Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Welcome back to another episode of Vanguard Radio. I'm your host, J. Richard Jones, and it's a pleasure to be with you today. 0:15 We're gonna talk a little bit about the promise of trust as a catalyst for transformation, and we have two very special guests joining us today that I'd like to welcome to the show, Chris Pogue, CEO of Thales Canada, and Jeff Spencer, CEO of Atredes. 0:33 Gentlemen, welcome to the show. Thanks, John. Thanks for having me, John. Pleasure. So I'm gonna set this up a little bit. 0:42 It's, uh, it's been five years since the government of Canada awarded Thales the Aegis contract, and, uh, part of that contract includes in-service support, refit, repair, maintenance, and training for the Royal Canadian Navy's new Arctic and offshore patrol ships, and joint support ships. 1:03 And this is just probably one of the largest contracts in Canadian, uh, history for, for ISS. But in the meantime, there's the challenge of digital transformation. It's just growing in leaps and bounds. 1:20 So today we're gonna explore the relationships between technology, we're gonna talk about workflow, we're gonna talk about new partnerships, and how it all comes into helping to create better collaboration between the primes and the SMBs. 1:37 So to begin, I think the first place to kinda go is, uh, why don't we start with you, Chris? It's, it's been five years since this contract was awarded. What, what's changed? 1:49 Well, I think if we go back a bit and imagine the purpose behind the Aegis contract, obviously to support the Arctic Offshore Patrol Vessel and the joint supply ships with in-service support, as you characterized, there was a vision, I think, put in place to establish a long-term, potentially 35-year contract that would give the flexibility to ensure that as the fleet went to sea, it was gonna be supported and supportable for its lifespan. 2:15 And the idea of that scale of a contract was also driven by the idea that w- we won't shape a contract driven by specific requirements or specific things that must be delivered on a specific date. 2:28 No, we'll imagine a performance-based contract driven by two key concepts. One, ship availability, and the cost of ensuring the ships are available and at sea. 2:39 And incentives are built into these kinds of programs that ensure everybody benefits by delivering on both performance, ships at sea, and lower cost to ensure the ships stay at sea. 2:49 It, it essentially becomes a platform for innovation. 2:53 It also is coupled with the concept of relational contracting, which is really the idea of getting away from these specific requirements and building a purpose-built team between government, defense, and the industry and all the industry partners. 3:09 And I think, um, you know, I was 20, more than 20 years, John, in the, in the Canadian military in the Air Force, and had the pleasure of being involved in some procurement reform ideas while I was there, and I think this idea of a relational contract, when we learn how to do it and do it well, 3:27 really creates the potential to probably have the most dramatic impact on the way defense procures systems and ensures that they stay, um, ready and able to service the men and women who serve. 3:40 I really think that's, it's an innovation platform, it's a different way of contracting, and it's a different way of delivering capability. Five years in, we've developed some of the infrastructure to support the ships. 3:51 The ships are now at sea, two ships at sea, and a third about to go to sea. And as that happens, as more ships are added, you'll see more and more innovation and more and more capability under this contract. 4:03 So quite a bit has changed. Now, the other thing that's new is this relationship, uh, between Thales and, and Atredes. 4:14 Uh, Jeff, can you, can you tell us a little more about how that, that g- that came about between the two of you? Yeah. 4:21 Uh, things kicked off, uh, around June 2021, and, um, when it did, uh, we got together, uh, early with, uh, Alex Marie and, uh, shortly thereafter, uh, Francois, um, who's a digital champion for, uh, uh, Thales, and, and quickly started discussing, um, some of the, uh, areas of, um, opportunity within the Aegis program. 4:47 And really where, where we honed down was the, the, the cost and value of time and where that was getting, um, sucked up based off of old legacy software and as well, um, uh, applications of Microsoft Excel that weren't able to keep everyone on the same page as fast as, uh, Thales wanted to see it. 5:09 And so what we were able to do is first identify, uh, an area of need. 5:14 But, but what we said is we said, "Look, we've never worked together before," and, and at Atredes we're, we're huge into earning trust, and we said that to Thales. 5:25 We said, "If we do anything together, we wanna earn your trust before we do any kind of contractual work." And so, um, what we wanted to do was two things. 5:35 One, show that we could do the work, and two, show that we understood what outcomes were needed. And so what we elected to do was provide Thales a proof of concept of the proof of concept. 5:47 And so what we did is we got together, um, we, we zeroed in on some of the key issues, and very quickly, within a week and a half, we turned around, um, uh, resulting software that was able to demonstrate, um, where Thales, um, wanted to migrate to And from there, um, we earned our trust and, and Thales extended us, um, an R&D contract. 6:11 And, um, and this was Thales' bet on Atreides that, um, we could provide something that would provide rollout value to the rest of, uh, Aegis. 6:20 And, um, from there, we used a couple different mechanisms, um, to, to further grab consensus across, uh, the Thales workforce, and, um, use that as our product requirements for building the, the penultimate software, um, which we delivered, um, together with, um, uh, the Thales team. 6:41 Now, you guys are a, a software platform, and you're dealing, uh, in actionable data. Like, it's all about helping to deal with the intelligence of management. 6:52 What was the experience like for Thales and, and, and was this a new approach? I think it's not so much a new approach, but maybe I, I wanna pick up on a couple of Jeff's themes that I think are really important. 7:04 Um, within Thales, we've been sort of k- developing, um... So Th- Jeff meets with, uh, Alex Moreau and Francois Rioux, our digital champion. It's kind of a serendipity moment where they bump into each other at an event. 7:19 And so we've been working hard to kind of create structural ways in which those things can happen more regularly so they're not, they're not re- re- relying on a, a moment of uniqueness. 7:30 And so we'd invested significantly in a thing called AI@Centech, um, out of Montreal with Scale AI, that has so far touched over 450 startup-like companies, um, around the world, not all solely in Canada. 7:44 And so we knew from that experience that touching these startups was really helping you see innovation through a lens that you wouldn't necessarily see within the broader Thales organization. 7:54 And, and some of those innovations are because those companies absolutely thrive, uh, they stay alive by being highly innovative and focused on a unique customer problem, just as Atreides is. 8:04 The other piece then that we moved towards was a concept called Synergy, which is really trying to address how Thales engages with small and medium-sized businesses across Canada specifically. 8:15 And these are the businesses that are maybe past the startup phase, so where Atreides is developing, you know, viable products that can get in the hands of customers. 8:24 And so Synergy allows us to now sort of reach a different part of the market. And small and medium-sized businesses in Canada typically are challenged by sort of chasing one funding mechanism after the next. 8:35 All good ideas, all helpful things to help them move forward, but how could we kinda close that chasm? 8:42 And so when we meet with a company like Atreides that's working on something that unique, and our team sees how the Navy, the end user problem can be addressed by, it's a logical place to merge. 8:53 And that allows us, I think, to, to move much more quickly, to get things in the hands of the Navy much faster and more effectively. At the end of the day, that's how innovation actually happens. 9:03 Now, some of these things like AI@Centech and Synergy are structures to help us enable it more. I'll call them innovation infrastructure, if you like. 9:13 So as you were going through kinda the process, um, collaboration as always, it's, it's two new parties meeting and, and earning trust as, as Jeff was saying. 9:23 Were there any, uh, lessons learned going through that that you, uh, can take away and apply with some of your other relationships? There's tons. I think I'll let Jeff give his view of what... 9:35 Like, I've asked others who, groups who've come through Synergy, I always ask, "What was it about our interaction with you that allowed you to trust us?" 9:44 Because some of those companies are worried about working with a large company, what's gonna happen to them. And I think we'll come back to that topic, but Jeff, maybe tell me, uh- Yeah... how's it been for you? 9:55 Yeah, you know, when working with, you know, customers, and it, it doesn't matter who you are, you know, when you approach a customer, you wanna approach it with a sustainable long-term relationship mindset. 10:11 And there's all kinds of different signals that you pick up on, on how the customer is approaching it and with that mindset. And right out of the gates, 10:21 Thales was signaling very strong that, um, relationships mattered tremendously to them, that long-term and, you know, lo- long-term trust was something that they were looking to build up. 10:35 And, and we got that loud and clear from the day when we started talking about what is this software going to do. And they said, "Hey, 10:45 we're going to frame the initial product requirements for this with Alex and Francois." And then they said, "But guess what? 10:54 We're gonna take these requirements, and we're gonna send them to the entire Aegis, um, uh, department heads." 11:02 And so we went around and spoke to, uh, it was 9 to, you know, 10 different, um, uh, individuals who all had their specialty across Aegis. And we applied what was called a consensus Delphi Oracle model. 11:16 And, um, and what that meant was we asked them all the same eight questions based off the initial product requirements. 11:24 And, and we got them to all feedback on what they thought about the product requirements and what was needed. And everyone said something different because everyone has a different specialty. 11:34 But there was a lot of common thread, and we took that common thread, and we brought it all together, and then we said, "Hey," we went back to the same group, and we said, "This is what your peers think. 11:44 And, and this is what your initial answer was, um, on what the product requirements need to be for this initial development. And is this what you, you... Would you agree with your peers? 11:54 Do you wanna change your answer ever so slightly?" And what happened is everyone's answers came closer together, closer to the average. And, and what I saw- 12:05 And, and the leadership from Thales that really impressed me was group buy-in. 12:09 And so now you've got this entire group across Aegis responsible for all kinds of different, you know, departments saying, "If we only do one thing, this is what we need." Well, from my standpoint, what do I see? 12:22 I see team buy-in across the platform program, which is gonna be the innovation vehicle if we're successful in this to actually carry it forward, and I know that the whole team has consensus bought into it, so that helps on the long-term buy-in on what we're gonna do next, and then the time after, and the time after. 12:43 So to me, you know, in, in the Atreaties team, we were hook, line, and sinker. 12:47 That was, that was the establishment of trust, knowing that, um, all the personalities at play that made up, you know, the Thales think tank of Aegis, um, were signaling this is what needs to happen. 13:00 What more could we ask for? You know, it really does, uh, keep coming back to trust. What I like, though, is, um, uh, you kind of did a measure twice and cut once, uh, approach. 13:13 You, you were involved with both teams as you went through. Now, am I correct, uh, in assuming that you did a self-fund, self-funded proof of concept for this? No. Uh, so I'll walk through the major milestones. 13:27 Um, we did for the first, call it, um, 30 days, we did a lot of learning with, um, Alex and Francois. 13:37 Um, at the resulting end of that, we built a, uh, you know, about a week and a half long POC of the POC, proof of concept of the proof of concept, and then with that, that was a signal to Thales to say, "We want you guys to get deeper in our organization, and we have R&D dollars specifically to carry this from, you know, the, the, the trust that you extended at the start of this to carry it on for another, you know, few months." 14:06 And, um, and then at the end of that R&D, then we tied it into, uh, the Aegis, um, uh, vehicle, um, to, to further carry this into the, you know, the longer term. 14:18 So it went from, you know, 60 days to three months to one year. And then all along the way, leveraging the experience from Thales and the input to help further craft what you were doing. Exactly. Yeah. 14:33 It's a great example, right, of how, you know, for a smaller company focused on a particular problem, they developed trust in us, uh, because we develop- we demonstrated trust in them, and I think that's, uh, that's a, that... 14:47 You can't ask for anything better than that. 14:50 A- another interesting, I guess, artifact of the success of this story is the, the, the designers of the Aegis contract, not only were they thinking about a relational contract and performance-based and long-term where innovation can certainly surface, they also created a mechanism called a value engineering ECP that is structured in the contract to allow you to bring innovation like what Atreaties was doing into the program, and they welcomed it into the program. 15:19 Obviously, the contact with the end user was crucial. 15:22 So lots of good thinking more than five years ago in establishing that Aegis contract that I think is leading to the innovation platform we talked about, uh, the potential to bring new capability in, and for Canadian companies like Atreaties, an opportunity to really test drive their ideas, demonstrate that they work, and get them in the hands of the, of the Navy. 15:42 To me, uh, that's kind of the perfect, uh, perfect merging of collaboration and innovation and delivering capability to the war fighter that's gonna make a difference in the way they operate. 15:52 So incumbents and primes like Thales benefit, and, um, really smart SMBs like Atreaties benefit. Uh, Chris, maybe you can comment on the benefits for customers in Canada. 16:05 Well, I, I, I think for the customers in Canada, and particularly the defense customer, 'cause that's really what we're focused on in the discussion, um, one of the challenges defense has always faced is long-term procurements that potentially end up with sort of almost planned obsolescence in the procurement. 16:26 So contracts like Aegis give them the mechanism to bring innovation in. You know, the, the pace of innovative change is much, much faster than the duration of a typical procurement. 16:38 You, you're gonna have multiple cycles. 16:40 So how do we ensure that the people who serve our nation, who we have the honor to serve by virtue of our industries we've chosen to be in, how do we ensure that they get the right equipment so they can carry out the mission safely, effectively, and return home to their families? 16:56 Well, contracts like Aegis and relationships with SMBs, highly innovative SMBs like Atreaties, and companies like Thales that foster that relationship benefit from it for sure deliver that capability to that, to that war fighter. 17:09 And at the end of the day, that's our singular purpose. All of us are focused on that, and to me, that's the strength of, of how these relationships actually work. 17:18 So the trust involved and the technology are basically accelerating collaborative innovation and performance outcomes, and I think we really do need this to help kinda shape the defense procurement, uh, uh, process. 17:35 And, you know, as I was looking at some of the, the information on the profiles here, you know, when you talk about technology, everybody gets really excited about the shiny new technology that's come in, and I've heard people say, you know, in the past, uh, when it comes to technology, the margins are in the mystery. 17:51 But there's some, some very, uh- Hmm... basic process here that needs to be improved in workflow, and it sounds like this collaboration has, has really worked out well. Well, I think innovation is, um, multifaceted. 18:05 Certainly for Atreaties, they're bringing unique innovation in how they're thinking about solving the problem, and obviously the innovation in developing the software platform. But innovation is also business models. 18:14 It's also how you, how you structure yourself, Synergy being an example of an innovative business model that's really... There's no technology in there at all, or very little. 18:23 It's a, it's an innovative way of, of operating together. 18:25 And when I think of, uh, your previous question and the challenge, I mean, I think of Commander Vesi, who really leads the Navy's sort of, one of the Navy's many innovation agendas, and he has sort of a, a drive to take advantage of this recapitalization period for the Navy. 18:41 He says it's the largest since World War II. I, I don't know. I have to trust him. And sort of future-proofing the Navy. 18:48 And Commander Vesi's looking at how, you know, how can I bring, you know, new capability to the Navy more effectively. 18:53 Well, certainly something like Aegis, value ECPs, Synergy, and relationships with SMBs, it sure feels like a, a way to deliver on his vision of what he wants to achieve. 19:02 So I think there's lots more for us in the future along these paths. I know, Jeff, you know, you know the commander as well. Maybe you have a, a, a, an additional perspective. 19:11 Yeah, you know, I mean, kind of specifically, you know, uh, Commander Vesi has these, you know, 25, you know, change agendas that he wants to hit on. 19:20 And, and, you know, specifically what we're doing right now and working on is really around the digital, you know, enablers, including, you know, data pipelines, real-time analytics, um, you know, smart, sustainable, you know, including predictive maintenance, modernizing approvals, which is a really, really big one. 19:39 Um, uh, you know, taking that stuff outside of Excel and into real-time, auditable, compliance-based software. 19:46 And then, um, you can also tie it into, you know, fleet maintenance, uh, or fleet optimization, which is, you know, uh, one of his 25 as well. And, you know, I like, you know, how Chris kind of frames this. 19:58 You know, it, it's, it's not just what Thales and, and, you know, Atrentes are doing here, right? I mean, like, 20:05 you, you start to look up and you see this, like, path of, like, innovation that's been laid out for us that, that we were welcome in to take advantage of. 20:13 So I mean, it starts with things like the ITBs, which is an incredible concept, um, really powerful vehicle. 20:21 And, and, and then you have someone like, you know, and, uh, Commander Vesi who comes around with his, you know, 25, um, areas of, of innovation, you know, kind of change management, 20:34 leveraging that framework, that vehicle. You know, he puts down his own innovation, you know, framework, and then, and then it takes a Thales to come in and interpret both of those and say, "Well, wait a second. 20:46 You know, if we're going to bring real innovation to Aegis with what's been laid out, can we take advantage of these, you know, of these innovation policies that have been put together?" 20:55 And, and that's where I'm really, you know, from an Atrenti standpoint, you know, down to the, um, you know, the last, you know, step there. 21:02 Our job is to recognize everything that's happening and understand, you know, what, what's incumbent on us to fit into this whole framework to succeed. 21:13 And there's really important things that we have to go in eyeballs wide open, right? I mean, like, you know, to be successful on this, we can't just make software. 21:20 We've got to make it, and we've got to make it on and be able to deploy it to, you know, the Aegis Azure credited, um, you know, environment. 21:29 And so there's a lot of things that, you know, if you're gonna be an agent of change and innovation, um, you recognize what's being put down in front of you and, and understand what your requirements are to be a part of that. 21:43 It's, it's not one person's job. And, um, and so it's been, you know, it's been great, um, um, watching everyone kind of recognize their role and lay that out and seeing how you fit into it. 21:57 I think this, this discussion really highlights the value of trust and collaboration. 22:03 Um, I'd be, I'd be curious to just kind of round table a little bit, but, uh, fast-forward five years from now, what do you think we'll be talking about then? 22:14 Uh, I, I will offer, John, that I hope, um, you know, we have more ships at sea through Aegis, and they're operating under a performance-based contract. 22:23 We're seeing dramatic innovations being brought to the, the ship in all facets, from AI embedded in the way they make decisions to, um, new systems like LIDAR systems on board the ship for remote sensing, a, a, a range of things that ensure that our ships, um, don't face that obsolescence challenge ahead, and that they can maintain their operational effectiveness. 22:47 And I think we will see programs like the Aegis contract, I hope we see more of them in, in other ways. And while I would love Thales to be involved in all of them, they may not be, but it doesn't matter. 22:56 That, that contract structure is so important because it, it leads to, yet demands trust. Um, and so, you know, if I can offer just a few thoughts, I think, around the theme of trust that's so crucial. 23:10 We started with Aegis and where it is five years and where it can be five years from now, and certainly 30 years from now if we keep going, is the idea that, um, a few things really struck me in the process of working with Atrentes, but also with other s- uh, small, medium-sized business through the Synergy program. 23:27 And, and that was really that there's a few sort of North Stars that have to guide these relationships, and one is, uh, I think assume good intent by all. Like, assume everyone has the right intent, right? 23:39 Number two would be to evolve kind of a, a mindset, an infinite mindset of possibility and long-term sustainable relationships, which I think Jeff spoke to well. To invest energy in the small things. 23:53 I, I was commenting on what Jeff had commented earlier, but I've seen it from other SMB, small, medium-sized business we work with, is they talk about the little things that made them trust us. We return phone calls. 24:03 We answered emails. We showed up at meetings, and we shared information. And, you know, it's not some massive, big moment of trust. It's those little things that you do every day that makes a, a difference. 24:14 And, and fourth- Have a shared purpose. Write it down, post it on the wall, remind yourself at all the time about it because that shared purpose is, um, is your North Star. 24:26 It's the compass point that you're all working towards. Within the Thales vision we have of ourselves, we do really, we say, "Committed to collaboration and building a future we can all trust." 24:36 And I think the relationship with the Treaties hits both of those. Yeah. And, you know, I, I look at it, um, you know, John, you know, scaling from, 24:48 you know, scaling off those best principles that, that, you know, Chris laid out on a, you know, just keep getting bigger kind of scale. 24:57 You know, we started off doing a POC of a POC, which led to R&D, you know, that, that Thales puts aside, which led to the innovative, you know, framework that, that Aegis is. 25:08 And, and if we take those same principles that Chris laid out and we apply them now to being successful, um, on, on the Aegis framework, um, I, I wholeheartedly agree with, with Chris, then that can become a lift in, in adoption across other classes of ships. 25:27 And, um, and that's what we're trying to do, right? I mean, like, y- you know, where we're at now, it's not about just Thales. That's not the stakeholder, right? 25:36 I mean, there is multiple stakeholders involved in the software we're trying to deliver. 25:40 And if we can show all those stakeholders coming together in real time decision-making, um, you know, capability, which leads to predictive maintenance decisions, 25:50 well, why wouldn't the other classes ships want that in other countries? Mm-hmm. In non-defense applications, you know? 25:57 And so, um, so I think, you know, we're, we're always looking to, um, create a best practice model, as Chris laid out, and when we have it, keep what's good, and then, um, see where else it's a fit. 26:11 Well, it certainly sounds like this has been a great c- collaboration, and, uh, it really does highlight, um, the need for trust and how it can be a catalyst in transformation, and it's gonna help to basically be where the puck is gonna be, uh- [laughs]... 26:28 five years down the road, you know? That's kinda how I see it. Great analogy during the Stanley Cup season. [laughs] Yeah, that's true. 26:37 Um, but, uh, you've been listening to Vanguard Radio, and we've, we've been talking about Aegis. We've been talking about digital technology. We've been talking about trust. 26:46 We've been talking about, uh, the foundations and principles of, of good business relationships and, and good planning and, uh, the outcomes of success. 26:56 Our two guests today have been Chris Pogue, CEO of Thales Canada, and Jeff Spencer, CEO of Atreaties. I wanna thank you both for, for joining the show. It's been really interesting. Thank you. Thanks, Jeff. 27:09 Thanks for having us. 27:16 The views, information, or opinions expressed during the Vanguard Weekly Podcast Series, CGE Weekly Podcast Series, Vanguard Radio Podcast, and CGE Radio Podcast are solely those of the individuals involved and do not represent those of Vanguard or any affiliated media products, their employees, or owners. 27:37 Vanguard Magazine, Canadian Government Executive Magazine, and its affiliates are not responsible for and do not verify for accuracy any of the information contained in this podcast series. 27:48 This podcast may not be copied or distributed without express written approval of Promotive Communications Inc., PCI. You may not edit, modify, or redistribute this podcast without consent from PCI. 27:59 PCI assumes no liability for activities in connection with this podcast or for use of this podcast with any other website, computer, or playing device