Is it individual training? Uh, and some, I mentioned virtual reality. 11:44 That, that can help a lot. AI. The decision cycle and the use of AI is, is a key. What we're, what you're gonna see, and, and what's happening right now, is AI agents that can handle individual aspects like logistics. 11:59 It could be, uh, armament, how much, how much do you have? Your, your speed over, over ground. What's the enemy? What's the weather looking like? 12:07 You can have- Everything you would be looking at in a headquarters, an agent is out looking at all these different things. Now, you, you will have those. If 12:17 I can, I can foresee here very soon, there are gonna be agents developed. You're gonna start off, a unit's gonna get ready to start training. 12:24 You take these agents, and you start tweaking them early on in, when you're going through training and simulation, and you develop them f- uh, to build trust. You have to trust the technology that's out there. 12:36 So your, your actual development of the agent, you've worked with it, it's giving you, uh, data back, you, that, that seems reliable, and you can, you can bet on, that is where you're looking to get to. 12:47 You're getting, you wanna get trust out of those agents. Now, you take those agents and you deploy. So you have built trust in it, just like a p- people or, or collective training, team of teams. 12:57 You take this agent with you, and it can now, it's part of the headquarters, it's, it's helping with decision support. 13:03 And that's, you know, AI is a big part of that, the digital twinning, being able to, to, to emulate the systems and see what happens, uh, either from a friendly standpoint or enemy standpoint when it's attacked, advanced modeling, all of that are, are different aspects of, of advanced training. 13:22 But mainly, you're training people. You're, you're, you're, you're making sure cognitively that the, the humans are, are the ones getting trained, but the support is the AI. 13:34 And there's just so many tools, and it's advancing so quickly. I'd like to talk a little bit about readiness and operational outcomes. 13:41 In your opinion, what are the biggest barriers to adoption when integrating advanced training technologies in, into the CAF? 13:48 Well, there's, there's some cultural resistance to change if it looks like the technology's coming too fast and it's not proven out. So you're gonna have some resistance there. 13:57 It's like, "It's not how I was brought up, and I, and I, I've gone far along this way." And the, you know, speed of procurement, uh, could be part of it. 14:06 There could be the greatest technology out there, but the speed of getting that in the hands of the war fighters is, you know, historically has been slow, and, and, and tends to give you yesterday's technology tomorrow. 14:20 But maybe you're getting old technology 'cause that's what you've, it's taken so long to get the procurement through that, uh, that what you have is, is not gonna, gonna help you out. And then, uh, innovation has been 14:32 a bit that's not necessarily, uh, evolved well in the contracting as well. So you, you know, the CAF is gonna want innovation as part of the war fighting. Uh, 'cause we're looking at weeks. 14:45 I- in Ukraine right now, the, the, those drones that are being flown, uh- Oh, yeah... they've got a three, three-week, they're in the field for three weeks, they analyze what's going on, and then they redo it. 14:54 Within six weeks, everything is, or, or at least components, are completely redone. The tactics and doctrine are completely redone. 15:01 That speed cannot be replicated in s- standard contracting, uh, as it currently exists, uh, in Canada as well as most, most nations. 15:12 What can we do as, what, what can industry do to help take away some of the barriers or make it move a little more quickly? We have, uh, Calian Ventures, we've announced. 15:21 Uh, it's $100 million that's going into Canadian industry, and we're working with small-medium companies to get technology past the valley of death. 15:31 You know, the valley of death is where you get, uh, you know, there's, there's federal or regional money, you start developing a capability, and then you run out of money and, and people, time, or whatever. 15:42 You just can't get that technology in the hands of the war fighters, 'cause you don't have the right, uh, maybe you need a bit of mentoring, you don't have the right contracting vehicle. 15:48 You just, you just run out of money, could be part of it. 15:51 And we're trying to, to, to do, to help with that, and get those companies to that, uh, to the point where they have a fully workable solution from a technology standpoint and an innovation standpoint that is unique or really answers the challenge. 16:06 'Cause these people, you know, uh, there may be just a handful of folks that are involved in this company, just like, uh, uh, you know, Apple. 16:13 They, they're two guys working in a, in a garage, and they came up with, with Apple computers. 16:17 The, these, some of these smaller companies, they don't know what's not possible, because they're not looking at it from a, from a prime standpoint. They're not looking at it from, from a, a historic standpoint. 16:27 They're looking at it from, "I think this will, this will solve that challenge." 16:30 And that's why we're, we're betting on Canadian industry, especially the real innovators, and we wanna be part of it and help, help grow the entire defense industry. 16:39 So Jay, now with your crystal ball, looking ahead 10 to 15 years, what is military training gonna look like if we get it right? 16:49 Yeah, and I'm gonna kinda link back to the individual and collective training that I, I talked about a little bit earlier. That's gonna, the technology's gonna allow the, the higher throughput. 16:58 So more soldiers, more sailors, airmen, are gonna be trained faster, which allows a, a better force generation for the Canadian Armed Forces and, and militaries in general. 17:10 And then once the, you get the initial group through, and then you get into warfare training, extensive use of AI, uh, and, and building trust in the AI for decision support, planning, and, and threat analysis, and, and everything along those lines is gonna be, uh, part of, of, of what I would expect to see from a training aspect. 17:29 M- And, and using agents and, and getting further developed. You know, right now, we didn't talk about agents 15 years ago. 17:35 Uh, you know, there, there's some parts of this when you start looking that far out and, and you're talking about technology, I'm not real sure at how far it's gonna, gonna go, uh, beyond that, and where, where we're gonna be looking. 17:45 But human autonomous teaming, how, how humans work with machines and technology, is gonna be a major part of, of future training. 17:54 And I would expect to see that, that, you know, it reduced time in training, more effective, you'll be able to have fewer humans on the battle space, a lot more machines and technology out there, and how that all works together is gonna be probably the primary, uh, training, uh, challenge that's gonna be out there. 18:10 For instance, the, uh, the Collaborative Combat Aircraft, the CCA, that's being developed by the US Air Force and down in Australia, uh, Boeing Australia, is a autonomous wingman that's supposed to fly around with fifth gen and, and soon to come sixth generation aircraft. 18:24 How do you work with those systems is, is a challenge from a human capacity standpoint, a- and then doctrinally, how do you, how do you train to that? 18:34 Gonna be a lot of technology and innovation and training required in the future, that's for sure. Yep. You've been listening to Vanguard Radio. 18:43 I'm your host, Jay Richard Jones, and, uh, today we've been talking about the next generation of war fighter training. I wanna thank our special guest, Mr. Jay Ballard. He's Vice President of Defense with Calian. 18:56 Thank you so much for coming on the show. It's been incredibly interesting. You're welcome. Yeah, thanks for having me. Really, I really enjoyed this, this talk. 19:11 The views, information, or opinions expressed during the Vanguard Weekly Podcast Series, CGE Weekly Podcast Series, Vanguard Radio Podcast, and CGE Radio Podcast are solely those of the individuals involved and do not represent those of Vanguard or any affiliated media products, their employees, or owners. 19:29 Vanguard Magazine, Canadian Government Executive Magazine, and its affiliates are not responsible for and do not verify for accuracy any of the information contained in this podcast series. 19:40 This podcast may not be copied or distributed without express written approval of Promotive Communications Inc, PCI. You may not edit, modify, or redistribute this podcast without consent from PCI. 19:51 PCI assumes no liability for activities in connection with this podcast or for use of this podcast with any other website, computer, or playing device.