Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Welcome back to another episode of Vanguard Radio. I'm your host, J. Richard Jones. Today we're gonna be talking about future-proofing submarines. 0:18 It's really talking about securing Canadian underwater capabilities. 0:22 And we have two very special guests joining us, and they're gonna talk about how they contribute to the Canadian underwater landscape in assisting and supporting the goals of security, especially within the Arctic. 0:37 Our first guest is Simon Carroll, President of Saab Canada. He leads the Canadian team in Ottawa, Medicine Hat, Burnaby, and Halifax. Our second guest joining us today is Jason Howard, and he's with Saab Sweden. 0:54 He is the CPSP Campaign Director, otherwise known as Canadian Patrol Submarine Project Campaign. Both of these gentlemen have extensive experience, and, uh, I'd like to welcome you both to our show. 1:09 Thank you very much, John. So Simon, uh, my first question is, um, why are the submarines so important to Canada, the new ones specifically? Yeah, thanks, John. Um, 1:22 Canada boasts a, a longer coastline than any country on earth, and protecting the underwater infrastructure and the shipping routes that go along with that coastline is imperative, uh, for Canadian national defense and also for the, the Canadian economy. 1:38 Uh, there's miles and miles of undersea cables that are anchored to the sea floor, uh, around the world, that connect the world, as 95% of data flows through these, uh, undersea cables. 1:50 And the ability to commu- uh, to protect those, uh, is, you know, extremely important for pretty much all walks of life these days. Submarines are a way of doing that, one way of doing that. 2:02 They're a strategic system that can be used for almost the ultimate deterrence. 2:07 Uh, simply the idea that a submarine may be present in, uh, Canadian waters, uh, may be enough to deter hostile actors, certainly getting closer to that very, very long coastline that I mentioned earlier. 2:20 Uh, in addition to the, the undersea activities, it's maintaining the freedom of operation for all sea traffic. 2:27 Uh, we jokingly like to call, you know, one of the roles of the Navy, uh, keeping the sea lanes free lanes, and a submarine is certainly a massive contributor to that. 2:37 And, uh, as we know, um, the, the sea lanes that operate in and around Canada, uh, you know, provide a- an awful amount of, uh, economic benefit. The shipping, the, uh, the transport routes that are conduct... 2:51 you know, connect the country from coast to coast are extremely important. 2:55 And, uh, the use of submarines, um, to, you know, ensure that this traffic can continue and this, this, uh, economic benefit to the country can continue, uh, is essential. 3:06 So Jason, Saab is no stranger to submarine development. And for the benefit of our listenership and readership today, could you share with us a little bit of the history that Saab has had in submarine development? 3:19 Because it's really quite robust. Well, absolutely, John. Uh, the tradition of shipbuilding at, uh, Saab Kockums Karlskrona shipyard, for instance, goes back, uh, over 300 years. 3:33 Essentially, the city of Kar- Karlskrona was the headquarters of the Swedish Navy, uh, at the end of the 17th century, uh, which is incidentally now a UNESCO World Heritage site. 3:48 Uh, but when it comes specifically to, to submarines, I could say that we have over 100 years of experience with, uh, submarine construction, which really started already in the early 1900s and, uh, is still ongoing. 4:06 What I can add here is that over, over time, we have literally built seven submarine classes, and, uh, they're currently in use on three continents. 4:18 Just to give you an, uh, an example of some of the countries that, uh, use them, of course, Sweden. Uh, Sweden, we have the Gotland-class submarine, Södermanland, currently in operation. In, uh, the near future, the A26. 4:33 If we look at Australia, we have the long-range high-endurance submarine in operation. Uh, we hope that will go through a life-of-type extension soon. 4:44 We expect that, and of course to, to support AC, that'll be running that in, uh, Australia. And of course, Singapore with the Archer-class submarine. But I mean, but, uh, coming back to the shipyard, we, uh... 4:58 I think it's important to emphasize that we have recently made considerable investments in, uh, infrastructure, new technologies, methodology, 5:09 and really added a sort of good level of, uh, precis- precision automation, for example, on, uh, precision welding. 5:20 Uh, new technologies and, uh, methods a- around piping, for, for instance, which constitutes a huge part of the submarine. 5:32 Now, th- this is really important, considering that building submarines is incredibly complex and will probably continue to be, uh, complex and even more complex in the future, and I would dare to say probably even more complex than building spacecraft, to be honest. 5:52 Wow. Um, Jason, in terms of being able to maintain a successful submarine program, which Saab has done, is it the investment in technology- And the infrastructure, that is one of the key factors in that success? 6:11 Well, absolutely. Uh, th- that is one of the, uh, the main factors. 6:16 Uh, but if you talk about, uh, how Sweden maintains and successfully, uh, successful submarine program, I actually have a couple of points around that, if that's what you, uh, referring to. 6:27 Firstly, we have achieved, uh, this through really early and continuous dialogue, uh, with the customer, and this is really to understand the customer's needs, their wants, and ultimately, the requirements. 6:42 For us, really, the heritage of the submarine serves as the sort of, uh, design base, if I may put it that way, having a smart approach to evolutionary design rather than revolutionary, if you understand what I mean. 6:58 Really keep what works, change what can be improved, and, uh, basically add more capability. I think, uh, another very important point is around, uh, performance-based design. 7:12 Future-proof the product, and early on have a sort of strategy for risk handling and, uh, risk mitigation. 7:22 Uh, one example I can give you is, uh, using, for instance, uh, mature technologies and, uh, really mature systems and products that are currently out there. 7:34 I think the third point is, is equally important, and that is agency interaction and a very strong network of competence. And again, I'll give you another example. 7:46 In Sweden, we have what you call the triple helix approach, which really serves as the foundation for, for dialogue and, and, uh, getting things right, [laughs] if I can put it that way, and that would include typically, uh, the, the Navy, uh, the customer, uh, academia, uh, probably, uh, a bunch of research organizations, uh, government authorities. 8:13 Are this actually delivering what the customer wants? Uh, and in essence, uh, at least we believe putting us in the, in the forefront of things. 8:23 I think the, the final comment here is really around sustainment, which is, uh, pretty important, and we, we can see this in Canada around the Victoria class now. You must have a forward-leaning joint approach. 8:39 Uh, when I mean joint approach, industry and customer, industry and Navy, as an example for improvements or, or maintenance. This approach can 8:51 drastically improve, uh, mission readiness and, uh, of course submarine availability. 8:58 You know, Jason, it's, it's, it's obviously a very methodical and well-laid-out approach to the building of, of submarines and also collaborating with the OEMs and, and the government to develop program, and, uh, to, to develop and meet program requirements. 9:17 Uh, in your opinion, is, is this approach unique to Saab? Well, firstly, before, before I get there, uh, I would just like to, to make a comment, uh, really based on what 9:30 S- Simon said, and that is the harsh Arctic conditions, but also linked to that, very important, I believe, uh, to both Sweden and Canada to be able to operate in these, uh, conditions effectively. 9:44 This is something our submarines know how to do really, really well. Uh, but coming back to your question, what, uh, what Saab submarines are designed for, uh, let's put it this way. 9:57 Uh, this can range from, uh, and I've got a couple of points here. [laughs] Number one, uh, detecting and classifying threats early and correctly. 10:08 Uh, our submarines employ a variety of capabilities, um, anti-surface warfare, of course, uh, anti-submarine warfare, 10:19 collecting of, uh, intelligence, whether, uh, COMINT, communication intelligence, or ELINT, electric signal intelligence. Uh, we're pretty good at that. 10:31 I think another important point is, of course, having a sturdy and reliable design, uh, less vulnerable to, to shock and degradation. 10:40 Uh, and I don't know if you're aware of that, uh, John, but, uh, I think important to mention that we're one of the few that do live shock testing of, uh, our submarines. Uh, 10:51 I don't know if it'd be fun to be on board when you do it, but, uh, but that's something- [laughs]... we conduct, of course, to, uh, to test them. 10:59 Uh, I think what is also really, really important is the, the whole thing around operating extremely stealthily. 11:08 Uh, for example, signature management, uh, in a variety of, uh, regimes is quite important with the visual radiant noise, uh, in the magnetic spectrum, maybe infrared. 11:22 And actually, talking about this, I wanna touch on a bit of a story. 11:26 Uh, I don't know if you're aware, but in, uh, I believe it was around 2004, we had, uh, HMS Gotland in, uh, San Diego in the US by the invitation of the, the US Navy, 11:41 and in fact, they end up, they ended up leasing the, uh, Gotland class submarine for, for some time. 11:48 And they leased it to do, uh, some, uh, some wargaming, where we ended up penetrating the defenses around, uh, I believe it's a Nimitz class, uh, uh, aircraft carrier. 12:03 And, uh, you had several surface vessels and, of course, some nuclear class, uh, American nuclear class submarines looking for, for the Gotland. 12:11 And time after time, we managed to, uh, to penetrate these defenses and basically- Sink the, uh, aircraft carrier. I think this underlines how important, uh, you know, it is to, to have a stealthy submarine. 12:26 And again, that's something that we're really good at. I think one of the, the... 12:30 one of my last points here, and that, that is really, really key, I think, and that is having a future-proof solution and, and submarine here. 12:41 And therefore use a sort of, uh, minimal, uh, personnel approach, what we call lean manning, uh, to operate the submarine. I mean, how do we achieve that? 12:53 Uh, through, um, increased automation, uh, launch and recovery of, uh, variety of unmanned vehicles, and manned vehicles for that matter. 13:04 And this is, uh, pretty key considering the challenges, uh, with respect to, to budget constraints these days and limitations on crew. Uh, I think this is important. 13:14 I think this, this is something that is a, uh, a challenge for, uh, dare I say, both Sweden and Canada alike. So this is pretty important. John. 13:26 Yes, I, I think it is, and, uh, I appreciate, um, you commenting on how the submarines are, are future-proof. Um, I think in terms of reliability and, and, and confidence that that goes a long way. 13:39 Um, the solutions do have to be affordable, and then especially when we're, we're talking about trying to be secure from underwater threats. Um, I'd like to kind of revisit a little bit of the Arctic again, if we could. 13:53 And, um, Simon, if I could get, uh, your comments in terms of, um, you know, Saab's, how will Saab's experience in Canada, how is it gonna help with the Canadian, uh, patrol submarine project? 14:06 Uh, and, and w- and what are your thoughts on, on, uh, the Arctic, if we could expand a little more on that? Sure. If I just touch on Saab's experience first, John. 14:15 I mean, we've been, uh, engaged with the Canadian military for, you know, the better part of 35 years plus now and, uh, a, a large part of that has been working closely with the, uh, the Canadian Navy, uh, specifically on the Halifax-class frigates for their, their radar and their fire control, uh, solutions and, and systems that are on board those. 14:35 So granted, that's more in the air and surface surveillance rather than the underwater, but what it gives us is an opera- a, a great opportunity to, you know, to really understand the end users and to, to understand what the Canadian Navy, you know, expects out of its partners and its, its, uh, suppliers, uh, in that regard. 14:55 Um, the same can be said for the, the Army. You know, we've, we've recently, um, heard that the, the Canadian government has donated Carl Gustaf, uh, rifles to the, the, uh, Ukrainian, uh, war that's going on there. 15:09 Um, and they're, they're products that have been made by Saab and, and we're looking to continue to support that. 15:16 Um, and then I guess an- another part of our experience, uh, is, you know, our real dedication to working closely with government partners and our business partners when it comes to things like technology and knowledge transfer. 15:31 Um, people use the term, you know, techn- transfer of technology quite a bit, but we sort of believe that, um, just having that technology is not good enough. 15:41 You have to know how to use it, because if you don't know how to use it, then, you know, you're not getting the best out of it and you're not getting the best value for money, and you're also not, uh, giving the best capabilities to either the end user or your business partners, uh, in, in trying to do that. 15:55 So, you know, I think the understanding of not just the armed forces, but also the Canadian Procurement organization and the Canadian Innovation and Economic Development organization, you know, we, by, by understanding that, we can greater, you know, contribute, uh, at a greater level to Canada, both the end user, but also the technology and the, and the future economy of the country. 16:21 And I think that's an important aspect of the business in defense, uh, these days as well. 16:27 I mean, number one is always going to be getting the right equipment to the right people for them to use at the right time, uh, so that they can stay safe and secure, and they can protect the country, as is their job. 16:39 Uh, but then there's also the economic side of it as well, and I think it's important that we help develop local industry, uh, as well, so that, um, you know, the country becomes more self-sustaining and the defense industry grows. 16:52 Because it is a big industry and one that I think Canada can increase, um, at a, at a much more significant level and, and do a lot more domestically, and we'd be very happy, uh, to support that. 17:03 And, you know, a program like the Canadian Patrol Submarine Program, uh, is gonna be a big one. You know, it's, it's not, uh, every day that people or the Canadian government will buy new submarines. It's generational. 17:16 I mean, by the time the Victoria class finish, we're looking at, you know, 40 to 50 years activity of a, of the same class of a submarine and, um, you know, we recognize that. 17:25 And as Jason said, right at the very outset, uh, one of our, you know, one of the things that we really take pride in is being there for the whole lifetime of a submarine and, and supporting the people that we're using. 17:36 So it's not really a buyer-seller relationship, it's more of a real genuine partnership. 17:42 And, and that's something that I think, uh, our experience in Canada will help, um, you know, should we be, uh, fortunate enough to provide submarines to Canada in the future that, you know, that's something that I think that we can really benefit, uh, both Saab and more importantly, uh, the Canadian government and the Canadian people. 18:01 Canada is, uh, a member nation of the Arctic Council, as Sweden is as well, and the protection of the Arctic, um, you know, is a, is a key part of the future national defense with regards to, uh, NORAD and also the, uh, the Arctic Council. 18:19 Um, Saab's ability to, uh, to- Develop, deliver, uh, submarines that can operate in these regions, uh, has been proven. 18:28 Uh, obviously, the Sweden being a- an Arctic country as well and the operating in and around the Baltics, uh, is a key part of that. 18:35 And I think as we look to the Arctic in the future and the potential threat, uh, from the Arctic, from other Arctic, uh, regions and, and, and players in that space, uh, the ability to operate in the Arctic with a submarine force, uh, will be, will be key to helping Canada protect its national interests. 18:54 Oh, uh, for sure. I mean, I think it's well worth noting, Simon, um, Si- that Saab has been supporting the Canadian Armed Forces for over 35 years. Am I correct? Yeah, that's correct. Yeah. 19:07 I, I guess one of the challenges that, that the Canadian military is having in general right now, I mean, COVID's changed so much, right? And technology in- Sure... 19:16 some ways has advanced as a result of this, this horrible situation, but the, one of the big challenges is, is training and, uh, retention that people are having to deal with, too. 19:27 I'd be curious to ask you, uh, in, in your development phases and in how you work with other clients, have you guys, uh, discovered any, uh, training methods that, um, are now more effective and that you're implementing? 19:43 The, the fight for talent, uh, across the board i- is very real. Uh, and I think we all, all know that, and certainly training methodology's a part of that. 19:52 Um, Jason mentioned earlier how very difficult it is to, to build a submarine. Uh, and as a result, it takes time, and technology can move on. 20:01 So, you know, we've gotta look at how we can use things like, uh, artificial intelligence to help with training, but also with the technology development, uh, as well, and also keeping, um, keeping the training pipeline relevant for your people as the technology moves on. 20:18 So it's, it's a bit of a tough balance, uh, but it's one that I think that we spend a lot of time with. 20:23 And, and Jason, you can give great examples of, you know, what we're doing in Sweden, in the shipyard in particular, and that's something that we'd have to consider very closely and look at implementing in Canada with, you know, with training partners here as well. 20:36 Yeah. I can certainly add a little bit to it. And I th- I think it comes back to my, um, the previous point that I made regarding lean manning. And you touched on a very important point, John. 20:51 Uh, finding crews these days i- is not easy, and I don't think it's easy for anybody. And a- as a result, as, uh, Simon said, on the training side, of course, we've, uh, made a number of advancements. 21:04 But, uh, again, I come back to, to lean manning on the submarine itself, and training the crew to, uh, to use automation, artificial intelligence a bit more in the future, uh, I think that will be key. 21:18 Uh, including, uh, unmanned vehicles to do many things that, uh, in the past, uh, manned vehicles used to do. So I think this is, uh, probably gonna be quite a, a big focal point. I think so. 21:33 Uh, my, my last, uh, question, as I, as I mentioned, a lot has changed in the last three years, but if I were to ask each of you to look into your crystal ball, what do you think the, the submarine building experience will be like five years from now? 21:48 And I guess, Simon, I'd like to start with you, if we could. Sure. 21:51 Well, I mean, while I am a Navy guy, I'm not a submariner by any [laughs] stretch of the means, so submarine building, uh, is gonna be an, an interesting [laughs] one for me to comment on, I guess. 22:01 But look, I would think it's, it's touching on the points that Jason just raised, you know, how do we include technology in regards to automation and artificial intelligence to maybe do more with less, which is a bit of the Swedish way, I would suggest. 22:16 Um, and how do we maximize the benefits of that technology, uh, moving forward? So, you know, I won't give you three, because I, I, I think that that's more along Jason's sort of area. 22:28 But, um, certainly the use of AI and automation, um... And I will add that I think it's important as well that we meet sustainability targets in doing that, uh, as well. 22:41 You know, there's, there's all different aspects now to, 22:44 you know, manufacturing and training and, um, you know, sort of delivery and assembly of, of t- of s- massive systems like this, but you've gotta do it in sustainable ways, and I think that that's an important feature to note that, you know, as a company, that's right at our, the forefront of what we're trying to do. 23:02 We have science-based targets that have been approved now as well. And I think that regardless of what you're building, not just submarines, they all have to be taken into consideration. I think that's a great point. 23:13 Um, Jason, uh- Yeah... looking forward to hearing what you see. Absolutely. I mean, Simon really, really covered it, but I think, uh, again, it comes back to, uh, uh, automation, uh, within the shipyard. 23:28 But, but this doesn't take away from the need to have, uh, staff and, and competence to, uh, to operate the equipment. 23:37 Uh, and I think this comes back to what I told you about the, the triple helix, and ensure that we, we don't only retain that network of competence, but ensure that we increase it and it evolves, uh, all the time. 23:53 And, uh, that is something we're also really good at doing with, uh, with our customers, is to make sure that they, they keep on the edge of things, uh, when we come to technology and, and competence. 24:04 Uh, but of course, there are these jobs that, uh, that, that will probably not change very soon. And f- for example, is, uh, uh, bending steel. 24:14 There, there's certain s- special skills when it comes to bending steel without machines, where you need to feel and touch it, and that is a competence that you have to have in the tips of your fingers that individuals [laughs] develop through the years. 24:29 So it's, it's really a combination of, uh, getting people with the right competence, and then, uh, having the, uh, machines to make it a little bit easier and, uh, more precise for certain disciplines, I would say. 24:41 That's very interesting. You've been listening to Vanguard Radio. I'm your host, J. Richard Jones. 24:48 Our special guests today, Simon Carroll, President of Saab Canada, and Jason Howard, uh, Saab, uh, CBSP Campaign Director. Gentlemen, it's been a pleasure to have you on. It's been very informative as well. 25:02 I hope you'll come back and join us again. Thank you so much. Uh, thanks for your time, John. It's been a pleasure. Thank you, John. Uh, a real pleasure. Swedish. 25:10 [outro music] The views, information, or opinions expressed during the Vanguard Weekly Podcast Series, CGE Weekly Podcast Series, Vanguard Radio Podcast, and CGE Radio Podcast are solely those of the individuals involved, and do not represent those of Vanguard or any affiliated media products, their employees or owners. 25:37 Vanguard Magazine, Canadian Government Executive Magazine, and its affiliates are not responsible for and do not verify for accuracy any of the information contained in this podcast series. 25:48 This podcast may not be copied or distributed without express written approval of Promotive Communications Inc., PCI. You may not edit, modify, or redistribute this podcast without consent from PCI. 25:59 PCI assumes no liability for activities in connection with this podcast or for use of this podcast with any other website, computer, or playing device.