Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Welcome back to another episode of Vanguard Weekly. I'm your host, Jay Richard Jones, and it's a pleasure to be with you today. We have a very special show today. 0:17 Uh, we're talking about the digital divide, and a very special guest. We have Major General Rupert Jones, who is a retired, and, uh, as well as Caleb Walker, country manager from WithYouWithMe. 0:32 So today we're talking about the digital divide. Uh, Mr. Jones, you're talking about, um, digital divide. There's a lot of different, um, topics and, and ways to approach that. 0:43 But I think the best way would be to consider the current events. 0:48 We hear all about, you know, the need for tanks and this terrible war that's going on in the, the Ukraine and all kinds of military equipment that's, that's required. 0:57 But underneath of that, uh, all of that, what about the technology and some of the issues and challenges that are going on there? Yeah. Well, uh, firstly, thank you very much, uh, for inviting me to join you today. 1:08 It's an absolute, absolute pleasure to join you from the United Kingdom. Um, so yeah, I mean, I think what you touched on is, is such an interesting issue, isn't it? 1:17 Because, you know, the world's attention is rightly on Ukraine and we focus on the, um, what you might call the kinetic aspect of it and, and the human suffering that comes from that. 1:29 But of course, there's a, there's a, uh, a seen and an unseen digital element to this, to this war. The seen bit is the bit that takes it into our phones. 1:40 It's the social media aspect that allows every Ukrainian to, to have a voice and to share, share their story. Um, and we might return to that because I think that's, that's really, really important. 1:51 But, but what you've also got going on, of course, is, is the true unseen battle, which is, uh, it is a electronic battle. 1:59 Uh, and it's about using, amongst other things, cyber tools, and some of that is really quite sophisticated, uh, state-based cyber. 2:09 Uh, and some of it will be kind of more, more mass bots, if you like, uh, that we've heard, we've heard lots about, uh, in, in, in the past. 2:17 I think what I would say about all of that, and, and I kind of here I draw on my personal experience in the counter ISIS campaign in Iraq and Syria, that, that was ultimately about an idea. 2:29 It was about trying to defeat ISIS's narrative as well as a physical defeat. 2:33 But all of that information campaign, the cyber effort, and we had a pretty, uh, sophisticated cyber campaign, it could only ever, what we would call in the military, shape the outcome. It could never be decisive. 2:45 So it's really, really important. 2:47 But, but ultimately, whether we like it or not, once you get into a sort of, uh, a really unpleasant, brutal, harsh war fight, which is what we've got going on in Ukraine, that, that physical element, uh, is, is central. 3:01 Caleb, how do you see it? No, I, I think it's, uh, it, it's really is shaping. It could be years before and it could be, you know, the day before or on, on target. 3:12 But, uh, I think it's, uh, just an important aspect is that we, we probably are missing the fact that, uh, there's a massive, uh, uh, amount of personnel that are engaged in that conflict right now. 3:23 There's like the 300,000 people that are part of the, quote unquote, "IT army" of the Ukraine. Uh, but then there's also criminal elements, uh, in Russia that have just been unleashed, uh, as well. 3:35 Uh, and so there, there's so many dynamics to, uh, this conflict, uh, that, uh, we, we might not be, uh, really fully able to understand maybe till, not till afterwards. 3:45 Uh, although I'm sure some of the experts, uh, in, uh, Western, uh, countries that are, that are, uh, engaged in this conflict right now in the cyber domain are probably well aware of it. 3:54 But, uh, yeah, I think it's, uh, an interesting aspect of what we're probably missing here. But, uh, M- Mr. Jones, you, you... Uh, do you have any other comments on that before I Yeah.... hand it back? 4:03 I was just gonna add, you know, i- if we, if we go b- back not that far in time, a, a soldier on the battlefield, his, and it, and of course until quite recent was a, a his, his weapon was his rifle, his grenade, his bayonet. 4:20 Uh, increasingly, he and she have other weapons at their disposal. 4:25 Um, and, you know, whether it's the war in Ukraine or whether we look to our own militaries into the future, we need, and we've known this for a long time, our soldiers in particular, you know, they, they've got at their disposal more and more sophisticated weaponry, communication systems, and, and the like. 4:42 And, and we need much more from them. 4:45 Um, and, you know, I think there's a question mark about whether Western militaries are getting that right yet, whether they're training them and empowering them sufficiently to exploit their full potential. 4:57 In a case like what's going on in the Ukraine, how much of a factor or what are some of the issues just with communication and technology alone? Um, can that end up being a game changer in terms of success? 5:09 Well, I mean, I think, you know, all these things, uh, enable. Uh, so, you know, effective com- communications, uh, enable you to operate. 5:22 And what I mean by that is, you know, whether you're President Zelenskyy trying to, uh, talk to your high command, whether he's trying to speak out to, um, Washington, or whether you are a ground commander trying to speak to your soldiers or your soldiers speak up to the, uh, the, the, your bosses, you need communications, don't you? 5:44 And we're all trained in the military that, that when communications break down, and oh, by the way, they do, um, they always do, always at the most inconvenient possible time. 5:53 What good militaries do, and w- and we see this in how the Ukrainians are fighting, is they kinda know what's required of them. 6:02 I kind of know what I was meant to be doing w- at the point when I lost communications, when all my digital architecture fell over. 6:09 Um, so I, so I'll kind of I'll, I'll go after that, and at some point I'll get back in touch with my team and my boss will get ahold of me again. 6:17 But in the meantime, fundamentally, I knew what it was I was meant to be doing. Conscript militaries aren't that, aren't capable of doing that, uh, because what I've just described is a h- is a very complex... 6:31 Uh, you've got to be good, and you've got to be part of a sophisticated cultural organization to do that. 6:37 Uh, and I suspect what we're seeing with the, with the Russians is they're not able to do that, and what the Ukrainians are doing very effectively is disrupting them. 6:44 No doubt targeting their command vehicles, their communication systems, so those, those conscripts, in the absence of orders, are, are all but defeated, and they end up surrendering or, or whatever it might be. 6:58 So I'm hearing there that training is such a huge part and part of the teamwork. Um, Caleb, do you want to comment on that? Well, I just like that, uh, comment, uh, so much. Uh, just the enabling. 7:09 Like, you don't, you don't expect it to be there all the time, but when it is there, you want to be able to use it to its fullest measure to enable, uh, the ground forces. 7:17 And, and that, and that's the same like, in a way, and I'm sure we're gonna look at this in a, as an after action, but the open source intelligence stuff that is able to be going on right now, when you have a local population, uh, see something, they're putting it onto the, to the internet, or they're using, uh, satellite imagery or whatever it is that, uh, the, uh, Ukraine, uh, military is able to pull from, like, they don't expect it to be there all the time, but when it is there and they have the opportunity of using that open source to move faster and to enable operations, they're definitely doing it. 7:48 Uh, and so that's just the other dynamic to this, I think, that's, uh, really, uh, really important, is just being able to use the information when it's there to enable you to move faster. 7:59 Uh, and it's really, it's really a, a very, um, it's interesting to watch. Mr. Jones, would you say that in a sense, it's kind of a form of digital guerrilla warfare? 8:10 You've got the information in real time, you're posting on social media. It obviously has an effect on, on esteem and what gets out to the world, but, uh, it's also pinpointing things very quickly. 8:22 Yeah, I mean, I think there is a bit of that, isn't there? You know, so, so go back in time, go back into history. You know, military formations, they were very regimented. Um, they worked on drills. 8:32 They moved across the battlefield in a, in a, in a certain way. Um, and what technology has allowed us to do is disperse more and more. Uh, we don't have to be in touching distance of each other. 8:45 We almost no longer need to be in line of sight of each other. You know, you c- you can, and you can... And you see this, what the Ukrainians do, they're dispersing really, really effectively. 8:54 And what you do begin to get is, is, is more of an insurgency style form of warfare. Dispersed defense is highly effective because the enemy have never really got anything to, to, to attack against. 9:06 So I do think there's something, something really powerful in that. And, and, you know, to Caleb's point, which I think is, is so interesting, is this idea of open source, because 9:16 defense organizations, we've struggled with open source because we do, we do classified information. You know, and frankly, the higher the classification, the better. Um, if it's top secret, that's fantastic. 9:27 Uh, but of course that's, that isn't agile, and you need it. Of course you do. 9:33 But, but down in, down in the battlefield, you need, you need fast information, and a very significant percentage of the information you need is available in open source, and that is becoming more and more of an issue. 9:48 And our militaries are working very hard to identify how do you change those protocols? 9:53 How do you change the protocols so that you can get the dirty internet into your highly classified headquarters, so you can turn all that information really, really fast? 10:02 Again, I mean, a, a vignette from Iraq and Syria, but again, I've seen it happening in Ukraine. In our, the kind of coalition operations room, you know, we had, we had truth, you know. 10:12 We had this highly classified, you know, um, common operating picture on one screen, and then over to the left we had the dirty internet portraying, uh, uh, live maps, which is just a product of social media. 10:26 Uh, and it would show the front line. It would show where kind of incidents had happened. 10:32 And, and generally speaking, there was very little difference between what we knew to be the case, because we're getting it through all these highly, highly classified and highly, uh, sophisticated technical systems, 10:44 and what was being posted on, on social media. So, so we militaries have to harness that more and more because you can be certain our adversaries are going to. Yeah. There's no way to shut it out. 10:55 Would you say that that's, uh, been an advantage to the, to, uh, to the Ukraine fighting forces? Yeah. Yeah, I mean, it certainly looks... You know, as Caleb a- alluded to a moment ago, you know, 11:07 at the end of this conflict, you know, we'll, the, the, everyone will pore over the lessons. What we're seeing is kind of perceptions a- at the moment. 11:16 What it appears is that, you know, the Ukrainians who are, you know, they're, they're a competent military, and, and our two nations, amongst others, have been, been working with them for a number of years, uh, that, that they are able to, to operate at a more sophisticated level. 11:33 Um, now of course, it's helped in this instance, isn't it? Because they have right on their side, and they're fighting for their homeland and their families, and boy, oh boy, that makes you fight hard. 11:43 Um, but they're up against an army that, um, firstly, is underperforming for, for whatever reason, but even at its best, is never going to match man for man, woman for woman, piece of equipment for piece of equipment, uh, the s- the sort of militaries that we're part of, and indeed the Ukrainians. 12:02 Now, that's not to say they can't ever match them with scale and mass, but for... I would take a Ukrainian fight every day over, over a Russian one. Yeah. For sure. 12:12 Uh, what do you think would be the recommended steps for the future to, to, um, solve the issue of the digital divide? Oh, well, if only, if only I had that magic bullet- [laughs]... 12:25 uh, we could have a good chat about it, and the three of us would be really wealthy. [laughs] It's interesting, you know, Caleb will have a different perspective, you know, from, from Canada, 12:35 but, but I think all of our nations are seeing it broadly the same, aren't they? 12:40 So you can draw any different statistic you like, um, but they all point to the fact there's a complete shortage of digital skills in, in the workplace. Employers can't get the people they need. 12:53 The people who are correctly, uh, who have the right skills, um, can call all the shots because they know, you know, they, they, they, they, they've got the skills that are needed. As... 13:04 Certainly in the UK, the education system isn't helping. Um, it's, you know, it's continuing to teach, you know, all the good old-fashioned subjects. 13:14 I'm not saying they're, they're not important, but they're not really preparing people to be digital natives. 13:19 Uh, and, and most employers aren't helping either because, you know, frankly, in their minds as an employer, they're too busy to give their staff the continuous improvement training they need to up, to upskill them. 13:32 So, um, you know, we know we've, we've got to do, do something differently, and we can't, I don't think, rely on our, on our governments to do it through the education system. 13:43 You know, we're just gonna be, we, you know, it's gonna be, be too slow. So Caleb will have some views in, in a minute. 13:49 You know, he talks about, I think, very rightly about a digital insurgency, and it does feel like that. 13:54 It feels it's gotta be bottom-up driven because there's a whole stack of people who want to improve themselves, and they w- they want to get on the digital, uh, journey, but, but they've gotta find a route in, and I think there's an awful lot of false routes in. 14:09 Now, you know, I'm, I'm an advisor with... Caleb works with With You With Me, and I'm an advisor there. 14:15 And, but I do think it, it's, it's routes such as With You With Me who help people to have the confidence to realize this isn't some black art, 'cause we kind of think it is, don't we? 14:27 You know, if you haven't been involved in the digital game, you think it's, it's for other people. It's for techies. It's for people who did, you know, adva- you know, advanced maths at school. 14:37 And of course, the point is, it's not. It is for people just like you and me. Uh, it i- it is highly accessible. You've just gotta be, you gotta be guided. 14:47 But, uh, Ca- Caleb, Caleb will have some, some thoughts I have no doubt. Yeah, I think so. Uh, Caleb, uh, let's, wh- what's your take? Yes. 14:55 Uh, no, I was actually just talking to, uh, we have a, a youth, a project lead, uh, in, uh, With You With Me. 15:02 Uh, I was trying to understand, like, what is the, you know, the, the 15, 16 to 21-year-olds, like what are, what, what are they looking for, uh, to try and get into this? 15:11 Uh, 'cause, like, you know, we should be trying to upskill everybody, uh, and make it easier for everybody to get into this space. 15:17 But I mean, if you're looking at, we're talking about the military here, and, and, you know, statistically they do try to, uh, get in the younger, uh, crowd, uh, to, uh, to be part of the army. 15:26 Uh, and, uh, one of the kind of interesting things he said yesterday, uh, as part of our, our new weekly discussions of, of talking about this is that, you know, younger people, they don't wanna commit to the, to the five, to the seven, to the nine-year commitments, but they are interested. 15:43 Uh, they want the flexible apprenticeship. They wanna learn. They wanna be able to add value, uh, and see where they can, uh, add that value. 15:50 And so I, I, I think really how do we, yeah, how do we, uh, how do we kind of close the digital divide? 15:56 We just have to show the workforce that they can learn these skills that are relevant, that they can use, uh, in their jobs or in a future job. Um, and, uh, we need to kind of bring them along on the journey. 16:07 And so, yeah, we're, we're, we are gonna have to do a bit of a, it is an insurgency 'cause we're gonna need young leaders and people that are out there, uh, in the front proving to the team, proving to the, to the group of people they're working with if you're, and, and then, you know, if, if, if it's in the army, you're, you know, you're proving to the soldiers. 16:25 Uh, but then also proving it to the, uh, people you wanna probably bring into the military, uh, and some of the youth that they can learn this quickly. 16:32 They can, uh, they can, like, do it as an apprenticeship, and they can add value to the organization. Uh, but then they don't have to commit to, to nine years 'cause I don't think they're looking for that. 16:41 Uh, so that's really the interesting kind of aspect I think. 16:44 Uh, and, and that's really what, when I saw the 300,000 people were part of the IT army of the Ukraine, like I'm assuming that most of those people are not actually part of the Ukrainian army, but they're very interested in their problems. 16:55 So how do you allow people that are very interested in the protection of Western countries and, and their defense, uh, that wanna get involved in this, but they wanna do it in more of an ad hoc and flexible way? 17:06 And I think that's gonna be some of the big issues that, uh, people are looking at as we go forward here. Uh, Rupert, Rupert, what's your thoughts on that? 17:13 Yeah, no, and I think the, um, I think that's so right, isn't it? You know, there's 300,000. 17:18 They're not, they're not all using, uh, information, digital tools in a kind of offensive manner against their invader, but they're all contributing to the fight in some way, even if that is only by, um, sharing the narrative, inspiring the defense, you know, drawing in public support in, in other nations s- so we double down on sanctions or whatever it might be. 17:43 And a- again, if I can draw on a kind of counter-ISIS, um, uh, analogies, which, which we, it was a very impressive, it was called the Global Coalition, and there were kind of about 80 nations and organizations part of it. 17:56 Pretty, pretty impressive. And the, the, the communications plan was very much run at, at global level. 18:05 And, and the trick there was not for governments to communicate, you know, and spout forth, you know, what can appear to be propaganda. The trick was to work much more subtly And to try and get, 18:19 forgive the, the analogy, but, you know, a, a, a young teenager, boy or girl, you know, somewhere in the Middle East, to reject ISIS's vile ideology and promote the voices of tolerance and moderation. 18:35 And when you begin to get that running, that's Caleb's insurgency. That, you know, that's powerful. A- and, you know, they, they then begin to turn the information campaign rather than big institutions, nations doing it. 18:47 And I, I think, you know, a lot of those 300,000 that Caleb is talking about, th- they're, they're those people. 18:53 They're the ones who are kind of, who are generating that, that, that noise that's so, so important to get the world's attention. I think that's- Yeah... what goes viral, right? 19:03 And, uh, and this, and this is where social media really kicks in. Do you think, um, I'll just come over to you in, in one second, Caleb. 19:11 Do you think this has been underestimated for what we're seeing currently with the Ukraine crisis? I don't know. 19:17 I mean, I think, you know, we, we've had a few times where people say, "This is the first time we've had a war by social media." And of course, you know, w- we've been having wars by social media for quite a long time. 19:28 Um, uh, we've either been paying attention or we've not been paying attention, and because this one's, you know, feels, feels a bit more Western, more of us are, are paying attention. 19:37 But, but, but equally, each time you get one of these kind of awful conflicts, it gets a bit more, uh, digital i- in its nature. 19:47 And it's probably fair to say that the Ukrainian population are a bit more savvy at the digital skills than perhaps the Iraqi population was in 2016, 2017. 19:57 I'm, I may or may not be right, right about that, but it feels as though they are. So I think it, with each of these conflicts, you know, the, the, the sophistication of some of this social media work improves. 20:09 You know, some, some of the... You, you'll have all seen it, you know, some of the, some of the stuff on TikTok and things. You know, it's really very clever. It's very subtle. 20:18 A- and some of it, of course, what it's doing is laughing at the Russians, and there's nothing that Putin hates more than to be mocked and to be humiliated. 20:28 And when he's being mocked and humiliated by, you know, a young, a young woman, you know, in her 20s, you know, all dolled up, making a fool, fool of him and the Russians by giving a little de- TikTok demonstration about how to start up a Russian armored vehicle. 20:45 You know? Videos like that are incredibly powerful because they amuse, they inspire, um, but to us and to the adversary, they, they, they humiliate and, and that's very powerful. Yeah, powerful tool, dangerous tool. 21:01 Caleb, over to you. 21:03 Well, I, I just, yeah, I love the, uh, where the conversation's going here is it's, I, I guess they call them influencers, but, like, the, the key thing is to understand, um, that, like, it, it's a difference, it makes it a more, um, uh, accessible, like, the con- like, the, uh, for everyone out there, when they can see people like their peers or people that they're, uh, um, uh, friends, family, uh, engaging in this, and it makes it easier for them to think, "I can engage in this." 21:31 It's one thing to have, like, a, you know, like, a special forces person with a black balaclava. Like, some people are like, "Whoa, like, I, I don't think I could ever do that." 21:39 But if they can see, in the conversation and the example that, uh, Mr Jones has provided there, like, that, that's, uh, that's where everyone's like, "Yeah, I could do that. I could jump in." 21:47 And so everyone wants to be part of that, uh, easier. Uh, so it's, it's... 21:51 I'm definitely not doing it justice on, like, the right, uh, like, uh, social media campaign and, and what they're, some people are really thinking about to, to mobilize a workforce. 22:00 But, uh, but sometimes I think that realistically in, in the military, we're not, we don't think change management very well, uh, 'cause we just do command and control, and that's, we just expect people to do as, as we're, we're told. 22:14 But, uh, when you really start, uh, digging into it, there's some change management, there's some influencing, there's communications plan that are going on right now that is gonna be very important w- on, on, uh, on th- today's conflict, but in future conflicts as well. 22:28 Uh, it's, uh, h- you know, how do you change people's opinion and, and, and get, and grow, and grow an army while a war is going on? And I think that's what, uh, you've seen some people do quite well i- in Ukraine. 22:40 I think so. I think, um, you know, in terms of training and, and, and careers, it's, we're seeing everything kinda move to a transitionary, transitionary remote, uh, uh, learning opportunity. 22:53 And, uh, on the private sector too, there's a paradigm shift that employers need to, to make to get that, um, in, in, in order to really build the right, uh, type of people for their company, and to have attractive options. 23:06 I mean, right now the workforce, it's, it's hard to get good people. So, uh, [lips smack] uh, final comments, Mr Jones, uh, on the digital divide, if we could, and then I'll ask Caleb to weigh in. 23:18 Yeah, I think the, the, uh, the last point I'll make probably links to some degree with Caleb's last point, which is, you know, so we talk about the need for an insurgence here, insurgency here, the degree, the, the fact that, you know, it needs to be bottom up. 23:31 It needs everybody playing a, playing a role. I think we also need to recognize that big bureaucracies, and particularly big public sector bureaucracies, defense in, in our case, struggle with this. 23:44 So in the United Kingdom, you know, we've got a plan for a defense digitization, uh, d- defense transformation, we got a digital strategy, we got all the building blocks, but this is deeply counter-cultural, and there are huge impediments to, uh, digitally transfor- transforming even a military the size of the British Armed Forces or indeed the Canadian Armed Forces, you know, which of course are a fraction the size of our, our American friends, for example. 24:09 Um, but, but th- these are really difficult things for, for defenses to do, uh, and they're gonna need all of our help. Caleb, your final thoughts? 24:22 No, it's, uh, we just, everyone doesn't think that maybe they can, uh, really change the, the direction of the massive ship, uh, mid-course, but, uh, I think, uh, as more and more people take ownership of this, uh, problem at all the layers, then hopefully that, uh, uh, then whoever the captain is of the ship, they'll, they'll work out that they probably need to change course. 24:41 So, uh, for everyone out there that's doing a great job as part of, like, the, uh, digital transformation at, at, at, uh, it is important. Uh, don't lose hope and, uh, and keep driving it into the insurgency. 24:52 You've been listening to Vanguard Weekly. I wanna thank our very special guests this morning, Major General Rupert Jones and Caleb Walker from With You With Me, country manager. Gentlemen, thank you so much. Thank you. 25:07 [outro music] The views, information, or opinions expressed during the Vanguard Weekly Podcast Series, CGE Weekly Podcast Series, Vanguard Radio Podcast, and CGE Radio Podcast are solely those of the individuals involved and do not represent those of Vanguard or any affiliated media products, their employees or owners. 25:34 Vanguard Magazine, Canadian Government Executive Magazine, and its affiliates are not responsible for and do not verify for accuracy any of the information contained in this podcast series. 25:45 This podcast may not be copied or distributed without express written approval of Promotive Communications Inc, PCI. You may not edit, modify, or redistribute this podcast without consent from PCI. 25:56 PCI assumes no liability for activities in connection with this podcast or for use of this podcast with any other website, computer, or playing device.